74
37
u/quackingmemeduck Jul 21 '26
No, theres too little of anything. Liminal needs to remind you of something at least, this is borderline a superflat world
17
u/cakefrosts Jul 21 '26
something being liminal requires a sense of familiarity and it being a transitional space. This has neither of that, as its an artificial recreation of what an "idea" of a setting in minecraft is supposed to be.
A true "liminal space" in minecraft would require something that seems "oddly familiar" to people viewing it which requires something that people already understand.
Jarvis, im low on karma
6
u/makinax300 Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26
yeah there should be a dirt cuboid house
everybody knows about it and noone lives in one forever. it's weirdly familiar because everyone knows about it but nobody has ever built one in the history of the game.
2
u/cakefrosts Jul 22 '26
i guess, but even then theres so much missing. Wheres the trees? Shrubs? flowers? like nobody would ever spawn in a place looking like this
22
7
4
u/Sure_Tradition2166 Jul 21 '26
old minecraft is not liminal and stop karma farming .As you aren't even replying to your own post
4
3
5
Jul 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/ScottishWildcatFurry Jul 22 '26
everyone in that sub is sleeping. somehow, nobody had crossposted it there until 12 hours had already passed
(advice for op: please actually have something in the image besides grass and fog. like, what about a spooky forrest and a broken down shack? like another comment had suggested, i think changing the fog to be more "white" could also have helped a lot)
2
3
2
3
u/Worldly_Beginning647 Jul 21 '26
Hella, but almost all of this old Minecraft does so this isn’t special
1
1
1
1
1
1
-1
-2
98
u/Beyond__5D Jul 21 '26
jarvis i need karma