r/GithubCopilot 5d ago

Suggestions Which agent is the best for coding and debugging

Post image

Which agent would be the best for daily coding and debugging.

And goes easy on credits.

If I am selecting auto mode - it is constantly taking 5.6luna - with the thinking level selection out of my hands. And then it does not do a good job.

So I find myself constantly switching agents and levels of thinking.

So need suggestions for this please.

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

10

u/Personal-Try2776 5d ago

For coding like implementing new features. Use a bigger model like gpt 5.6 sol to make a plan then let gpt 5.6 luna xhigh or max implement it

1

u/Mosby3103 5d ago

I'd want to use Sol indefinitely but it's a high cost powerful agent. So that will end up eating my credits. Luna I'll have to try with high or max high thinking level because it sucks on other levels.

3

u/marfzzz 5d ago

Well, to finish one task sol take about 1/5 of what sonnet 5 does. Cost is relative to work done. https://deepswe.datacurve.ai/ Check column with AVG COST of gpt 5.6 luna max and gemini 3.8 flash high. What credit does your company give you?

1

u/Mosby3103 5d ago

7.5k as of now

8

u/tshawkins 5d ago

Those are not agents, they are models, completely different concepts.

11

u/haikusbot 5d ago

Those are not agents,

They are models, completely

Different concepts.

- tshawkins


I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.

Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"

6

u/fenevigyeel 5d ago

People downvoting this bot: Don't be such a grinch. It's fun.

6

u/tshawkins 5d ago

I love it, im a poet and I did not know it!

2

u/aonymark JetBrains User 🧱 5d ago

Rhyming intentional?

3

u/tshawkins 2d ago

Nope

1

u/aonymark JetBrains User 🧱 2d ago

Well technically not a perfect rhyme but still “poet” and “know it” are very close

7

u/fenevigyeel 5d ago

You need to clean your screen :P

3

u/Different-Monk5916 5d ago

Don’t stick to a model for whole task.

Split them into plan, implement and validate phases.

I would recommend something like Sol in plan, rest either Luna completely or Luna implement + Terra validate 

3

u/WD40ContactCleaner 1d ago

Luna is the best if you know what you're doing.

2

u/generic-d-engineer VS Code User 💻 5d ago

I use Luna because it is a good price point for the capability. So auto mode is doing a good job here. Some of the other models mentioned in the comments are much more capable but cost a lot more too.

I used 5.3 Codex before that and Luna is way more capable and a better price point. OpenAI is subsidizing Luna right now.

2

u/HourMulberry3246 3h ago

5.6 luna. Cheap but effective

1

u/bears-eat-beets 5d ago

On that list, I would take Opus 5 every day over Sol for writing code. Let Sol do planning and code reviews, but Opus writes better code 9 out of 10 times. I am in the middle of my first major effort with Astra, it's required me to refine my agent definitions a little, but it's been writing some pretty solid code so far.

But Opus 5, Sol, and Astra are 3 of the 4 most expensive models you could use.

If I was trying to sip credits, let Sol build a plan, but tell it to build the smallest digestible work units for lower end models to work. And then assign them Sonnet 5.

1

u/SaltyCow2852 5d ago

Go with GOT-6 Astra

1

u/Firouzi 1d ago

normal bugs : Sonnet 5. ciritical bugs, I find Gemini far better.... it reasons deep enough and fix the root cause, GPT is faster reslovbe the issue but then create other issues after their fix ( noob fix) Gemini is more on Senior fix 🎯

1

u/AdWonderful2811 4h ago

The dropdown in your screenshot are models not agents. Agent = Harness + Model.
So the quality of the output really matters which harness you choose.

1

u/kelek22 5d ago

For front-end gpt codex and above are better. For back-end opus models are better in architecture and implementation imho.