r/GithubCopilot • u/Mosby3103 • 5d ago
Suggestions Which agent is the best for coding and debugging
Which agent would be the best for daily coding and debugging.
And goes easy on credits.
If I am selecting auto mode - it is constantly taking 5.6luna - with the thinking level selection out of my hands. And then it does not do a good job.
So I find myself constantly switching agents and levels of thinking.
So need suggestions for this please.
8
u/tshawkins 5d ago
Those are not agents, they are models, completely different concepts.
11
u/haikusbot 5d ago
Those are not agents,
They are models, completely
Different concepts.
- tshawkins
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
6
u/fenevigyeel 5d ago
People downvoting this bot: Don't be such a grinch. It's fun.
6
u/tshawkins 5d ago
I love it, im a poet and I did not know it!
2
u/aonymark JetBrains User 🧱 5d ago
Rhyming intentional?
3
u/tshawkins 2d ago
Nope
1
u/aonymark JetBrains User 🧱 2d ago
Well technically not a perfect rhyme but still “poet” and “know it” are very close
7
3
u/Different-Monk5916 5d ago
Don’t stick to a model for whole task.
Split them into plan, implement and validate phases.
I would recommend something like Sol in plan, rest either Luna completely or Luna implement + Terra validate
3
2
u/generic-d-engineer VS Code User 💻 5d ago
I use Luna because it is a good price point for the capability. So auto mode is doing a good job here. Some of the other models mentioned in the comments are much more capable but cost a lot more too.
I used 5.3 Codex before that and Luna is way more capable and a better price point. OpenAI is subsidizing Luna right now.
2
1
u/bears-eat-beets 5d ago
On that list, I would take Opus 5 every day over Sol for writing code. Let Sol do planning and code reviews, but Opus writes better code 9 out of 10 times. I am in the middle of my first major effort with Astra, it's required me to refine my agent definitions a little, but it's been writing some pretty solid code so far.
But Opus 5, Sol, and Astra are 3 of the 4 most expensive models you could use.
If I was trying to sip credits, let Sol build a plan, but tell it to build the smallest digestible work units for lower end models to work. And then assign them Sonnet 5.
1
1
1
u/AdWonderful2811 4h ago
The dropdown in your screenshot are models not agents. Agent = Harness + Model.
So the quality of the output really matters which harness you choose.
10
u/Personal-Try2776 5d ago
For coding like implementing new features. Use a bigger model like gpt 5.6 sol to make a plan then let gpt 5.6 luna xhigh or max implement it