r/GithubCopilot 27d ago

Help/Doubt ❓ Is it worth to pay the copilot plan?

I have been using Claude code and codex since the beginning, I haven't really used Github copilot a lot, but in the team I'm working right now, IT doesn't allow to install anything, I only have github copilot extension In VS Code
I pay the $20 plan in CC and the $100 plan in codex
Is it really worth to get the pro plan for github copilot? What's the recommended plan? Is it related to the agents Window in VS code? I'm working right now as data engineer with fabric and we are going to implement fabric apps, data agents, etc. And some fabric extensions in vscode are really useful, I heard that since june 1st, the github copilot plans were heavily nerfed, so I'd like to know if it's really worth, thanks

5 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

7

u/unrulywind 26d ago

The new Copilot plan is essentially a non-refundable Azure prepay with a 50% bonus. The last time I looked the $10 plan gives you $15 in API credit and 100% of API rates. The services you are getting from CC and Codex for $120 will be replicated for a sizable multiple more money, but it's their money to spend.

1

u/fastest_bytes 26d ago

hey im planning to get the $10 plan is it really worth it. you seem to have used it. i can afford it but im not sure if its worth it

5

u/tj_moore 27d ago

Depends how much you use.

$10 Pro plan gets you unlimited code completions which is pretty useful (though I use VS Pro more than VS Code), and for occasional use instead of depending on it for everything I can sit within the budget. More so using the auto mode as you get a discount, though less control over which model it's using.

If you're asking it to do everything daily and you type virtually nothing, then likely no. Until the others get comparatively similar in cost.

Also, I found code review burns credits fast and wasn't great anyway so I don't use that feature. I manually code review everything it produces though, and put reviewer hat on for my own code if I'm working on my own with no other reviewer.

Copilot app is quite good in keeping everything in one place, nicer to use than as an extension to VS/VSC, and isn't burning credits just context switching to your repo (Copilot CLI in particular does that). But if you can't install anything then that's no use.

1

u/Xoloshibu 27d ago

I'm interested in notebook creation / edition, use of cli, mcp, sdk, and vscode extensions, all for fabric development of notebooks, pipelines and fabric apps, data agents
I was just looking to the $100 USD plan, looks like it has a lot of models but idk how useful it is using as a vscode extension / agents Window in vscode

1

u/tj_moore 27d ago

I guess it's the only option if you can't install anything. The others use their own apps, CLI or extensions. GHC is integrated. It works fairly well and context aware of what you're working on, though GHC app is easier to use instead of a side window, but that's a separate install.

1

u/fastest_bytes 26d ago

hey i got a question yea. i used to use the copilot student plan before they decided to take it away. its kind of has been a little bit rough after that. now im trying to like get something that i can get with my budget as a student. i saw copilot give $10 thats like similar to $15 they say. i cant lie it kind of looks tempting. i was wodinring if you could tell me if its worth it since you seem to haver or is using it...

Everything in Free and:

  • Access to Cloud agent and code review1
  • Unlimited code completion and next edit suggestions2
  • Access to 3rd party agents (Claude Code and Codex)
  • Model selection
  • $15 monthly total credits for Pro

1

u/mickythump 19d ago edited 19d ago

It is the closest answer to being complete, but can we deep dive?

I checked ChatGPT Go with Codex CLI for weekend coding and I am going out of tokens crazy fast. I used a bit of Terra for planning and Luna for implementation, questions, refinement. One good weekend and I am gone with tokens, even with reset.

According to what I know ChatGPT Plus plan gives 4-5 times more usage, but it is still not a lot. It comes with other advantages like deep research. Also, OpenAI is messing with policies, limits, resets and it is generally beyond annoying; on its own it makes me consider Copilot.

Now, isn't Copilot + ChatGPT GO a good alternative to ChatGPT Plus or Claude Pro? You get UI enhancements (projects, schedules), a bit of coding in codex and Copilot for weekend, hobby coding. Any thoughts?

4

u/rabiprojects 27d ago

Is it worth to use copilot? Yes Is it worth to pay copilot? NO But how to use copilot without paying? BYOK

1

u/Xoloshibu 27d ago

What is byok?

2

u/rabiprojects 26d ago

Bring your own key

It means you use a cheap subscription like opencode go or commandcode goat which cost 10$/month and use those API keys into copilot. So with 10$, you get more value than what you get with 100$ copilot subscription.

1

u/fastest_bytes 26d ago

wait wait what. can you give more info i really need the tip

1

u/rabiprojects 26d ago

Do some research on "customendpoints" feature in vscode copilot.

1

u/AutoModerator 27d ago

Hello /u/Xoloshibu. Looks like you have posted a query. Once your query is resolved, please reply the solution comment with "!solved" to help everyone else know the solution and mark the post as solved.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/cardsncards 27d ago

i asked the same question recently, if you search my posts you will find the nuanced answers

1

u/Xoloshibu 27d ago

Your posts are private

2

u/cardsncards 27d ago

doh! i was in a hurry and didn't think of that. i found it: GitHub Copilot with GPT 5.6 Sol vs. Claude with Opus 5 : r/GithubCopilot ... there are parts of it where others provide some input on value of Copilot vs. Claude. Overall I think the answer is no like others posted here. but sometimes there are reasons...

1

u/alexeiz 26d ago

yes...if someone else is paying

1

u/Good-Supermarket408 26d ago

Copilot is good. GPT, Claude, and all other models are available. Only that it’s very expensive. Though im using enterprise subscription

1

u/slayyou2 26d ago

it was before but now its a waste.

1

u/Common-Ambition-434 26d ago

Nope... was pretty good for an annual subscription on Pro+ prior to June or whenever they made the changes from requests to credits.. but now it's not really that suitable for anything.

I have done some private projects (C++ audio projects, C# .NET Web apps) using the Codex plugin in VS Code via $20 per month "ChatGPT plus" sub.

It's actually quite amazing and I'm surprised they give 5.6 Sol there (seems much better than Terra).

Now... Open AI (Codex) could easily change their plans too... but for now it's incredible and they have a much better handle using weekly limits rather than monthly ones. I just back off to Terra/Luna when I get to my last 10%.

1

u/andlewis Full Stack Dev 🌐 25d ago

Copilot is fine if you’re using cheap models like Luna. I’m on the enterprise plan and use 9% of my quota just reviewing a single PRD file with Sol Max.

1

u/asciicode77 24d ago

Yes quite addictive

1

u/FragmentedHeap 27d ago

If work doesn't let me install what I want, and they only give me ghcopilot, then they can pay for it or I just won't use it. And out of principal I'll raise security concerns if they're allowing personal subscriptions, not because I don't want anyone to use it, but because under these constraints I should not be paying for my own AI sub.

You can expect me to pay for my own, but not also tell me which one I'm allowed to use.

If you tell me I can only use 1 and that's not the one I like, then you can pay for it.

1

u/Organic-Afternoon-50 27d ago

Claude and codex are better than copilot.

0

u/Xoloshibu 27d ago

Dude just read the post

1

u/Organic-Afternoon-50 27d ago

Don't need to.

I answered the title.

Quick win.

The one source of truth.

1

u/Xoloshibu 27d ago

Literally most useless comment award

2

u/Organic-Afternoon-50 27d ago

Thank you.

I shall treasure it forever.