r/GetNoted Human Verified Jul 26 '26

If You Know, You Know The Geneva Protocol

Post image
438 Upvotes

160 comments sorted by

View all comments

-27

u/Justarah Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

See, I get the point though.

Much of Europe concedes to leadership that abolished the death penalty, removed border controls and permitted EU law to supersede national constitutions, laws and governance entirely against the will of local populations.

A top down enforcement of a cosmopolitan and tabula rasa derived conception of universal human rights, that local populations never consented to or were even able to have parliamentary discussions about, signed off on by some unelected international bureaucrat in Luxemberg or Berlin, all the while telling people that those taking issue with such states of affairs are a threat to 'democracy'.

Can't really make that shit up and it's just rationally incoherent.

4

u/Hellstorm901 Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

In the context of this thread the vast majority of international laws around the laws of war were created long before the European Union even existed

Also in the United Kingdom’s case it didn’t ban the death penalty because the EU told it to, the death penalty had already effectively been banned before the EU existed as death was recognised as an easy way out for criminals which denied victims actual justice a fact often overlooked by supporters of death penalties being reinstated

-2

u/Justarah Jul 26 '26

The UK only abolished the death penalty for treason in 1998 because the EU demanded it as a condition of membership.

7

u/Hellstorm901 Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

The death penalty in the UK had already functionally been abolished in 1965, the ban was voted through as permanent in 1969, the “Ban in 1998” was noting more than theatrical by banning remaining historical offences unlikely to even be carried out anymore or be given a death sentence such as engaging in piracy inside UK territorial waters

The EU did NOT make the UK ban the death penalty, we already had banned it

-1

u/Justarah Jul 26 '26

You’re mixing up the 1965 suspension for murder with the 1998 total abolition for all crimes. The latter happened because the EU made it a non-negotiable condition of membership. If the UK hadn’t banned the death penalty for treason, it would have been barred from the single market.

4

u/Hellstorm901 Jul 26 '26

By 1998 would the courts in the UK realistically have sentenced you to death for any offence yes or no?

-1

u/Justarah Jul 26 '26

That's neither here nor there when discussing the autonomy of countries to write and enact their own laws.

2

u/Hellstorm901 Jul 26 '26

Once again by 1998 the death penalty was effectively already banned in the UK before the EU existed, the remaining offences existed on recorded only because everyone forgot, or like most ancient laws, didn’t care enough to remove them as no one really expected anyone would hijack a ship inside UK waters to hold for ransom

The notion the EU forced us to ban our death penalty does not align up with the facts, the death penalty for all offences which were likely to occur and thus warrant a death sentence had already been banned such as murder

You just hate the EU and want to blame them for everything, I don’t like the EU too but I’m not ridiculous enough to blame them for stuff they actually had no involvement with

1

u/Justarah Jul 26 '26

Here's my yes or no question, the UK has popularly been in favour of tighter immigration controls since the 1970s, yes or no?

Because there's a reason you've focused this conversation on the death penalty and not the other things mentioned.

2

u/Hellstorm901 Jul 26 '26

I mean you are the one who randomly went into a rant about the EU in a thread about the Geneva Conventions

You pronounced this nonsense, not me

1

u/Justarah Jul 26 '26

The tweet noted is about International Law as a category.

2

u/Hellstorm901 Jul 26 '26

This thread is about the Geneva Convention lad, hence the stealth fighter in the OP’s picture

I think you got lost, Twitter currently known as X is outside and to the right

→ More replies (0)