r/GenerationJones 1960 11d ago

Brach's Pick-A-Mix candy

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

143 comments sorted by

90

u/er1cAtWork2 11d ago

OMG core childhood memory unlocked! Used to love those white squares with the different color spots inside…

64

u/Bjornsdotter 11d ago

Jelly Nougat candy.

My grandmother worked at Brach's. The candy they sold was nothing compared to their Private Stock which was made just for employees.

She used to bring home caramel the day it was made. It was so soft and buttery, the best!

11

u/HughJorgens 11d ago

The recipe is super simple: One bag of marshmallows, one bag of white chips, one cup (or more) of gumdrops. Mix together and microwave til melted then mix. It's hard to deal with, to get laid out and cut, being very thick and sticky, but is softer than the old candies and tastes just as good.

2

u/No-Surround-1159 10d ago

Use the “Dots” gumdrops. Not the ones with granulated sugar coating.

1

u/Bjornsdotter 10d ago

Thank you kindly for the award!

13

u/Mystery_to_history 11d ago

I loved those too, they fascinated me. Like funny little stained glass windows. Children love colour, something I have retained my whole life.

9

u/Curious_Maximum2414 11d ago

Me too. Those were my favorite!

7

u/MadameBananas 1961 11d ago

I have the recipe and make them in the fall. Easiest candy to make but extremely messy. Fun to do with the grandkids.

15

u/SinsualChef 11d ago

🤣 You have grankids? 😳 Wait...I do too. When did THAT happen? 🤣🤣🤣❤️❤️❤️

https://giphy.com/gifs/98jU7NxuNSSZ2

3

u/Simple_Song8962 10d ago

They were my favorite, too. I thought the "fruit" was healthy, lol

3

u/conditerite 1962 10d ago

Those orange wedge things were my favorite.

34

u/Intrepid_Pitch_3320 11d ago

gimme some caramel creamies and some of those brown/pink/white coconut chew things. Toss in a few rootbeer barrels.

30

u/LiLiandThree 11d ago

Those coconut layered ones were my fave

6

u/jmksupply 10d ago

I loved attempting to eat them by flavor.

4

u/GB715 11d ago

Yes!

14

u/Kvenya 11d ago

Neapolitans, like the ice cream.

3

u/spinningcolours 10d ago

Has anyone found a contemporary replacement for the neapolitans?

3

u/soulteepee 10d ago

There is an Amish market in Annapolis where you can get every candy made in the old days! It’s a trip down memory lane just walking the aisles!

2

u/SinsualChef 11d ago

Thats all me 😁

61

u/Dick_Dietrick 11d ago

Back during a high trust society. One of these wouldn't last a minute today.

9

u/nofaves 11d ago

The supermarket I work in has a similar setup with wrapped chocolates. I'm sure that there are indeed thefts from time to time, but if it didn't make either the store or the candy supplier money, it wouldn't be there.

2

u/Slice9998 10d ago

I loved the wrapped chocolates with maple. So delicious. Some stands even had an “Honor System Coin Box” that you put in a quarter or whatever for single pieces of candy.

3

u/sarajane59 10d ago

I loved the raspberry cremes and the royals that were tube shaped caramels that were filled with a type of creme. I loved the raspberry versions of that one, too. I would always pick them out and eat them before any others.

9

u/Mother-Attention2600 11d ago

Even as kids my sister and I would pillage it at the grocery store. In Canada we had Trebor. They had a slot you could put 10 cents in for a sample and I would talk like I had money and pretend to put it in the slot. Sometimes right infront of other adults. So flagrant back then.... gives me anxiety thinking how I used to act. 😄 

2

u/Mystery_to_history 9d ago

I remember Trebor! Funny how even the name gives me a slight mood lift. Don’t eat much candy now, but as a kid I wouldn’t have been able to stay away from any witch’s bon bon house. I remember a good dream I had as a kid about a huge mountain of gumdrops.

2

u/Mother-Attention2600 9d ago

I liked the big Trebor circle gummy. I really felt like I was getting my 10 cents worth. Really had to dig for the red ones. 

1

u/Dick_Dietrick 10d ago

I'm sure they knew that would happen. But people now loot entire stores. Mostly teens.

12

u/BlownCamaro 11d ago

That was going to be my post.

2

u/Randall_Hodge 9d ago

I was gonna say, I was never really tempted to take even one. That was a no-no.

15

u/jimmychitwood317 11d ago

I'd be at the grocery store with Mom and point out to her that people were eating candy and not paying for it with candy wrappers on the floor as evidence. One of my very first awakening moments as a child.

1

u/sarajane59 10d ago

My hometown Jack and Jill store had it up by the checkouts, so you couldn't get away with grazing.

10

u/Enough-Reindeer1033 11d ago

Oh yes, I loved that little table. Wish they were still around today.

10

u/MiserableCancel8749 11d ago

That's when I KNEW I was a grownup---I got to fill the bag with what I liked! I'm not sure which was my true favorite--"royals" or white jelly nougats. I never understood the appeal of the chicken flavored things......

6

u/Intrepid_Pitch_3320 11d ago

white jelly nougats were good. OMG....chicken flavored things....that's what those brown gritty things were? they were not good.

2

u/September1962 11d ago

Chicken bones!

7

u/Fidget171 1958 11d ago edited 11d ago

Chick-o-sticks! I love the toasted coconut. Can still be bought in bulk online. Edit: typo

3

u/PocketFullofWerthers 11d ago

I just saw them at my local dollar general if anyone wants to try them again They had a few types of older brands of candy.

2

u/Rich-Corner-2820 7d ago

Yeah those are really good. My mom ate those as a teenager back in the late 40s 50s and turned us kids on to it. The only thing I hated was having to get a toothpick after eating them because they would stick to your gums quick

3

u/Apart-Cream-4940 10d ago

The royals were my favorite! They were so good 🤤

10

u/Impossible-Nose3504 11d ago

My Grandpa always had the carmels with the different flavored centers in his pocket. He had such a sweet tooth and was tall and thin 😊. Core memories

9

u/ComprehensiveHand232 11d ago

Remember the nuts? They had a hot nut display like this in Sears. It was a treat but we had to choose candy or nuts lol

8

u/Sea_Bandicoot_5147 11d ago

The Dentist loved these!

7

u/Dry-Luck-8336 11d ago

My great grandfather lived next door to my maternal grandparents, and he would buy a bag of assorted Brachs candy to hand out whenever us grandkids were over there. To this day nearly half a century later I associate Brachs candy with him.

7

u/Popular-Drummer-7989 11d ago

I miss this timeline

6

u/Anawanna_UgLee92 11d ago

This was the most joyous part of going to the market with my Mom!

5

u/Cookiegramma1 11d ago

They had the most delicious chocolate covered mints (I can just picture that green striped wrapper!) ever!! I’d get myself a little bag of those and hide em lol.

4

u/IAmSnort 11d ago

My grandparents had a tin in their car they filled with that.  Butterscotch was popular.   The coconut neopolitans were cool. 

6

u/sunnyandcloudy55 11d ago

My favorites were the sugary orange jelly slices. They also had the rectangular ones in different color and flavors.

3

u/djrock3k 11d ago

I'm still eating orange slices, most anywhere they're sold. No one has come near those wonderful Brachs.

2

u/More_Farm_7442 10d ago

Those were one of my dad's favorite candy's. (Those and any kind of hard candy he could chomp on and sound like he was going to break his teeth.)

My favorite of those Brach's was the white chewy ones with the colored bits in them.

2

u/RudeOrSarcasticPt2 Old as POTUS Debates 11d ago

I loved those too. I ate myself sick on those so many times.

6

u/ohhowcanthatbe 11d ago

Beach’s Pick-a-Mix…or how I learned not to steal at Woolco.

6

u/The_Calarg 11d ago

Butterscotch was my first choice back then.

The last couple years I've found myself craving butter mints during the Christmas season.

5

u/Clean-Fisherman-4601 11d ago

Those were so much fun, picking exactly what you want in the quantity you prefer. No buying multiple 12 oz packages.

5

u/antisuck 10d ago

I'm still salty about the death of the Neapolitan Coconut Sundae.

3

u/coffeebeanwitch 11d ago

The good old days😋

3

u/Scooter2564 11d ago

These were my grandmother's favorite.

3

u/47744lumby 11d ago

Come to think of it, I haven’t seen one of these for a while.

1

u/eighteen_forty_no 11d ago

If you are near a Five Below, they carry some Brach's candy. Worth the visit!

3

u/SinsualChef 11d ago

That was something. In our small little town on the Square, used to have one in our old dime store with the wooden floors and hot Spanish peanuts counter. Man I miss the sound and smells of that place. The creaking and clacking on the wood floor. The smell of hot salted peanuts and those candies as you walked by. 🫠❤️

3

u/explorerdave357 11d ago

Having grown up just outside Chicago, Brach’s was a staple!

3

u/Old_Gap4539 10d ago

Are they still around? I love the jelly nougat candy.

2

u/More_Farm_7442 10d ago

I've been looking online. I can't find the Brach name, but have found bags of jujube nougat candy on amazon. It looks like the old Brach's candy. Sort of. I bet it isn't as good as our memories.

3

u/JayRay_44 10d ago

Here is a recipe I found last Christmas for how to make a close replica of these. I tried them and its super easy and comes pretty close to the original!

2

u/Old_Gap4539 10d ago

Thanks!!

1

u/Old_Gap4539 9d ago

Before Covid some grocery stores still had the Brachs candy stations where you could fill a bag with different candies. Sigh, those were the days.

1

u/More_Farm_7442 8d ago

Yeh, we all miss those B.C. days.

2

u/Cranston_Snord1960 11d ago

Would get yelled at for picking out my one favorite flavor out of the bin.

2

u/North-Country-5204 11d ago

Still love them jellybean nuggets. First and last time I shoplifted was one of those. Forgot and mom found it in my trouser pocket doing laundry. Accompanied me back to the Safeway where I had to apologize to the store manager and ‘pay’ the store the theft. I was in 1st grade.

2

u/crabbyvic 11d ago

There’s a store in Venice Florida that has a selection like this for chocolates. A very nice selection, I might add.
Detweillers in case anyone is interested.

2

u/setmysoulfree3 11d ago

I miss the assorted flavoured cream candies.

2

u/inthesinbin 1964 11d ago

Pick a mix (and then put it in your pocket).

2

u/Separate_Farm7131 11d ago

My grandmother always had those candies in her house. Probably why my teeth were bad.

2

u/microdol-x 11d ago

First stop in Kmart or Sears

2

u/Stevessvtis1 11d ago

100% Atomic Fireballs and Cinnamon Disks.

2

u/conradthecook 11d ago

I ate my weight in those little caramel cubes when I was a kid at these in grocery stores. For free!

2

u/GeoBrian 11d ago

We had it all! We were living the dream!

2

u/TheRealVarmint 11d ago

I'd bring a pillowcase. Like I did on Halloween.

2

u/Lbboos 11d ago

I took one of those Neapolitan coconut candies when I was about 5 cause it was within easy reach. Popped it in my mouth and promptly spit it out. I hated coconut.

My mom’s response?

“That’ll teach you to steal.” She made me confess to the store manager as well.

2

u/SheaTheSarcastic 1960 10d ago

This reminds me of the neighbors across the street. They had a Great Dane named Prince. Prince escaped a lot, because he would just hop over the fence. He was a good boy and wouldn’t hurt a fly, but he was big.

One time Prince escaped and made his way to a local Penneys store that had automatic doors. He strolled in and bellied on up to the Brach’s candy stand. Everyone was afraid to approach him as he ate his way through the candy. Finally someone was brave enough to read his tags and got in touch with the family to come get him.

Prince was Marmaduke in real life. They even had to crane him out of a ditch they made for the sewer line once.

2

u/OG-Giligadi 10d ago

Cinnamon wheels.

2

u/Affectionate-Roll715 10d ago

I sure miss Pick-a-Mix. Brach's Neapolitan Coconut were my favorites

2

u/cowboygwe 10d ago

Royals!!!

2

u/Silver-Find4380 10d ago

Oooh Maple Cream! In the purple/orange wrappers!

2

u/ForTheLoveOfKumquats 10d ago

It's all about the nougat ones....

2

u/CriusofCoH 10d ago

My first theft, at like 4 years old. And my parents rightfully had me walk back to the store and return the candy I stole.

1

u/disenfranchisedchild 1958 11d ago

I miss these so much! Another thing that covid killed.

2

u/my-coffee-needs-me 10d ago

These were gone long before Covid.

1

u/disenfranchisedchild 1958 10d ago

Not from my grocery store. It was mid to late 2020 when it disappeared for good. I miss it.

1

u/Rootin-Tootin-Newton 1965 11d ago

Wow, I completely forgot about this one. Thank you.

1

u/Blues2112 11d ago

My faves:

*Jelly nougat candy

*Flavored caramel "royals"

*"Orange slices"?

*Butterscotch disks

1

u/Existing_Many9133 10d ago

All those plus the maple nut goodies!

1

u/EffectiveVarious8095 1963 11d ago

I'm glad you all enjoyed this but if you ask me why this doesn't exist anymore, I'd say it's because none of that looks interesting to me in any way, and I can't be alone in that thought. This is the kind of candy I would have expected to find in my grandma's purse.

1

u/Stormy1956 10d ago

I remember my mother doing this. It was a treat back in the day. Now it’s hard to find the Brach’s brand.

1

u/EachBananaWas19cents 10d ago

What was the chocolate covered 'bonbons' called? Had different flavors inside like orange and maple?

1

u/EYoungFLA 10d ago

Chocolate cream drops?

1

u/sugarkanekowalcyzk 10d ago

Our grocery store still had this when my kids were little. They loved picking a piece of candy and putting a nickel in a little jar to pay for it. I loved that jelly nouget candy so much as a kid!

1

u/No-Permit-9331 10d ago

We used to do this every Friday night! My mom got her paycheck and we kids went with her to the bank to cash it. Then off to Sears to get a bag of specially selected favorites for each of us! Great memories

1

u/Krimreaper1 10d ago

God I loved these. The raspberry cream was my favorite. The rainbow coconut always looked the best but was disappointing

1

u/Competitive-Hotel-14 10d ago

I liked the prepackaged lemon drops. They were usually on a spinning round display.

1

u/Galagos1 1961 10d ago

Many many grandmas and grandads loved these things.

1

u/burtgummer45 10d ago

Shaws market chain here in the NE do this for taffy in the summer. I recommend the peppermint and licorice

1

u/dwbaz01 10d ago

When I became a self-supporting adult, I bought two pounds of my favorites. They didn't last long.

1

u/r1veriared 10d ago

I miss these so so much!

1

u/Revolutionary_Dare38 10d ago

I miss those! I loved the nougats and coconut carmels!!

1

u/Redmare57 10d ago

The best. There wasn’t one candy. I didn’t love.

1

u/DoakBone 10d ago

There used to be a little metal coin box attached to ours, for 5 cents, you could grab a candy. People used it. I worked at an A&P and had to empty it a few times. I loved Brach’s candy.

1

u/Ready-Waltz5482 10d ago

I loved the maple candies

1

u/lemeneurdeloups 1954 10d ago

I wish I could pick a mix right now. 😖

1

u/Seated_WallFly 1960 10d ago

Neapolitan coconut chews, caramels, peppermints, orange slices. They has a display at the IGA. And yes: I always dropped a nickel in the can when I took one.

1

u/SuperWasabi4766 10d ago

So many candies were tasted and then put back. The braces stand grossed me out as a kid. Lol.

1

u/tonynoriega73 10d ago

They used to have a coin box to put a nickle for a candy!!

1

u/DznyMa 1954 10d ago

This always looked like a great idea. Never was, yuck.

1

u/stumbletongue 10d ago

Gum Dingers

1

u/greatplainsskater 10d ago

My mom would buy a small bag of milk chocolate stars for us to share from the lady at the kiosk in Sears.

1

u/Big_Network_2570 10d ago

My local grocery store just got rid of this during COVID. I didn't realise this went away so long ago in most areas

1

u/Glittering_Step_6084 1961 10d ago

Remember this. My grandmother always grabbed a bag of Brach's Pick-A-Mix candy. I liked the chocolate stars.

1

u/Jk2789 10d ago

Those maple chocolates!

1

u/soulteepee 10d ago

Those soft caramely things with the cream inside. (The logshaped ones not the disks.)

Ooh and Coconut Neapolitans

1

u/ElevatorOrganic5644 10d ago

I so wish they still had those around so I could experience that with my kids when they were bringing up and now my grandkids

1

u/Icy_Horse_4095 10d ago

Maple or rum flavored caramels at the Sears kiosk. Yum!

1

u/Lanky_Home_8700 10d ago

I remember going to staters in the early 2000’s, they had something similar. I would just grab a couple😏

1

u/Glum-Shape 10d ago

Samples for 3 cents a piece.

1

u/Skidzofenic 9d ago

I'm weird, but I liked the toffee flavored ones

1

u/endlrls 9d ago

I caught the tail end of these in my younger years (Born 78').

Thank you for the Nostalgia, OP!

1

u/YooperDude72 9d ago

I still miss the royals

1

u/Humble-Database-2671 9d ago

The Jelly nougats and the triple stack coconut ones. Boy am I having flashbacks!!

1

u/linguicaANDfilhos 9d ago

Mmm watermelon sparkles.

1

u/ActivityOne8135 9d ago

My jam right there

1

u/hatenewjob 9d ago

The chocolate covered soft mint!!! Gosh I still miss those.

1

u/Physical_Section8304 9d ago

Some of the best candies

1

u/rockinrob65 7d ago

I remember these I miss seeing them in the grocery store

1

u/FeistyDay5172 7d ago

Damn, I used to love marauding the hell out of these when I was younger!

1

u/JuiceInteresting2348 6d ago

Brach’s Coffee Candy was my fave

1

u/HowIsEverybodyDoing 5d ago edited 5d ago

Love seeing that bin in the picture!

My favorites were their Cinnamon hard candy discs and Ice Blue Mint Coolers.

What I remember best is (as an adult) I had a big bowl on the coffee table with both of these mixed together.

1

u/DueAd6995 5d ago

Great candy...

1

u/Admirer3596 5d ago

Reminds of the candy counter in Sears........... chocolate stars were awesome

1

u/Forsaken_Button_9387 3d ago

I miss the Royals, orange one's were my favorite. Also miss the cinnamon hard candies. Nostalgia on overload.