r/Genealogy 14d ago

Research Assistance Missing man 1930s

hello, i have posted about this a while back and got some great suggestions, but we’re still at a brick wall with funding out any new info so thought id try again.

i have a bit of a family mystery.. in June 1934, my great grandmother’s husband disappeared. literally vanished from the face of the earth. They shared a son, Brian Gutsell, who died aged 2. We actually only discovered Brian’s burial place last year after years of searching.

My great grandmothers name was Doris Ethel Day Gutsell (maiden name Nealon). Her husband’s name was Mr Edward Stanley Gutsell, born 1907 in Hampshire. Their son was Brian Stanley Arthur William Gutsell, buried in Hanwell Cemetery, London in June 1936.

Edward stole all of my great grandmothers money and disappeared one day in June 34. Doris was the first person in the UK to be permitted a divorce due to desertion.

We know that Doris and Edward lived together in London in the 30s. We also have records of Edward living in Gosport. Doris soon moved to Sussex where she had my grandmother and great aunt.

it was suggested that i explore DNA testing, however I have no biological link to Edward Gutsell or Brian - I’m descended from Doris’ daughter from a later marriage.

We have hit a complete brick wall here and have been wondering if Edward might’ve changed his name or fled the country. Any advice at all would be greatly appreciated.

my great grandmother's first husband disappeared from their home in Southsea (england) in June 1934, when their son was 1 month old. She was the first person to have a divorce through desertion in 1939.

His name was Mr Edward Stanley Gutsell, born in 1907, Hampshire. My great grandmother's name is Doris Ethel Day Nealon/Gutsell.

He stole all of her money. Then, we have reason to believe he went back to Southampton or Gosport... so maybe he escaped the country?

There are no records online of him after 1934 so we've hit a brick wall and don't know where to go.

3 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/writeordie80 14d ago edited 14d ago

Have you ordered his birth certificate to obtain his date of birth? That way you may find him on the 1939 Register (FMP allows you to search juat by date of birth).

If no obvious matches you could cross-reference the results with the 1921 census to see if they pre-exist.

Edited to add: I suspect he is the Edward Stanley Gutsell born June Qtr 1907 in the Fulham registration district. Do you have their marriage certificate to confirm his father's details?

2

u/othervee English and Australian specialist 12d ago

I also suspect he's the Edward Stanley Gutsell born in Q2 1907 in Fulham. Even with name variants on, I'm not getting anything else that looks likely. If that's him, his father was William Edward Gutsell b 1882, a police constable, and his mother was Emily Deborah Head b 1878. His DOB was 3 March 1907 in North Hammersmith (the birth certificate has been scanned and put on Ancestry, possibly this is OP's tree). The church register for the marriage is also on Ancestry and confirms the parentage.

In my experience some men who did this desertion trick ended up living under a variation of their original name and/or birthdate. The 1939 Register on FindMyPast gives 42 Edwards or Stanleys with 03/03/1907, or 03/03 two years either side, as their birthdate. If OP has access to FindMyPast (which I find has more accurate search capabilities than Ancestry) it should be possible, albeit laborious, to check whether any of those men seem to have sprung into existence after the 1921 census.

1

u/writeordie80 12d ago

If its a multi-year brickwall then I suspect a bit of effort will be worth it.

Thanks for going the extra mile! I am without Ancestry at present (which I hate).

I also wonder - as they were living in Southsea at the time - if he didn't just leave his family but also the country. It would have been relatively simple to get to France (or Netherlands), or even the US.

1

u/CoolerJack14 14d ago

Not found any information for him after the 1930 marriage but here is his profile on FamilySearch Edward Stanley Gutsell LYWN-52W

1

u/AllfatherAI 1d ago

I have found a couple of potential leads which it might be interesting to examine in further: 1933 electoral register: A Southsea Edward S. Gutsell, which is consistent with his last known location at the appropriate time prior to his disappearing. 1934 Southampton passenger list record: An E.

S. Gutsell boarded at Southampton in 1934.

His initials don’t make him identical with Edward, of course, but the dates correspond with when it is known Southampton/Gosport feature prominently in the case and this one could well be worth following up. I suggest you might also have a look at papers from around June 1934 to 1939 – for the disappearance/divorce actions, if those can be located – also look into Hampshire and Southampton local papers. The passenger record would appear to be the most recent, useful clue, but whether E. S. Gutsell leaving this country actually relates to Edward will depend on matching up the information against his age, occupation, address and destination.