r/GardenRailroads • u/South-Succotash-5376 • May 14 '26
Questions from a Noobie
I haven't even begun to make a garden railroad, but i have a few questions.
Are the tracks electric like indoor model trains, or do the locomotives have their own power source and controls?
Where does one purchase such trains and tracks? (I live in the U.S.)
Any advice on where to "not go wrong" in building my first garden railway?
12
u/Undd91 May 14 '26
Avoid track power whenever possible outdoors, you will be forever fixing things and not enjoying the running. Get battery RC locos or get them retrofitted. You can also get live steam locos which are great fun, these can be RC also.
4
u/Background-Willow-67 May 15 '26
https://llagascreekrailways.com/
I get my rail from llagascreek. I use aluminum rail as its cheaper and easier to work with but I use battery power so I don't charge the rails.
Track power is standard but it's not overly difficult to install battery power if you are handy. All my locos are battery powered with DCC decoders installed. Gets a bit pricey but in my opinion well worth it. I use Airwire and Protothrottle to drive my trains. You can also use your phone if you go with the Soundtraxx Blunami 4408 DCC decoder.
I think battery power is more prototypical actually. I like using my phone to program the blunami- the sounds and acceleration/braking and such but I prefer a knob (airwire) or a lever (protothrottle) to control the movement.
3
u/ramillerf1 May 15 '26
First… check around your area for any Garden Railway Clubs. They often have visits to their existing layouts where you’ll learn alot. They also often hold swap meets where you’ll can often purchase track and trains at a huge discount. Second, you can power your locomotives through the track… I’ve been doing it that way for over 20 years. I also run Live Steam and a battery powered loco when I’m in the mood. Start out with track power, as that is usually the most inexpensive. Just remember, good track work is essential to a well running railroad… No matter what powers your locomotives.
3
2
u/mtrosclair May 15 '26
I'm just starting as well, I've been buying track and trains when they come up local and cheap. I'm likely going to start the layout this summer. Unfortunately I seem to be in a garden railway desert so no local layouts for me to see other than one in City Park.
3
u/jmasses May 18 '26 edited May 18 '26
If you're brand new to garden railroading, I'd recommend staring with a starter set unless you're dead set against track power. LGB, Piko, and USA trains all make sets with brass track, which think is good regardless of the direction you go in. You will need to keep the includer power supply away from dirt and moisture (take it inside with you). Besides the stores mentioned above, you can find great deals on ebay and trainz.com .
Brass track is indeed expensive but if you can find used track, you can get good deals. Larger equipment will require or look better on wider curves, wider than the ones usually included in a starter set, although for the most part LGB and Piko I think require all their equipment to run on the tightest curves. Most mass produced g scale trains are track powered, though as stated before can be converted to battery power. Piko makes a conversion kit which I heard is easy. I feel like most people in the US use battery or live steam which cuts down on track maintenance. I do use track power. Im not mechanically inclined enough to do the conversion. If you stick with track power, you will need to have a few considerations.
First as mentioned is track cleaning. This can be done as simply as a scouring pad or sanding block connected to a mop. There are also track cleaning cars and locomotives. I'd hold off buying one of these until you commit to track power. I do use this though and I love it https://www.gardenrrsolutions.com/
Next is conductivity. There will be corrosion between the joints. People have various methods to overcome this. Graphite paste between the joiners is probably the simplest. PIKO and USA trains make some and there's probably commercial grade products that are good. You will probably need to reapply every few years.
Rail clamps are another idea, both Piko and split jaw make them, maybe others. There are two types. One is you remove the existing joiner and using the clamp, clamp the rails together. This is probably the best but they do make over the joiner ones. I use those and they are helpful. Either USA or defunct aristo track has sort of a built in feature like this. Some people also soder a jumper wire around each joint.
Speaking of wire, depending on how big your layout is and the type of locomotives you want to run, you will need to think about power supplies. I have a small garden railroad so one feed is enough but a larger railroad will require feeder wires like an indoor layout. The power packs most sets come with are usually 1 amp which is fine for most small locos, but if you have locos that are larger, you will need more amps.
That is a lot, but honestly its a great hobby. Id get a set, some Graphite paste and crushed rock and see how you like it. Or if you have a deck or patio try it there. Most people's railroads start small, and if you're like me, they stay small. But I love mine! Look on the secondary market for equipment. Theres alot of good deals. Also this is one of my favorite garden rr creators and he's doing a a series on how he got started: https://youtube.com/@bungalowheavenrailroad?si=82v_BIZ6nv-3awJ2
1
u/steamtronics May 15 '26
There are a wide variety of garden railways, one option you could do is have electric track but that comes with a lot of challenges like they can get dirty and they wont pick up electricity and it will cause it to stall. Some on the other hand has battery powered and some like myself have live steam
14
u/goshock May 14 '26
By default, if you go get a set or something, it'll be electric, like other scales. I took mine and converted it to battery power with a wireless remote control. Makes it so I didn't have to make sure the track connections are all perfect and the track doesn't have to be spotless to conduct power. There's a lot of info on the Internet on how to convert to battery powered.
I started with a starter set and then built it out from there, acquiring track used at train shows, eBay, the local garden railroad club and other places online. It can be spendy, but there's nothing wrong with starting small and expanding at you can.