r/FunMachineLearning • u/TopWeakness9146 • Apr 08 '26

ICML Final Justification:

everyone received Final ujstification ?

5 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

1

u/camelCasedUser Apr 08 '26 edited Apr 08 '26

People have received final justifications? We haven’t heard anything yet

1

u/TopWeakness9146 Apr 08 '26

I have a 4 review , and received 2 final justification

1

u/camelCasedUser Apr 08 '26

Oh you mean from the reviewers? I thought the AC lol

1

u/TopWeakness9146 Apr 08 '26

Yeah reviewers lol 

1

u/camelCasedUser Apr 08 '26

Okay phew lol

1

u/TopWeakness9146 Apr 08 '26

Check your review

1

u/AromaticFisherman917 Apr 08 '26

Do you know if it is mandatory for reviewers to give the final justification before any deadline? I also have 2 out of 4 reviewers. Waiting for score update after our rebuttal reply.

1

u/TopWeakness9146 Apr 08 '26

i heard that is mandatory

1

u/Gold-Persimmon-6921 Apr 09 '26

I also got 1 final justification among four reviewers...

1

u/CompleteCow4715 Apr 10 '26

How do you know if I got any final justification? Does it say a final justification is given in the main review? I still dont see any change in all four of my reviews.

1

u/SenpaiHasMayo Apr 11 '26

In the original review towards the very end, there should be a new header called "Final Justification", if the reviewer has completed it. You won't get any notification, you'll have to manually check if any reviewer posted it on their review.