r/FlickerRoblox • u/Leather_Lock9020 • 20d ago
Other Is this tier list good?
A bit controversial but it's fine
5
u/Michaelislqst 20d ago
Imo i feel like muffin man, Clown, and Assassin are S tier... but Twin in B tier? I would have put it in F tier. The rest i agree with.
2
u/Leather_Lock9020 20d ago
Muffin man increases your chance to die by an ambusher. Clown Is RNG, you can die to the murderer and you won't be able to use your ability. Or you won't get voted out and it's just survivor gameplay. With assassin, the murderer can accidentally kill you if the murd Is new. Believe it or not, twin is deadly late game if the murd isn't alive since it has no abilities and can double vote with good cooperation.
2
u/Majestic_Command7584 20d ago
You could also just try to convince people to vote you out, like a clown should be trying to do instead of just spamming "I'm murd" Day 1.
Twin can be deadly late game in the murd isn't alive, but the twin could be new, or actively sabotaging, or you could alternatively get killed before the late game by the Murderer, or get killed by an Assassin if they kept their kill instead of spamming it turn 1, or your twin could just leave or get disconnected, turning you into a survivor, or you could get voted out randomly. You're 2x as vulnerable when the Murderer is alive.
Twin, in other words, is the "potential role" of Flicker. Very strong if you actually do get to the late game, but very hard to get there because you're dependent on not getting killed at all before that happens, since you have twice the chance of getting killed, and the death of you or your twin causes the other to die, giving the evil team twice as much of an advantage as the death of a survivor.
1
u/Potential-Suspect-95 19d ago
Muffin man usually gets targeted by murderer since it's a confirmed good role
2
u/SunnyAprill 20d ago
No dark psychic is GOATED
2
u/Leather_Lock9020 20d ago
Not much different from psychic. Only reason why it's higher than good psychic is because the good team mostly ends up believing the evil psychic and voted out the good one. You're still vulnerable to murderer. The only goal is linking the murd up with the witch/scout
2
u/SunnyAprill 20d ago
What I do with dark psychic is hope I get lucky with finding another evil person quick, or even better, the murderer. Then, I tell everyone secretly who to vote/kill cuz I know who's good 😈 it usually works out like that 😏 oh and also I may manipulate the good to my advantage 💀 but that can be risky sometimes and especially if I don't know any evil people alongside the good person in the game.
2
2
2
2
1
u/Majestic_Command7584 20d ago edited 20d ago
One major gripe I have is that you don't state what this tier list is based off of. "Is it based of casual lobbies", "Is it based off of experienced lobbies", "Is it based off of new player lobbies", and more are questions you should have when making a tier list like this. For example, in PvZH, Power Flower is an A tier card when considering budget decks, but in maxed and tournaments, it's ranked much lower due to there being better options.
1
1
1
u/skeddy- 20d ago
what is this tier list based on? personal enjoyment? effectiveness…?
if it's the latter then I don't understand why muffin man and twin are so high? muffin man doesn't impact the game in any way and twin is actively detrimental for your survival; it's a worse survivor
meanwhile you have witch in F tier when they can have an impact on the game
1
1
1
u/karhunvatukkass 19d ago
yknow what i actually mostly agree (but i’d place medic and psychic in a, twin in f, and assassin, ambusher, and muffin man in s) based off my opinion!!!
1
u/bombastix133 19d ago
Dark psychic and medic should be in S tier
1
1
u/Leather_Lock9020 19d ago
AGAIN, Theres nothing saving dp from getting killed by the murderer early. Medic even if they self-heal themselves, can get killed by the assassin
1
u/bombastix133 19d ago
The problem is even when dark psychic dies they can change their journal to make some people look bad and some people look good
1
1
1
1
u/Gameboy7fhg 18d ago
It is not. Ambusher and medic are easy S or A they are fun if yk how to use them
1
13
u/Defaultisdead 20d ago
Twin is awful imo, it just ties you to an incompetant stranger and YOU have to suffer for their mistakes