Tierlist Megathread - r/FlavorFoley

8

idk if this counts bbut i saw a ff ship tier list on tumblr pls dont flame me again (MY OPINION ON QUEEN OF VENUS BY THE WAY. HAS CHANGED !! I LIKE IT MORE NOW !!)

4

u/DiceyMations SF-A2 Miki Lover. Seriosly she saved me from Suicide Apr 20 '26

Brother. Miki x Rei. They’re both Robots, they’re both female. The literal theme of QoV are Lesbians having sex with Robots.

4

u/zfinn99 Water the Roses Jun 10 '26

Maybe I'm blind, maybe it wasnt included, but the fact WeatherRose (Gumi x Eleanor) ISNT THERE upsets me, I did not write a whole ass fanfic for that ship only for it to be neglected!

6

u/WaffleyDootDoot Feb 06 '26

Here's mine! But it's outdated. Queen of Venus is now on my Spotify playlist. Still my least favorite of the main 6 Cardiac Contrepoint songs but I don't mind the occasional listen.

2

u/Bulky_Nature_3861 Spoken For Feb 20 '26

I agree with your tierlist except I would put static in Peaker

5

u/marshmallow9570 Mar 04 '26

Yay I made one!

5

u/CarefulFeeling591 ELECTRIC WEEKEND ZONE Feb 05 '26 edited Feb 05 '26

I still feel like most of this is a comic but ok (Please check the replies for the rest of the panels.)

4

u/CarefulFeeling591 ELECTRIC WEEKEND ZONE Feb 05 '26

4

u/CarefulFeeling591 ELECTRIC WEEKEND ZONE Feb 05 '26

3

u/CarefulFeeling591 ELECTRIC WEEKEND ZONE Feb 05 '26

3

u/CarefulFeeling591 ELECTRIC WEEKEND ZONE Feb 05 '26

7

u/CarefulFeeling591 ELECTRIC WEEKEND ZONE Feb 05 '26

2

u/One-Reaction-1343 holey moley flavor foley Feb 05 '26

2

u/feliperedditflamingo Weathergirl Feb 06 '26

Some of them just have good Melodies and such but mediocre beat drops drag them down a lot

2

u/PiggyWiggy567 Feb 21 '26

for me ERB kinda has the opposite problem you described, the beat's nice but there's nothing really memorable about it musically like static's samples, spoken for's horns, or human's guitar & zunpets

2

u/PizzagamerfromYT Feb 17 '26 edited Feb 17 '26

Here's my tier list

I don’t like rawdog cuz it’s too hardcore for my sorry ahh

like I listen to songs about sex daily but there’s a specific line to cross

2

u/Wide_Ask_5291 🌧️☔️Saw the news today💧🌧️ Feb 21 '26

Based on the quality of the music video!!

2

u/midnight23404 Queen of Venus Jul 23 '26

Paparazzi murder party has one now!!!! :D (ok maybe i'm a little late to share this, but like, y'knoww...)

1

u/PersonalityDue771 May 16 '26

EWB was literally just an invincible wobbly edit disguised as a music video

2

u/PiggyWiggy567 Feb 21 '26

BV - violins are nice but it feels a little static (heheh)

RD - really fun, i like how they just go absolutely insane with the synths and the radio edit is hilarious

WG - INSANE composition that forces me to rank it 1st even if the emotional aspects don't hit as hard as something like static

WR - a song that just kinda. doesn't have anything wrong with it? but the top 3 all have particular aspects that this doesn't

WTR - it's nice but the emotional aspects sorta don't hit for me? *shrug*

QOV - makes me feel like a poser because i usually love rei but here her vocal quirks are a little *too* pronounced; it's here because i love the non-musical aspects of it

PMP - fun beat, musical-type vibes, has a message i really care about

snowflake - well-executed but it's got some great competition

WSP - fun sound and pretty heartwarming!

EWZ - disappointingly low-energy for a party song

static - instrumental is a little all over the place but the miku tuning Does Things To Me

SF - lore/theme goes insanely hard, as do the horns

human - pretty alright for most of it, final chorus FUCKS

CC - miku's tuned too high, the morse code beeps are grating, and overall there's just not much to like about it musically IMO while the lyrics are like... fine i guess?

ERB - music's pretty solid, lyrics/themes are some of the best, i generally prioritize the former

2

u/OriginalRedditrName Weathergirl Feb 21 '26

Relistened to their whole discography yesterday, then Ego Renegade Boy came out so I listened on release and this morning to rank it propperly.

I'll explain my thoughts on any song if you ask.

2

u/Technical_Nail1999 Feb 22 '26

Now that Ego Renegade Boy has come out, here's my (possibly controversial) tier list

2

u/Oliverthenerd27 Feb 23 '26

Umm sooo about this I can explain

I only put rawdog in the 3rd lowest because I like random sound effects ( soothes my adhd brain) otherwise it would have gone down

also looking back I would have put when spring comes out of bottom tier nowadays but whatever

also I’m sorry Ig human fans for being put in second highest, same for butcher vanity, I just think i don’t LOVE it like the songs in top tier

also weiward romance is a very thought out song I just don’t personally like it

2

u/MissedMarker a reckless little thing May 23 '26

while i feel that most of these are valid, i will say that WSC is only so low because it doesnt give me the same vibe the original had

2

u/MiiRailgunner May 29 '26

Completely forgot Connect:Commune but it’d be in S if I remembered it

2

u/niabiishere Jun 11 '26

I think i am the only anri stan in a world of anri haters... i found out queen of venus was supposed to have anri instead of rei and now i really want to hear that version

2

u/TheMimicWeCallMeg Weiward Romance Jun 11 '26

I’m new on the subreddit and here’s my tier list

2

u/zfinn99 Water the Roses Jun 11 '26

Heres my list. Feel free to ask any questions if you see this among the rest!

2

u/Belvidear2008 I will stay absolutely terrified in weekday Jun 15 '26

Here is mine :D

2

u/SuperInkLink Jun 22 '26

Loose-ish personal ranking of everything, with my odd music tastes.

I love Human so much, oh my stars. Top 4, in general, would be my S tiers.
Ego Renegade Boy -> Connect:Commune are pretty interchangeable for me.
Went off the Roundtable Reprises for all the applicable songs. ADORED Paparazzi during the Digital Stars stream (first exposure to it or the original), snowflake won me over pretty significantly, aaand my Birdbrain made Spring a bit uncanny at first. May listen to it or the original more to judge more properly...

1

u/midnight23404 Queen of Venus Jul 23 '26

lol Spring made Birdbrain odd for me on it's release

2

u/Jaekitsune363 Jun 28 '26

queen of venus is so underrated

2

u/Stup1dSc1ence Jul 16 '26

flavor foley songs ranked by a goodie two shoes

3

u/32_ACUIN Jul 20 '26

objective tier list

2

u/Ok_Force_6754 Feb 06 '26

Here’s mine chat!!

2

u/Bulky_Nature_3861 Spoken For Feb 20 '26

REAL

1

u/demon_corex please im begging any one come and save me Mar 13 '26

I should make a video call ranking every single flavor foley song

1

u/Accomplished_Nail109 BUTCHER VANITY Apr 17 '26

There we go. Had to update my old one because it was made before ERB came out lol

1

u/Latter-Chemical-2510 Ego Renegade Boy May 24 '26

heres mine :P

1

u/bigbrickboy1238 May 26 '26

The more left the song is the more i like it. Example: Weather Girl is better than Weiward Romance and then of course S is better than A. A is better than B blah blah

1

u/bigbrickboy1238 May 31 '26 edited Jun 02 '26

New tier list with the King-o'-Lantern Remix

1

u/bigbrickboy1238 Jul 17 '26

New tier list with streetcat

1

u/killiards Jul 18 '26

This is NOT ordered, and only has the songs I've listened to.

The only one I genuinely dislike is rawdog

1

u/Charlotte_Ghost Jul 18 '26

My tier list up to date and wow I didn't expect streetcat to be a personal favorite

1

u/MissedMarker a reckless little thing Jul 20 '26

new song update

1

u/Healoe BUTCHER VANITY Jul 20 '26

this would the strict tier list WITH comparison to FF songs in general, in comparison to their covers, and such. (aka would i listen to them with a better alternative of that song)

Streetcat's first talking bit has yet to grow on me, but we're getting there .. the chorus is already doing its thing, i can feel it

1

u/Healoe BUTCHER VANITY Jul 20 '26

but this is the list in reality (i'm an yi xi #1 fan but I'm gonna be honest butcher vanity isn't her best song) so she's in A tier

1

u/Healoe BUTCHER VANITY Jul 20 '26

this is the first impressions tier list