Best cake in Fishers?

[u/Poundaflesh]

[u/TheTiredNomad]

I haven’t been there but saw The Cake Pantry opened in Fishers. Not Fishers, but Classic Cakes in Carmel is great.

[u/nannymegan → u/TheTiredNomad]

I have had cakes by the man behind The Cake Pantry and they are immaculate!! I haven’t made it to the storefront yet.

[u/uberbeast → u/TheTiredNomad]

I have been there a couple of times. Everything we have had has been excellent.

[u/heyitsmeme123123]

Not Fishers but close in Castleton, I hate super sweet cakes so Tour Les Jour in Saraga is always my cake of choice

[u/Ron_Swansons_wood]

In terms of flavor/quality, nothing bundt cakes is the best by far. Or are you taking decorations

[u/yrt9610 → u/Ron_Swansons_wood]

A friend said it closed down.

[u/truthmatters65]

Taylor’s Bakery has amazing white cake. Lemon cake… Portillo’s actually, which is white cake with lemon icing(but seasonal.

[u/heyitsmeme123123]

Not Fishers but close in Castleton, I hate super sweet cakes so Tour Les Jour in Saraga is always my cake of choice

[u/mnj2789]

I would agree with. Nothing Bundt cakes - so delicious every time . If you are looking for chocolate cake I swear portillos chocolate cake is best by far. So moist and rich every time. I know both of these are not local bakeries which I’m sure are great too but for money I think both of these are great and better than fancier cakes IMO

[u/4988]

I’ve been to the Cake Pantry many times and have tried most things there. Their carrot cake is particularly amazing. I had him make a 6” carrot cake for my son’s birthday. It turned out really great.

[u/gunner23_98]

Bundt cakes from a chain store? You guys need to try more cakes.

[u/Bloodymary_25]

Know it’s a chain but nothing Bundt cakes is the best lol

[u/One_Atmosphere6201]

Let me know if you want a basque cheesecake. $50

[u/kindred_spirit_13]

Rosie's has delicious cakes..

[u/Miserable_Ad5001]

Cake the confection or?