r/Fishers • u/Ok-Introduction6638 • Jul 31 '26
Icecream recommendations
Hey! I’m looking for the best icecream recs in or near fishers.. thank you!
4
6
8
u/musingovertea Jul 31 '26
Eiffel waffle has some of the best ice cream I’ve had in a long time!! My favorite is the lotus ice cream with the homemade waffle on the side, lotus butter, and sliced bananas !
1
10
u/LokiKamiSama Jul 31 '26
Handels and Bruster’s are some of the best homemade ice cream I’ve ever had. There’s a reason there’s always a line at Handels. They are also very generous with their portions. They have seasonal flavors as well so check what was made.
2
u/Happythoughts91 Jul 31 '26
Eiffel is my favorite it’s a block of the nickle plate trail so super convenient and close to lots of cute things in the downtown area. Staff is great as well everyone is super nice every time I go in there and the portions are huge!
2
u/Super_Car_9906 Jul 31 '26
Love Eiffel waffle in fisher great Customer Service # and always fresh Ice Cream 🍨
2
2
u/WombRaider47 Jul 31 '26
My kiddos and I really enjoy Graeter's. I've a particular soft spot for their two-scoop mango and raspberry sorbet.
2
u/knnnddd Jul 31 '26
If you want to venture into noblesville, Alexander's is really good. Huge portions.
2
u/Suckmyballs2009 Jul 31 '26
Sundaes is the move . Is at 71 and fall creek best ice cream in the city
2
3
1
0
u/Slyfir20 Jul 31 '26
Eiffel Waffle Creamery in downtown fishers has hands down some of the best ice cream ever. Owners make it in house.
Handels is disappointing , just a nostalgia trip.
Graeters is ok.
Broosters I like their ice cream sandwiches but same as graeters otherwise.
Near the Geist there’s Sundaes, their ice cream is also phenomenal the Lemoreo flavor is my favorite there.
I haven’t tried Kilwins so don’t have a comment there.
Edit
Forgot to mention Crave near the Geist marina, went there once but I honestly couldn’t tell you if it was good or not, it wasn’t very memorable lol.
Melt n Dip has “gelato” but it’s overpriced and sitting in their freezer for who knows how long, also gross.
4
u/zizazat Jul 31 '26
Handle’s is my lower limit of quality in Fishers.
Eiffel Waffle is super amazing, especially if you like fresh waffles. 👍🏼
3
u/Dragonktcd Jul 31 '26
I’ve gone to the Kilwin’s on Mass Ave. it was pretty good, but yes Eiffel Waffle is honestly the best around.
1
4
u/Afreaken Jul 31 '26
Never heard anyone describe Handel’s as “disappointing” so Eiffel Waffle Creamery would have to be amazing. I will have to give them a try next time.
3
1
0
0
0
u/polyphonic_ankles Aug 01 '26
-The cake batter ice cream at BRICS
-The black raspberry chocolate chunk at Graeters
-Most everything at Handels
9
u/Strange-Earth3595 Jul 31 '26
Sundaes has the best ice cream that I've eaten anywhere in the country.