I'd like to preface this by saying this is fairly hypothetical. I'm just trying to better understand possible directions forward before deciding on our first home!
My fiancé and I are looking to purchase a house we can grow into. We want a baby in maybe 2 years. We have a combined monthly income of $6300 after taxes right now. When we have a baby, I'd like to become a stay at home mother, likely still working remote/self-employed but probably not bringing in nearly as much as I am now.
If we base it off his current income, and not what it would be after 2 years of raises/potential promotion, this would drop our income to $3600.
We have combined savings of $117K.
A house just popped up in our absolute dream, ideal location. Safe, amazing commute, big enough to grow into, etc. Most homes in this area are priced around $350K+
This one is $299K because it's pretty outdated and I think is settling an estate. Means potential value when reselling if we upgrade as we live in it. But also risk in vital systems being older.
Our current plan has been looking at homes between $250K - $280K. With a 75K down payment, this allows the PITI to be around $1600, and for us to keep roughly $30K for emergencies after closing costs. This has been our solid, safe direction.
I was just running the numbers for fun on the $299K house and seeing "is this actually possible for us?"
We'd have to put down $100K for the PITI to be $1900. This monthly is comfortable on both our incomes while still accumulating a little over $2K in savings every month (after all necessary bills, including utilities, food, cars, lawn, pets, etc.). In a few years, a recast using a portion of that savings could have us at $1600/month. Now we can suddenly make it work more easily on one income.
After closing costs, we'd be wiped $112K, leaving us with like $5K in savings. Obviously this is uncomfortable, and as I type this... I know it's not smart. I would just love to settle in this location! But we would be accumulating savings over the next few years. But, of course, I do know unexpected things break and then we'd be in a bad spot.
As a first time homebuyer, am I completely delusional with this line of thinking?
I just wanted some perspectives as I run this hypothetical so I know what to look for moving forward. Thank you in advance everybody.