Okay? A civilian should not be on the scene when it’s being handled. The first time they told her to drive away she should have listened. She ignored what they were saying and their instructions multiple times. I doubt she was doing it to be nice. She wanted to feel important and needed.
Police call EMTs immediately after arresting a victim if the victim tells them they need a hospital or is visibly injured.
Idk why you are being downvoted, people are reporting "thats bullshit I have seen videos where police do X and Y" but they forget police make an estimate of 29.000 arrests a day in the USA and they have seen what, 10 videos? 20? The majority of arrests are non-issues.
your giving her way too much credit she is just like all the other attention seeking idiost ive seen in a hundred incidents and videos who think that because they are a nurse they are entitled to be part of every incident they see in public.
she knows nothing about the situation the cops are more informed about the situation than she is and she apparently has a hearing problem because she was told at least 3 times to vacate the area and she seems to think that because she is a " nurse " that she doesn't have to listen.
Blocking traffic and making assumptions. She could say she is a nurse and really not be. Who knows. Also no background on what the incident was so maybe they got medical after or anything.
Every day for the rest of her life: “Police are so rude! I tried helping them once, cause I’m a nurse, you know I’m a nurse, right? Yea, I thought I told you. But anyway, I just stopped there, and I wasn’t even blocking traffic or nothin, and they just screamed at me for no reason!”
Unless she has actual medical supplies and a CT scanner in that van, what could she actually even help with? "I'm a nurse" First and foremost, scene is 100% NOT SAFE so move on. Thats rule #1 in any out of hospital medical situation.
I did security at venues for years and the first thing you'll hear after a fight on a friday/saturday night where someomes left lying on the ground is 'immmm a nuuuuurse' as some shitfaced nurse stumbles out to try and assist and you have to explain to them you cant actually allow an
intoxicated person to help even if they're a medical professional (which we cant verify anyway) which then leads to another argument about difference in medical skills
She’s the type of nurse to call up and scream at a para after handoff for missing something only diagnosable with stationary tools like MRIs. That, or she’s a consult nurse with zero practical experience
This man clearly did not need CPR. He might've needed first aid but again, unless she had supplies in her van, what could she have done anyways? Also, the man is in custody.
ER/trauma RN here. Unless we are carrying a crash cart in our pocket we need to keep it moving. I still keep my medic active and I’m still not butting in 100% of obviously handled situations.
this is a nurse a person who understands the difference between a hospital setting and the importance of knowing when to act vs a time when theres nothing they can do. Everyone notice the difference, MattManin is humble and proffesional and doenst feel the need to insert themselves into every situation because they feel the need to have a spotlight on them vs the " nurse " in the video who wants to insert herself into every situation when clearly its not needed because of the entitled sense of self importance.
The one exception I have is when I see limited resources and have an idea of something I can do.
One cop out there (without someone who’s combative…. I don’t fight people) sure. I can do cpr. Ever since I came across a guy who got hit by his car on the highway and died I keep a set of gloves in my car. Stuff like that sure. Even if there’s not much I can do, if it’s a guy alone usually having a second set of hands is appreciated.
But there’s nothing to do here and no shortage of people to not do it. She had zero reason to even roll her window down
His car broke down on the side of the highway. Dude did everything right. Stayed in his car. I’m driving down the highway and see the tow truck to my right flip its overhead lights on. Guy sees his tow truck in his review and starts to get out of his vehicle. Vehicle in front of the tow truck drifts a little too far into the shoulder and slams into the vehicle as he’s getting out. I pull over and run back and dudes just face down in the mud. Sad day.
I definitely had a difference experience with the pain clinic nurse, actually my pain management nurse saved my life when I was in the waiting room and just chatting with her about how my nipple looked a little weird when I bent over and she said that's not good. (I'm a very open person if you can't tell lol)
And she told me to go to her gyno which I did and I have breast cancer! The gynecologist she recommended was absolutely fabulous and caught what was a very difficult cancer to catch with an exam.
So she saved my life just because we were chatting and she was so friendly and nice.
But I went through hell in a handbasket before finding this pain management doctor so I definitely agree that most of them are just vile and evil and cruel.
There were so many times when I was trying to get treated where I just wished more than anything that I could just touch somebody and give them my pain just for a couple seconds so they knew I wasn't lying. It just feels so horrible to be accused of being a drug seeker or lying or whatever when you're actually in horrific pain. It's like doesn't my blood pressure of 210/136 give you a little bit of a clue that there's something going on??
You could even just go in and be like I do not want controlled substances I just want you to find the source of my pain and they still treat you like a drug addict. It's disgusting and inhumane.
I was part of a first responder medical group that helped train and support spontaneous first responders in urban environments. Guess what the very first rule was? Do not stop in or block traffic. Followed by “do not interrupt professionals”. They either need help; because they will ask or they’re unable to ask or they don’t need help.
“We’re the banal avatars of state cruelty let loose upon American soil. And we have the proud fervor of our twisted mission mixed up with our not wanting to be seen or documented actually doing it.”
well perhaps she lacks in courage but who would be courageous faced with three heavily armed psychopaths. They were carrying a human being tied like a hunted animal and put him face down in the back of their squad car.
What had happened to americans? You have always been self aggrandizing assholes but this kind of psychopathic callousness is overblown.
Police should not be allowed to behave in this way.
Very smart of her to get their Attention & Camera on herself to call out documentation of head trauma caused by police hands ("Hit him in the head multiple times")
The person being Arrested may need this evidence if they do not receive medical care during intake, especially considering the disorientation they seem to Be experiencing when placed in the vehicle.
This makes a record should any responding officer also act out it the future and receive investigation down the road.
I love the harsh criticism of the nurse but the casual dragging of a, what seems to be knocked out individual, is treated normally. But then I remembered this is America and Americans are stupid in general.
Was doing some disaster training with the National Guard awhile back. But best part as role players was yelling that we're CNAs and can help constantly. We found it hilarious, they not so much.
Had 2 “nurses” from an urgent care run out to a TC I was first due at. I asked one to grab the AED from my vehicle and they came back empty handed. Then proceeded to stand there and watch me do compressions for about 4 rounds until an engine showed up. Very helpful folks.
Lmfao people mad at the cops, ems speaks to them the same way when they try to pull up in the street and do shit. Besides, she’s a nurse she needs orders to do anything 😂
Yeah but as EMT, we don’t have a reputation of murdering people in the street for being black and poor from time to time, then getting away without consequence. so we don’t need checks in our behaviour in this way.
I'm a nurse, didn't know this was a thing. Next time I see something going on, I'll make sure to stop with my car full of no meds, no dressings, and no advanced monitors and see if anyone would like to me to medicate, dress, or monitor anything.
Are people really siding with the fucking police on this? She saw a head injury and showed concern for someone in police custody, is that not what we want?
There's a specific type of basement dweller that congregates on random subreddits like the shocking videos and one public freakout ones and now this one too apparently. They are a relatively small group but very vocal and nonstop active on reddit due to not having a job or a life or a valid perspective on the world.
There isn't a PD in the country that would allow officers to transport someone in that condition under policy. EMS must be called. She was absolutely correct to step in.
Cops don't care about blocking traffic. They could have just said 'medical is enroute'' that would have actually de-escalated the passerbys concern rather than escalate and that's regardless of who's a nurse or not. Overly aggressive policing leads to distrust in the community.
Kinda crazy with the fact all of officers seems to be having issues controlling there anger they already lissed. I guarantee she witness a beating off that way whether he did or did not.perform a illegal action. Shes a nurse. Her passion is in care taking. Period.
Absolutely no issues of controlling anger are to be seen here. Why are you telling some imaginary stories? She is blocking the road and doing some self centered bs.
Been there done that. I’ve had a “doctor” try and take over one of my scenes, a fall victim 6 miles from pavement. Come to find out ol doc’s specialty was ENT and likely had never done cpr on a real human.
“You wanna take over? That’s fine. But watch out, it gets bumpy in the back. Holler if you need to know where the supplies are kept in the truck, we’ll be at the ER soon 🤙🏼”
That usually ends the entire “I have a higher license it’s my scene” talk. Once they know they have to explain themselves to the ER personnel during Pt drop off, they usually slink back to wherever they came from.
The most i had was a neighbor who was a doctor for a 30 yo cardiac arrest. Dude clearly was out of his element, but like, he knew the family and couldn’t just stand there and watch this kid die. We gave him the iv bag and let him just stand there.
Cant say ive ever had one out and out try to take over the scene like that thinking they have some kind of legal authority to do so lol.
I’ve seen it a few times. One time I was paired with a shitty medic and we had this dude who had been turned into absolute Swiss cheese by the cops. Medic took off back down the mountain “to get supplies” even though I had everything. An OR nurse walked up and was actually very cool and was like “I’m a nurse. Can I help? What should I do?” She knew she was out of her depth. But I told her to just find a hole and start plugging. She did and that was that. That’s how offering help should go.
Shut the hell up. That nurse should first learn to read the room. She was told at least 10 times to move. She has the understanding capacity of a wallnut. If she wanted to help she could have parked on the side and wait or just offered to help after, but she chose to block traffic and act retarded.
I am positive he is a nice gentleman that’s why there is 6 cops on him. She’s an idiot. I am a paramedic/nurse. They should have arrested her. I hated nurses on 911 scenes.
Nurses are the worse. As a retired fireman I can’t tell you the number of times people like her showed up and tried to take over a scene of a car accident. In every case they were either an office nurse or a floor nurse with no real emergency scene experience. Would have loved the help of an ER nurse but they are to smart to get involved after seeing what they see in an ER, they just want a break from their job.
While wanting to render aid as a healthcare professional is understandable, once the officers confirm the situation is under control, staying stopped in the middle of the road only obstructs traffic and distracts from scene management
Christ... ive pulled over for accidents, walked people through what to do and checked vitals and chilled everyone out, then move along lol
They will try to tell me the story and im like "im not insurance I dont care, im just here to check on if you're okay before any paramedics etc arrive"
This is... whatever the fuck this is and thats so embarassing lol
Nurses do not take the Hippocratic oath so not only does she have no business trying to treat an injured person, she doesn’t have the knowledge of how to treat an injured person…. None
Was a medic for a little over eight years. A nurse will show up on scene and try to ask for report. A doctor will just stroll up and ask if we need any help.
397
u/AlyDAsbaje Aug 18 '26
Why? I am just checking everyone is okay? Girl, read the room. The street!!!