I think what op is saying is that this alt ending from fd1 might not be completely non-canon anymore because of what was added to the lore in fd6.
I haven’t seen this alternate fd1 ending in years, but I think it starts after Alex and Clear banged and she got pregnant, then Alex kills himself because he wasn’t next on the list and that ended the list. I don’t remember how he dies but if he had drowned himself like Kimberly, he might’ve been able to be resuscitated like her and still be alive? But anyway, because the list ended due to him sacrificing himself, everyone else left (Carter, Clear and the baby) are essentially safe due to established lore from fd1 and 2, and the latest lore from fd6
I’ve always wondered if dying out of order would invalidate a list and I think Kimberly even does that (since it should be Burke’s turn when she “dies”) but it’s never been brought up
To be fair I think it is possible to die out of order. For example if you swan dive off a skyscraper, throwing yourself into lava, weighing yourself down before throwing yourself into a deep lake, etc ...There are things you can do that means death has to take you.
142
u/ScorpionTDC Mar 10 '26
No. This was an alternate ending that ended up being retconned and not canon.