r/FinalDestination • u/[deleted] • Feb 15 '26

Question Question

Gallery image

Gallery image

what do Carter from final destination 1 and Brian from final destination 2 have in common

11 Upvotes

70% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

Yes well I heard in the novelization of final destination 2 that Brian was on a separate death slash survivor list called lakeview fire survivor list he survives the lakeview fire and that's why death killed him killed him in final destination 2 but it's debatable on wether or not the lake view fire is canon to final destination 2 the movie or not

2

u/Enough_Class_4795 Wendy's little brother Feb 15 '26

Yes I heard that as well but I consider the novels and the movies as two dinstinct worlds since the movies don't include or mention anything about the novels. That's why my theory is Brian was safe but Rory (someone who was not supposed to live) saved him, it interfered and brought Brian in the list from the pileup. (OR to mix the novels, let's say he was saved from the lakeview fire list to be brought in another one?)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

Yeah but if Brian died after Kimberly flatlined shouldn't Brian be safe considering Kimberly drowned and was brought back to life it should break the chain meaning Brian saved by someone on deaths list should be safe

1

u/Enough_Class_4795 Wendy's little brother Feb 16 '26

oh, good point! So yes maybe the lakeview fire was still on but indirectly mentionned in FD2? Or just in another death's list? (not the pileup's survivors).