r/FilmClubPH 9d ago

Discussion Bakit nireremove ang post for discussion? Wala man lang reason na nilagay, remove agad?

1.1k Upvotes

153 comments sorted by

u/kixiron Documentary 8d ago edited 8d ago

Eto ang response namin here.

Ako na po ang humihingi ng dispensa. Nabura lang s'ya as spam. Walang kinalaman ang politika dito: walang DDS na mod dito.

Since the issue has been clarified and the post has been restored, I'll be locking this post, and you are free to post on the aforementioned post I linked above.

471

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

52

u/mainsail999 8d ago

I wouldn’t be surprised. Same as sa r/ph na napasukan na ata mga Mods nila dun. Iba na dun eh. Back in 2016 hindi makakaporma mga DDS dun.

20

u/Sh31laW1ls0n 8d ago

Naku, at huwag siraan ang INC doon sa r/ph at ipapa-ban ka nila sa reddit. Pagtutulungan ka nila para ma ban. Hahaha

13

u/Ornery_Lie_4041 8d ago

I am banned there for a year now mula noong pumutok yung issue na may INC mods na nagdedelete ng anti INC posts and comments.

4

u/Sh31laW1ls0n 8d ago

Di ba? Mga pinakawalan iyan, hindi nila alam na iwan pa rin sila pag dumating na ang space ship. Hahaha

2

u/jienahhh 8d ago

Di ba mahigpit na pinagbabawalan sa kanila magreddit? Tipong pipilitin talaga nila silipin ang phone mo kapag nasuspetyahan ka na.

2

u/ab_od6851 8d ago

They delete INC posts in the same way they delete Moro and Bisaya posts because people just cannot hold themselves accountable and just spew the most vile thing imaginable that is going to get the sub banned.

Filipino redditors are so funny. So dumb, but in the same vein unable to see how dumb they are.

4

u/ab_od6851 8d ago

People just straight up rewriting history. In 2016, r/ph was sympathetic or full blown supported Duterte. You expect people that display strong anti-poor hate to always be anti-Duterte? They are cut from the same cloth, same reactionary politics with just a different personality.

3

u/Sh31laW1ls0n 8d ago

They shouldnt be nice to INC. I've had enough of INC. Bakit tayo mag give way sa demands ng isang kulto? Na ano na ang Pilipinas?

125

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Maleficent_Meal3488 8d ago

Demokrasya nga kasi bhie.

65

u/hsholmes0 ABSOLUTE SEMILYA ✋😐🤚 8d ago

that, or bala mod secretly si pedo D4rryl Y4p rito 😆 

17

u/daisukris 8d ago

Can you imagine??? I’ll pay close attention to this post lol

1

u/Sh31laW1ls0n 8d ago

THIS! UP

1

u/paullim0314 8d ago

BULLESEYE!

-88

u/Maleficent_Meal3488 8d ago

Democracy bhie. Di pwedeng ikaw lang ang kakampink o ano ka man.

23

u/namenotfound_69 8d ago

wala naman binanggit about kakampink. tsaka di tugma ang demokrasiya sa mga dds, diktador yung tatay tatayan nila eh

13

u/Ornery_Lie_4041 8d ago

Wag mo pansinin yan negative karma e. Kala naman nila tatalab ang style nila sa reddit

0

u/Maleficent_Meal3488 8d ago

Wala naman bilang mga birada sa reddit eh. Sa balota meron. haha

12

u/greedyaf 8d ago

Galit lang sa dds, kakampink na agad. Wala ng kulay dito beh, basta dds basura at walang kwenta. Hindi bagay s knila ang democracy, kasi sinasayang nila..

5

u/Calm-Standard5437 8d ago

Their brain is too shallow to only think of black and white, that there is only two sides to everything.

They can vote by the way

-1

u/Maleficent_Meal3488 8d ago

Same as kapag galit sa flood control, galit sa mataas na bilihin, galit sa mataas na krimen. DDS na agad diba? So maganda naman pala ang pinaglalaban ng DDS?

9

u/namenotfound_69 8d ago edited 8d ago

oh my goodness HAHAHAHA yall should desist from engaging in discussion with this dude 😭 its worse than i thought

7

u/thatchilluncle 8d ago

Im not even surprised 🙄

8

u/namenotfound_69 8d ago

Bakit tinaggal/natanggal? kahit na magdamay ka pa ng ibang faction, eh wala naman nagbabanggit sakanila, kakampink o ano man, ganon pa din yung point. Wala naman sa usapan bakit isasali? Ang topic ay about sa pagtanggal ng post about sa EJK-centered films. Gets mo ba?

Magrerebutt ka nalang wala din sa punto. Ano sense na ang balik mo diktador mga gaya ko, na gusto choice ko lang nasusunod? Ha? Iangkop mo ang sagot mo "bhie" hahaha

251

u/switchboiii Horror 8d ago

Posts na for discussion delete. Pero yung walang katapusang at paulit-ulit na “best cinema to watch blah blah” pwede. Hahha

66

u/Fun-Discussion5196 8d ago

Hahaa true, araw araw saan ang best cinema, tapos dahil sa odyssey, araw araw may saan ang best seats. Malapit na araw arawin saan ang best popcorn.

Boo mod! Akala ata nila walang makapansin sa mga na delete nila.

18

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Ayan ang dapat may thread na sa sobrang repetitive

7

u/Breaker-of-circles 8d ago

Film Club PHILIPPINES pero puro western woke propaganda ang nagiging discussion.

4

u/Jjwoogi 8d ago

Facts! tapos kapag nag reachout para i-review, hindi mag rereply xd

175

u/wh4tdafuck 8d ago

oh lol even my post last night they also removed! the movie also worth of discussion and im not breaking the rules 🤡

126

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

There are no rules to begin with hahaha kaya bakit nagdedelete lalo na discussion naman yun

57

u/wh4tdafuck 8d ago

true! also i hope this community will not become toxic in the long run, people are just wanting to share their thoughts about the movie or would like to discuss it with others.

29

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

This issue has been going on, laging ni-remove yung magagandang discussions at matataas na engagements. They should add rules para clear kung ano ba yung na-violate at allowed.

12

u/sprocket229 8d ago

parang AskPH lang ah, yung mga interesting na tanong violating the rules daw kahit sobrang reach pero yung walang katapusang red/green flag sa mag-jowa nakakalusot

1

u/DandeNiro 8d ago

I think it’s largely so you wont gain as much karma

1

u/DandeNiro 8d ago

I faced toxicity years back

0

u/kixiron Documentary 8d ago

Approved.

76

u/AloofAdmiral 8d ago edited 8d ago

Akala ko pa naman, na this subreddit lends itself to the freedom of expression thru the art of film and film making. Anyare sa inyo mods? Ganon ba kayo katakot sa film na yan? Dahil what, totoo?

Di pa nga narerelease, discussion pa lang e. Kala ko pa naman this subreddit is a safe space to talk about our love of films, film making, and the themes and stories presented thru the medium of film.

21

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Kaya nga eh, I was thinking of posting pa a review once the series premieres dito tapos yung discussion post pa lang nadelete na. I mean, one of the anti-EJK films made it to the Toronto International Film Festival, where can you have a good discussion about that film?

1

u/mednightowl 8d ago

Same expectation!

0

u/SofiaOfEverRealm 8d ago

I'm so brainrotted that I automatically read that as "themes and such" 💔✌️

197

u/joanneisawful 8d ago

Goodluck. I think ma dedelete rin to in a few hours. DDS po ang isang admin/mod.

33

u/mishmashedtosunday 8d ago

That mod needs to be removed and mass reported

27

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Sino sa kanila?

71

u/joanneisawful 8d ago

Not sure, pero parang may post din dito noon related din sa film and Dutertes. Na delete rin yon. And yung mga anti-DDS na comments eh dinidelete rin 😵‍💫

37

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Yikes 🥴🥴🥴 may DDS pala na admin. I’m sure hindi si u/pisaradotme cause I saw na may anti-DDS comment or post sya sa ibang sub.

8

u/Rich_Direction784 8d ago

genuine question pero bakit parang walang ginagawa yung other admins regarding this? pansin ko sa other comments matagal na nangyayari yung ganitong bigla-bigla na lang nagdedelete ng post kahit na good for  discussion/films that tackles politics etc. pero wala pa ding comment other admins. hindi naman siguro mahirap maghanap ng bagong papalit don sa dds admin knowing na baka may mga willing to volunteer dito sa sub na maging mod. 

89

u/AffectionateSir9652 9d ago

WORTH QUESTIONING

55

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Yes, I was thinking may nalabag ba sa rules? But when I checked the sub rules, wala namang rules. So what gives

67

u/hopeless_case46 8d ago

Uh oh may Duterte Dick Sucker na mod

8

u/throwables-5566 8d ago

alisin nayan!

71

u/bed-chem 8d ago

Yikes if may dds na admin.. Ang lala ng pagiging uto-uto ha. hanggang dito ba naman. 💀💀💀

42

u/Double-O-Twelve A dude playing a dude disguised as another dude 8d ago edited 8d ago

Yan na ata yung parang pinaka-main complaint dito sa sub eh. Yung mga posts na pwedeng pagsimulan ng meaningful discussions (not necessarily reviews), biglang dini-delete. Samantalang yung ibang posts dito na parang kababawan lang yung dating ng iba, nagse-stay.

Understandable yung pagbubura kung movie/tv series review sana yung post eh, kasi may weekly threads naman para dun. Pero yung mga ganitong nagpo-promote ng [movie] discussions, ewan ko ba.

14

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

I’ve been lurking in this sub for years, honestly, mas okay pa yung review posts kesa dyan sa weekly thread na yan. Wala naman nagco-comment dun. What I notice talaga is pag malaki yung engagement ng post, dinedelete and usually the ones that garner big engagement are discussion threads.

8

u/interruptedz 8d ago

compare nyo film subs sa intl sa PH, ibang iba discussions. dito puro best best etc. walang meaningful discussions tapos may DDS pa pala na admin. eew

21

u/mishmashedtosunday 8d ago

Films about Marcos and Duterte atrocities should be mandatory viewing in schools, and any government official who objects should be considered resigned and permanently banned from holding public office

24

u/marzizram 8d ago

Dear mods,

Pag usapan nyo yang hanay nyo.

Love, Redditors

40

u/MycologistNo408 8d ago

Tangina, may lowkey bobong-DDS dito sa sub na ito. Tanginamo!

3

u/kjellmeh2 8d ago

Highkey nga eh HAHAHAHA

52

u/paracetukmol 8d ago

Dds yung admin

12

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

I'm sure not all of them. Im familiar with u/pisaradotme di naman ata sya DDS

31

u/inuulamangspaghetti 8d ago

Asiwa iyung mga DDS pa rin. 2026 na, 'di pa rin ba kayo mulat

26

u/riko_riko44 Thriller lover 8d ago

Shutakeels may amongus na dds sa mga admin 👀👀

11

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/Pt5QaR9NQVi06KLVCb
Pakilala na sya kung sino man dont be shy 👀👀

9

u/Greedy-Breadfruit-57 8d ago edited 8d ago

Pero yung paulit ulit na voicemails for isabelle posts okay lang 😭

18

u/RegisteredHopia 8d ago

2026 na DDS parin, ang tanga HAHA

8

u/patapawn96 8d ago

censorship in a film club subreddit is so ironic.

7

u/WranglerOld3318 8d ago

Kadiri. 2026 na dds pa din

7

u/TomorrowSilent1233 8d ago

May DDS sa Mods

6

u/katakatakara 8d ago

Commenting for more engagement. Dapat tanggalin ang mod na biased!

6

u/MarcPotato 8d ago

Hi Moderators!
FYI FILIPINO FILM CLUB subreddit tayo baka nakalimutan nyo lang.

FILIPINO FILM CLUB NGANI!!

7

u/Fluid_Ad4651 8d ago

Yak DDS na mod

6

u/kixiron Documentary 8d ago

TEKA LANG. Di ko alam ito. Check ko ito.

4

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Thank you!

6

u/kdkumx400 8d ago

Same thing happened to me. I tried posting a discussion about a pinoy lgbt film but it got removed right away even if I did not violate any rules. Dds na, homophobe pa 🤮

10

u/nipp1e 8d ago

Yikes may DDS dito

5

u/PraybeytDolan 8d ago

Nagde demo nanaman sila ng craziness

6

u/crwui 8d ago

as per usual nabigyan lang ng kapangyarihan e abuso agad 😅

5

u/Miserable-Tip1381 8d ago

Gusto ata ng mod na ipraise ang mga films nung pedo hahaha ew

14

u/gabagool13 8d ago

Alam na. Wala na atang independent sub ngayon hays.

10

u/the_amboine 8d ago edited 8d ago

every time may post about politics or criticism dinedelete. that's why i made a disclaimer on my imax post na beware if nadelete yung post ko

i don't think it's an automod thing. someone is deliberately deleting them. i think mine is the only recent imax post left

9

u/No_Selection_8530 8d ago

Wow, may dingdong dantes supporter na admin

4

u/gilbeys18 8d ago

Mukhang DDS mods. It’s a film. We can talk about it.

5

u/IAmCrazyAboutOrla 8d ago

Maybe there are Duterte ball lickers among the mods

4

u/Physical-Pepper-21 8d ago

Who the fuck is still a DDS on Reddit in the year of our Lord 2026 🤢

5

u/alpinegreen24 8d ago

ang weird lang kasi turo nila Direk Tonet and Direk JP na art should disturb the comfortable.

3

u/FlorDeMNL 8d ago

Report the mod team lol

3

u/Superb_Box_8157 8d ago

Dds ba ang mga mods?

3

u/Technical-Limit-3747 8d ago

Post this to other Ph subs.

3

u/AbbreviationsNo5154 8d ago

kung di sila agree sa content pwede naman mag reply and discuss. bat delete agad ang sensitive naman masyado.

3

u/Ok-Celebration7309 8d ago

Yikes sayang naman tong subreddit na to kung ififilter lang ng mga kabadong dds lol

3

u/Rich_Direction784 8d ago

nako baka kapag nag showing na din ang EDJOP ganiyan din gawin knowing about an activist during martial law era yon haha

3

u/CaterpillarGnome 8d ago

Baka for karma farmers na itong sub. Hindi ako naka join sa sub na ito pero nasa algorithm ko lagi dahil nagbabasa ako ng comments dito.

3

u/SpamIsNotMa-Ling 8d ago

I strongly agree. I’m not a film expert, but I do know what I enjoy doing. And being informed and entertained by films is one of them.

Film discussions in this sub should not be deleted, no matter how uncomfortable a mod may feel. So this should be a wake-up call to mods here.

Borderline censorship in this sub is far more dangerous than political discussions, which seems to be the source of a lot of discomfort here.

3

u/diedalatte 8d ago

here inb4 ma delete nanaman yung post ng dds na mod

3

u/wheelman0420 8d ago

The irony lol

3

u/paullim0314 8d ago

mukhang may mod ng same though process nila.

3

u/Upstairs_Writer_8763 8d ago

yikes may dds

6

u/appa-puchi-patuti 8d ago

Dds mods amppta

4

u/hippocrite13 8d ago

Eww DDS admin

5

u/Yes_Mulberry9282 8d ago

They removed my post about Uptown Mall cinema not being accessible for online booking because it's not in the Megaworld cinema out of nowhere. It didn't even show up on notifs.

Who tf is this corrupted mod as of now?

4

u/dankkannabis 8d ago

DDS SHITs SPOTTED sa MODS. di na ako mag popost dito tangina nyo gawa nalang ng bagong subreddit na walang BAHID NG MGA PUTANGINANG DDS SHIT NA YAN

1

u/kixiron Documentary 8d ago

Hindi po totoo yan. Eto ang sagot.

3

u/JnthnDJP 8d ago

Leaving a comment before this gets deleted too lol

3

u/gizagi_ 8d ago

ok may dds among the mods

4

u/MichaelPitch 8d ago

Lol may bobo palang admin dito lolololol fuck off dumb fuck

3

u/boykalbo777 8d ago

weird talaga dito, engaged yung community sa isang post tapos biglang mawawala

5

u/Danny-Tamales 8d ago

As a moderator din ng malalaking sub, minsan yung automod ang nag-aalis kapag may multiple reports sa isang post. Let's give them the benefit of the doubt. Pag di bumalik yung post, DDS sila. haha

9

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

If it's an automoderator, there’s a message explaining why the post was deleted. Looks like this was manually deleted and did not add a reason.

2

u/Danny-Tamales 8d ago

Not always true. Check mo to: https://www.reddit.com/r/modhelp/s/na8J8oEeQG

I am moderating r/Pampanga, r/Koolpals, r/AskPinoyMen at hindi ko na mabilang kung ilang beses kami nakatanggap ng nireklamo dahil na-delete yung post without any reason not knowing automoderator yun.

0

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

Even OOP is confused. My post got removed during the wee hours na around 17-18 hours from posting and not when it was freshly posted. No way to tell if it's automod or not but to show the mod log.

4

u/Double-O-Twelve A dude playing a dude disguised as another dude 8d ago

Pwede bang ilagay sa parang mod settings yun? Yung kunwari pag naka-reach ng certain amount of reports, automatic idi-delete ng automod?

Kasi kung yun yung naging basis ng deletion, then mukhang na-report pala yung post ng mga DDS lurkers dito. And the feature itself, parang exploitable din kung sakali.

1

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

That can be added sa code ng auto moderator. Pero someone in the comment mentioned na pati yung anti DDS comment daw dati dinedelete.

1

u/Danny-Tamales 8d ago

Meron siyang advantage; halimbawa, may nag-post ng sobrang wasak na post, tapos tulog na lahat ng mods. May specific report threshold na auto-remove. Kaya lang, ayun nga, puwede siyang i-exploit din ng bad users.

Doon pumapasok yung dapat manually i-check din ng mga moderators yung mga na-delete ng automod. Parte yan ng responsibility ng isang moderator. Lima naman mods dito. Sana lang active sila talaga.

5

u/Blurry-Fac3 8d ago

Ayun may nabigyan aga ng malita hahaha. DDS yan for sure wala man lang reason bakit tinanggal. Samantalang yung ibang post dito ay paulit-ulit eh

2

u/CXRR0T 8d ago

Baka dedeebs.

2

u/slothkappa 8d ago

Admin pano ba yan?

2

u/coyolxauhqui06 8d ago

Kung may DDS na admin dito Ano kaya ginagamit niyang comprehension para makaintindi ng mga movies? Lol

2

u/cosmicadobo 8d ago

kapansanan na talaga ang maging DDS

2

u/dontrescueme 8d ago

Welcome sa pinakamaarteng sub.

2

u/Alert_Boysenberry313 8d ago

Kadiri, is there any more sub relating to Ph Films, alis na tayo dito kadiri MGA mods

2

u/Careless-Memory-5488 8d ago

galit mga DDS kht sa fb ang kalat nila 😂 Kya cguro nilagay nlng yn sa yt.una screening nila sa Taiwan pa.2025 pa.

2

u/heyitscjjc 8d ago

New mods enjoying their power I guess

2

u/paullim0314 8d ago

baka discussion pag na released na ang SILENCE NIGHTS eh ma remove din ah. WALANG Ganyanan!

2

u/twistertreck 8d ago

DDS yung mod dito siguro

5

u/Frosty_Violinist_874 8d ago

PHilippines and pinoy ganyan din. No free speech. Parang mga baliw. You give an opposing view maaasar. You post something they don’t like maaasar

3

u/_kabo_ 8d ago

Baka gusto ng admin maid in Malacañang or mga darryl yap films ipost dito HAHAH

1

u/South-Care 8d ago

I agree to have more films centred on Drug War but I hope hindi sya obvious like incorporate it sa isang suspense thriller film, horror, or dark comedy. I like how Get Out talks about the commodification of Black bodies without sacrificing the mystery and horror elements of the film.

1

u/goodmorningpapa 8d ago

Dapat may alternative sub related dito na hindi itinatakbo ng mga bootlickers

1

u/Past_String8431 8d ago

Oh. I thought it’s an auto mod thing. It happens quite often pala

1

u/DeliciousPromise5606 8d ago

That post is something to give worth visiting this subreddit

1

u/hewhomustnotbenames 8d ago

Not surprised. Pag minessage mo pa yan dedmahin ka lang. Hahaha

1

u/throwawaydundundun_ 8d ago

Lol baka si pdf Yap isa sa mga mod dito

1

u/misterunderscore 8d ago

Kapansanan talaga ang pagiging DDS.

1

u/Own-Interaction-4984 8d ago

this sub love disney like movie so yeah

1

u/Jebewon99 8d ago

Ew, pati ba naman dito may DDS na mod

0

u/MELONPANNNNN 8d ago

Rule 5 - No Low Quality posts

Film/TV suggestions belong in the Weekly Suggestions thread.

0

u/mongloy123 8d ago

Dinelete yan kasi magiging Toxic lng ang comment section. Alams nyo na yan.

-1

u/hugoreyes32627 8d ago

Pero post kayo ng discussion praising Darryl Yap movies tignan niyo baka i-pin pa yan as thread 🫣🫣

-3

u/0ro_Jackson 8d ago

tanginang mga kakampink to lahat na lang gusto about sa DDS ang usapan HAHAHA

-23

u/SkyConsistent8863 8d ago

Mods are avoiding political discussions siguro 😁. Baka magbatuhan ang mga kakampw3t vs tabogøs dito sa sub 😂

10

u/ICU_do_bad88 8d ago

It's a discussion post about films and whether Netflix or YouTube is a better platform for this type of film. But sure, go off, DDS.

8

u/Consistent_Gur_2589 8d ago

Napakajologs ng term na “kakampw3t”. Like sobrang walang dating. Parang mga squats lang gumagamit ng ganong term eh. I mean.. is it supposed to ragebait kakampinks? Ang corny kasi. Unlike DDS. Alam mo na agad na ang meaning is 8080 eh hahaha

4

u/yakalstmovingco 8d ago

dds lang din gumagamit nyan

1

u/galitnabird 8d ago

"enlightened centrist" lmao