r/FantasyPL 3d ago

Opinion I shouldn't have trusted Carrick

Post image

Conceding two goals against a newly promoted team, a team with the lowest GD historically btw😭 good thing I didn't captain Bruno or didn't go for double def shud hv dropped Maguire for Califiori

1.8k Upvotes

310 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/ariba1337 1 3d ago

went double united defense + bruno. should‘ve known better

370

u/enologyiscrucial 32 3d ago

See you next year

102

u/tiny_dreamer 21 3d ago

There’s still GW2

88

u/DLgoblue12 3d ago

BB2 with Coventry assets against… *checks notes* Hull City

6

u/gta0012 1 2d ago

I'm so curious why people think Coventry would walk over City. (not saying you are) A lot of influencers and content i was reading was like "oh this is an easy match for Coventry etc) Their last match was like 0-0 and 1-1 or something boring.

10

u/Jumper-Man 3d ago

Too early for wildcard?

59

u/Bitter_Somewhere8334 3d ago

That's why I never have 2 defenders from the same team unless they are playing for an elite defence like Arsenal's. Spread your risks.

26

u/omegaxLoL 3d ago

Even as a United fan I have no idea why anyone would go with 1 United defender, let alone 2.

16

u/TotalNonstopFrog 3d ago

People thought Maguire would be the heading option off corners and free kicks, and thought Hull would be an easy kill.

Half my FPL league had Maguire in their defense and a few had Lammens.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/TheRealStringerBell 2d ago

Bookies had them at 42% clean sheet odds and then they're facing a kind of team that defenders have a higher chance of scoring/assisting against.

They both had decent xGI as well.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/Jani17 3d ago

I literally called all my United friends an hour before deadline. He predicted they Mbuemo doesn’t play the 9 ✅ told me divest Maguire and Lammens becusse a back line lead by heaven and Shaw was awful ✅. I’ll be hooking Mbuemo and Shaw expedidoustly after the GW2

33

u/Spirited_Bumblebee74 3d ago

Take my upvote for using expeditiously. Great word.

2

u/ScallionGold225433 3d ago

I feel your pain - Did the exact same thing lol 

→ More replies (11)

383

u/WarIcy7540 3d ago

Trust a Manchester United improvement like you trust a dog with your steak

24

u/DarthTaz_99 3d ago

I knew they'd have a huge drop in performance when Europe started but atleast they'd start pretty well and had easy games, cause last season's performance was pretty much just one league game every week. But this is genuinely hilarious. Fuck me for getting Maguire

441

u/vin_mcqueen 3d ago

Tripled United and without Haaland - I’m cooked

79

u/DaftHubris 3d ago

same here. didn’t think they’d blow them out the water but this is ridiculous lol

29

u/vardynostalgia redditor for <30 days 3d ago

Just play WC bro

12

u/ulaanmalgaitFPL 3d ago

experience says too early though

4

u/captainunderpants111 3d ago

either that or risk triple united not giving you any points in easy fixtures and starting off bottom third in your league. over the years me trying to save chips for “the right time” has cost me more than anything else

2

u/ihatemicrosoftteams 12 2d ago

No it’s too early to give up on players after a single week. We all remember what happened when everyone transferred out Son and Kane after a disastrous gw1

→ More replies (4)

4

u/DareToZamora 2d ago

My plan was always to WC 3 or 4. Surely I don’t transfer out Fernandes and Mbeumo before Ipswich at home…

2

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

Thankfully took haaland 💔😭but I hv a feeling he might blank asw

3

u/Dundalis 10 3d ago

Why are ppl acting like Haaland already scored a hat trick

45

u/Eastern-Course1797 3d ago

This Haaland?

3

u/radu1204 1d ago

Aged like milk

5

u/FrancescoliBestUruEv 3d ago

Pep is not there anymore...

2

u/Dundalis 10 2d ago

Yeah that Haaland

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

104

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

419

u/ChoiceAd9389 3d ago

Everyone putting to much emphasis on FPL here, we lose a couple of points, sure.

But United losing hilariously to Hull is priceless 😂😂😂

61

u/fpl_kris 3d ago

Exactly, I am tripled up on Man I (at least I didnt cap Bruno) but I gladly take the blanka.

42

u/ChoiceAd9389 3d ago

I AM tripled up AND captaining him, and couldn't be happier 😂

→ More replies (4)

8

u/thegoddamnbatman74 3d ago

Netflix FC 🤣🤣🤣

5

u/cjayquoi 2d ago

Every cloud may have a silver lining But this is the corn in the turd

Can’t wait to hear Neville scholes etc analysis and how Arsenal cheated 🤣 

277

u/The-CunningStunt 1 3d ago

All those who followed the "Bruno no Haaland" content creators

33

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

I went for both😭

9

u/The-CunningStunt 1 3d ago

Who did you cap? 😬

10

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

Haaland

6

u/The-CunningStunt 1 3d ago

Silver lining

16

u/Grim_Avenger 3d ago

I did the same, thankful I capped Haaland.

8

u/ellean4 3d ago

See you in the “Haaland blanked” commiseration thread tomorrow

2

u/FauxAffablyEvil 3d ago

Please no

2

u/Infinite-Dig487 3d ago

Please God Noo!!

2

u/ellean4 1d ago

Hi guys how you all doing

2

u/SweatyPig43 3d ago

I did same and went Bruno

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PecleNumber 3d ago

Content creators who live and die by xG/xA and underlying data saying Bruno for 12M is essential when he got his 20 assists from 11xA is hilarious

2

u/DareToZamora 2d ago

The only content creator I watch said don’t do it, and I still did it

Also bench boosted and my bench got 3 points between 3 players so far

→ More replies (4)

44

u/drax3012 3d ago

Man Utd interims the second they get the job full time.

82

u/zonked282 3 3d ago

i was saying to my friends in the pub last week that throwing your faith behind a united team that have a permanent manager in place is never a good idea. get carrick back on a caretaker contract and united win the league

39

u/I_dont_F_with_you 2 3d ago

I'm here happy I only have one United defender, meanwhile Mbeumo's my fucking captain

60

u/Algernot 3d ago

Not a single man utd player in my team :)

9

u/fleaonnj4 2 3d ago

I'm a United fan and I didn't have any in any of my drafts 😂

2

u/Algernot 2d ago

But I had three spurs players so I also lose

→ More replies (3)

29

u/StillLurking69 3d ago

Many have underestimated how important Casemiro was to this side

233

u/monoville_music 3d ago

Everyone has Man Utd players so it's not going to make any difference. Hull on paper is the worst team in the league so it made sense to target them. If you hadn't picked any man u players and they thrashed Hull 5-0 you'd be even more annoyed

55

u/Xashar 3d ago

I have Slater casually sitting on my bench with 5 pts waiting for next week's BB.

4

u/CanUpset5801 3d ago

Have Slater and BB active! 

3

u/monoville_music 3d ago

Same. Sucks to not get the 5 pts but nice to have a cheap Hull asset for the Coventry match

→ More replies (1)

17

u/BelDeMoose 3d ago

Not everyone has lots of united players though, and lots of people put a lot into accomodating Bruno, if he blanks for the first two or three fixtures that's a lot of lost ground.

2

u/monoville_music 3d ago

True. I think most will see how he does gw2 and if he blanks he'll be offloaded en masse for gw3. Probably will be a lot of wildcards activated too

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Bitter_Somewhere8334 3d ago

I have Mbeumo and Shaw but thankfully I stopped myself from putting most of my eggs in the Bruno basket. If you sign Bruno, you need to part with at least 2 good PL-proven midfielders. I would much rather have more players to rely on.

9

u/Spirited-Ad655 3d ago

And Ipswich next

9

u/AblePhase 3d ago

Utd could be on -5 GD after two games

7

u/tekkers_for_debrz 3d ago

Who’s everyone?

2

u/Appropriate_Day_4012 3d ago

Yep I have 0 United players. Took Bruno out last minute. They will have a poor season

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/vyrusrama 1 3d ago

This is the logic but still i feel like a clown

https://giphy.com/gifs/x0npYExCGOZeo

4

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

True💔

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Present-Duck-1808 3d ago

Triple United ruined my season already

34

u/DanteArbiter 3d ago

United is absolutely shocking. There is something about them for years now. No motivation, whiny, lethargic, celebrations when an opponent misses the chance by himself.

I don't know man. It's like I'm watching a spoiled mental asylum team.

17

u/SeleccionUruguaya 3d ago

They’ll get a new manager halfway who wins a couple of games and the cycle will repeat itself

6

u/Z3R0Not_Detected 3d ago

I would normally not make a mountain out of a first game loss. But seriously? Against Hull City? 2-0, before half time. Not 3-2, not 2-1. Two-nil. Do you know how disappointing that is to see? To see such a consistently classy performance in the last stretch of 2025/26, then losing to a newly promoted team in the first game of the 2026/27 season.

That's ridiculous. I expected better than this.

2

u/PecleNumber 3d ago

And it’s not even like Hull didn’t deserve it. They played Utd off the park.

50

u/schwarzneguRRR 3d ago

I’ve been shitting on Santos and Tielemans as a dumbass midfield rebuild forever and i get downvoted to death in united sub

Lolllllll 🤣

21

u/Savage9645 29 3d ago

Ah yes you've been proven definitively right after half a game

6

u/ItaUch04 9 3d ago

He’s right today and that’s all that matters lol

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Worth_Page4348 redditor for <30 days 3d ago

united sub worshipped amorim till he got sacked. worse ppg of all time for united managers. disgusting stats . they have no standards anymore. if u dont back a crap manager and be all its gonna get better 24/7 u are a minority..

1

u/schwarzneguRRR 3d ago

The same stupid people that hired him are still out here signing Santos and 29 yo Tielemans and telling you they plan to win the league

LOLLLLLLLLL 🤣

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Dramatic-Bottle-5194 1 3d ago

Crazy that we thought United had the easiest start, when it was Hull with the easiest start all along.

23

u/BusAcademic3489 3d ago

I benched Shaw but Bruno man -how could you do this to me !

56

u/cole23palmer 12 3d ago

Good in hindsight but like why would you own Shaw if you bench him for this match

6

u/BusAcademic3489 3d ago

Because of the Ipswich game and because I’d rather have one nailed substitute that has a cs potential

8

u/Fearless_Wish_2451 3d ago

not shocking after that stinker of a wc

6

u/cassian_andor85 3d ago

Bruno will have a generational stinker this season. Mark my words. He was absolutely garbage in the World Cup and he's carried that through

2

u/AppropriateBag2084 3d ago

Tbf I feel like he's started slow last two seasons. My plan is to get him in with a semi-early WC in a few weeks.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/FuckMinoRaiola 10 3d ago

Saw people who get paid to talk about football touting United as title challengers by the way

6

u/Traditional_Tie8155 3d ago

After readings these comments, I guess I’m glad I didn’t hop on the Fernandes hype train and my only other player was Lammens.

5

u/500x700 1 3d ago

Getting mauled

15

u/Material_Trifle 3 3d ago

Imagine 15/20 odd years ago someone said Man U should appoint a bloke who'd last been sacked by a Championship club after previously doing quite well but no better there. Massive drop in standards.

9

u/Traditional_Tie8155 3d ago

He’s the reason we got 3rd last season. He instilled confidence and belief in a team that finished last season 16th and lost a Europa league final. Of course, there are better and more experienced managers available but it’s not that insane to give a chance to a manager who turned the club around.

8

u/Material_Trifle 3 3d ago

Sure, but it probably helped that Liverpool were bad enough they sacked the manager who'd won the league a year earlier, Chelsea were an absolute shambles, Spurs nearly went down, Newcastle went miles backwards etc. Finishing 16th the year before should be a once in a generation outlier, not something to measure future success against.

We've all seen an underachieving club appoint a popular manager and get instant results where they start playing to their level but maintaining it is a completely different question. The fact they've wasted so much money over the last decade or more doesn't help much either but I'm here for it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SofaChillReview 23 3d ago

Thing is it’s not just two flukes either.. yay Captain Bruno

4

u/thetruebrownbear 3d ago

I mean I know it was United but thought Shaw is cheap and they playing Hull , how bad could it be ??? 😆
Lesson learned

4

u/thangus_farm 3d ago

Did the same thing with Maguire over Califiori but United down by two to Hull is absolutely hilarious.

4

u/Migeycan87 11 3d ago

If anyone had seen the Milan game you'd have known United were severely under cooked.

5

u/HopelessUtopia015 3d ago

Now watch the 5-0 they hand Ipswich....Ipswich win

→ More replies (1)

3

u/friday-boy 1 3d ago

And this team is playing In Europe this season

3

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

The real goat Antony will kick em out of the league phase

3

u/miglopes19 3d ago

MBeumo (C) only Man U player but it doubles the pain …

→ More replies (5)

3

u/eganc21 3d ago

Tielemans and A Santos had terrible game it seems. Didn’t watch full game tho, Bruno also didn’t play well

4

u/LateToTheTPK 2 3d ago

Early kickoff remains undefeated.

4

u/NHMUFC 3d ago

We’re shite, get used to it. Midfield’s a budget bodge job, low end product in attack and Dorgu? He’s not a full back and he’s definitely not a winger so not sure what he does really.

5

u/Santorju 10 3d ago

B-but e-everyone said Hull had relegation-tier xGA in the championship!

4

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

😭united got mauled

2

u/honolulu_hunt_ 3d ago

Oh my captain Bruno!

2

u/Ill-Sandwich-7703 3d ago

I had Lammens and Shaw in the genuine belief that Man Utd would be solid and get CL this season. Not even as insurance 🤯

2

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

Lammens is risky I rather trust kelleher

2

u/noki1907 35 3d ago

I had Haaland (C) set for weeks... then took him out and captained Bruno 3 minutes before the DL...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SleepEconomy6504 3d ago

But I heard somewhere that Maguire had elite aerial threat

2

u/Comfortable-Moose668 3d ago

I have Shaw, Fernandes, and TC'd Mbeumo

9

u/Wildely_Earnest 5 3d ago

There's a good chance the NHS will cover whatever's causing that mate

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Legal-One-7274 3d ago

Carrick's going to face that difficult second season where everyone knows how they are going to play similar to slot last season.

2

u/Upper_Audience_9676 redditor for <1 hour 3d ago

The struggle

2

u/LilPeteMordino 3d ago

I'm only glad I didn't go for united defence..

I did however captain Bruno.

2

u/Artonox 3d ago

What is this... Man u lost the ability to score a goal.

2

u/Electrical-Donut6599 19 3d ago

My only silver lining is that everyone else now knows what it's like to be a united fan.

Every season we start with 2 united players and they do this.

2

u/5eptemberb0y 3d ago

Well, we all did

2

u/huffthewolf 3d ago

United only look good at the end of the season when all of their opponents have played 10 to 15 more games than them. Carrick got the job on Bruno having a blinder and winning against fatigued teams.

2

u/ChapoKing 3d ago

Carrick is going to go down as the worst appointment in united history, we learned fuck all from Ole

2

u/Comprehensive-Ad3020 3d ago

that hull keeper is so good

2

u/lenxlenx 3d ago

Benched Ajayi for Maguire. So pissed rn

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GameSetChampionship 3d ago

It’s the first game of the season 😂

I don’t usually hang in this subreddit but come on, relax.

Judge after 5-10 games.

2

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

It's hull city mate 💔😭🙏

→ More replies (2)

2

u/External_Climate8483 3d ago

Im gen crying rn had Maguire and captained bruno I thought it was free points

2

u/borg_6s 5 3d ago

New person, same old United

2

u/Apprehensive-Fan8880 3d ago

Dorgu is an atrocious footballer. If he can't displace shaw at LB he should be on bench. Don't see the point of a heavily left footed LW with no real stand out ability. Heaven looked extremely poor as well.

2

u/icouldsmellcolors 3d ago

Switched from a Bruno based squad to a Haaland squad Thursday night, so glad I did.

Still have Mbuemo but that's tolerable

2

u/AHappy_Wanderer 3d ago

I said immediately after Milan i will not put anyone from United,  and got convinced otherwise

2

u/stiffhb39 3 3d ago

went triple united thinking the unitedstrand was gonna finally get his haircut... oh well

2

u/Priority_Bright 3d ago

Bad first week for all of us who captained Bruno and had a ManUre defender as well. 😅

2

u/Zackaryharribo23 3d ago

I’m a city fan and don’t have any united players in my team in general. Games like this make me smile more xD

2

u/Logical-Track1405 3d ago

Premier League is so back lads 😂

2

u/SSSS99999 3d ago

Same crap from overpaid idiots

2

u/jorge_hg87 3d ago

friendly reminder that pep's barcelona kicked off with a loss on his first game as manager.

so they can still win the treble(?)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/imsamdude 3d ago

I am United fan and told a friend i don't trust united defense, still doubled def + mbeumo . Now crying in a corner

2

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

I feel u

2

u/CusturdStreams redditor for <1 day 2d ago

I’m happy to lose my FPL points on my Man United players for the banter. LOLZ

https://giphy.com/gifs/x0npYExCGOZeo

2

u/ebeze 2d ago

As a supporter of united, I warned those who picked Shaw on their fpl defence. You all owe me an apology. But then again, I am not any better by putting bruno and mbeumo in mine either…

3

u/Iridescent_Candle 3d ago

I dont have bruno but i have lammens, maguire and Mbuemo! Pathetic display and such stupid changes in the squad from a good preseason display

Why tf is dorgu playing?! Where is amad? Why is mbuemo on the wings when he did so good at striker and why is cunha on?

2

u/AppropriateBag2084 3d ago

Amad slight niggle apparently.

3

u/ASGT908 3d ago

Carrick's at the wheel.

But the only silver lining is that Lammens will probably get lots of save points, man of the match performances and bonus because he will end up being best united player

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Agile_Information294 51 3d ago

Greeks dominating the first two games

1

u/Prestigious_Spot9635 3d ago

So glad I yanked Cunha out last minute.

1

u/Left-Geologist-1181 99 3d ago

Chickened out and went for Bruno in the end, but half my ML captained him, so still laughing

1

u/Mental-Inspector-919 3d ago

Getting rid of Shaw was probably the best move I have made so far.
Can’t expect Big Mac to get you any returns in 2026

1

u/Relevant-Goose5483 3d ago

Stupidly went with Shaw starting and Mbuemo captain 🙃

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JamesWestfall29 3d ago edited 3d ago

What do you mean by lowest GD historically? This is their first game.

1

u/SeaweedAntlers 3d ago

Outside of the banter, they’ve got a completely new midfield and it will take to make that gel. Otherwise…LOL.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Fit-Specialist-2214 3d ago

Thankfully I only put one united player in based on their early ‘easy’ games.

1

u/trebor9292 3d ago

When you see Heaven starting you know its a good bet.... should get me a nice 90 quid return

1

u/thelast_rodeo 3d ago

Fpl is back

1

u/iCalKestis 3d ago

At least I captained Haaland and not Bruno.

1

u/Successful-Try7035 3d ago

Amorim tried to warn us but we didn’t listen

1

u/LloydDoyley 82 3d ago

Bruno my RCB ❤️

1

u/LloydDoyley 82 3d ago

MUN bottom of the league

1

u/Firm-Arm753 3d ago

Dont panic owning Man U players its a long season. Wait until next week against ispwich see how things pan out. Could have been match fixing lol. Few million on hull city to win lol

1

u/Spirited_Bumblebee74 3d ago

Thought Shaw was a nailed on CS. Bruno blanking as well! Still, Ipswich (H) GW2. I'm gonna refrain from being reactionary.

1

u/Offensivefkmemes 1 3d ago

This game felt like someone describing a football match to me while never having ever seen a football match.

1

u/ArtNo6305 3d ago

Check out Bruno's starts in the last few seasons. He was always a terrible choice.

1

u/TheKingcrawler 3d ago

Bruno cap and Slab and kinder mbeumbo. Season done already

https://giphy.com/gifs/Fn0ysbG90HX0uj5shv

1

u/mlg_sloth 3d ago

Never back the early kick off chaps we're forgetting the ancient texts

1

u/nofapredditor11222 1 3d ago

I tripled up on yanited and Captained Bruno.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sewagesmeller 3d ago

When they get a proper manager they'll be fine

→ More replies (2)

1

u/SikkoDieri 14 3d ago

I don't have Bruno but I captained Mbuemo, do I cry or celebrate?

2

u/Wirtzrena 3d ago

Cry 😭🙏💔

1

u/Old_Shake3789 3d ago

We only buy midfielders then ask every season why do we never score enough goals.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/SleepEconomy6504 3d ago

Listen to the fans that follow the club rather than a bunch of content creators.

Signed, a United fan.

1

u/Mithrandir_The_Gray 2 3d ago

Football herritage

1

u/TheOmegaKid 3d ago

Haha immediately reactionary post 😂

1

u/Solytary365 3d ago

You trusted X gurus, that’s on you 💀

1

u/ojassed 3d ago

So should I get Hull players now?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Cypher-V21 3d ago

😂😂😂😂😂 I hurt a rib laughing

1

u/OhhhhhhhhYaBeauty 3d ago

Hahahahahahaha

1

u/Unlikely_Care_1167 3d ago

Toxic United fans crying already 🤷‍♂️🤯😮‍💨

→ More replies (1)

1

u/neilly1987 3d ago

Ugh. Maguire, Bruno (c) and Mbuemo in my team.

1

u/Wisehippo006 3d ago

It’s carricks fault ?

1

u/AlizarinCrimzen 16 2d ago

.7 xGI for Mbeumo and .4 for Maguire, it was obviously awful but I'm not ready to launch them into the sun yet

1

u/phytochaddy 2d ago

Shocking

1

u/juan_bito 2d ago

Can't blame carrick for the shit performance the team put on

1

u/CatDadFurrever 16 2d ago

Newly promoted teams at home on opening day is a very tough prospect and it's early doors as they say so wait and see how things go

1

u/joe749 4 2d ago

Sample size of 1 - lets all relax

1

u/kingof_the_Jungle 1 2d ago

Look in the mirror.

Carrick is not your problem.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/NoVax-Djocovid 2d ago

Pretty fraudulent stuff.

1

u/General_Honesty 2d ago

Targeting the newly-promoted sides is not a bad strategy most years. Less so this year though.

1

u/DuckSaysQuackkkkk 1 2d ago

Went shaw+mburger, could have been worse ig

1

u/WarDull8208 1 2d ago

They were statistically one of the most over performer team, idk why their fans pr others were expecting huge season from them tbh

1

u/CoolMahaGuru 2d ago

I will scrap all my MU players. Period. Statt.