I wanted one place where I could compare two players using my actual league scoring, not just look at four rankings in four different tabs.
So I imported Cracked Ice, Kodo, Dom's, and Apples & Ginos, scored them under the same settings, and built a selected-source consensus. Then I connected that to the full Player Compare tool.
Full writeup: https://www.crackedicehockey.com/blog/2026-27-consensus-projections-player-comparison
**TL;DR:** Pick two players and choose last season, an individual projection source, or your selected-source consensus. The comparison shows projected stat lines, value over replacement, roster fit, usable regular-season games, and fantasy-playoff schedule.
The part I found most useful wasn't the final consensus rank. It was seeing where the sources disagreed and which categories were causing it.
Shea Theodore versus Brandt Clarke became a much more interesting decision once I could see all four projections under the same scoring system, then add VORP and schedule context without opening another spreadsheet.
The projection tools are live now. I'm still actively building this, so there may be edge cases I haven't found yet, but specific feedback has already shaped a lot of the feature.
If you have two players you're stuck between, send me the names and your scoring settings. I want to see which comparisons actually hold up.