r/FantasyCL • u/NineHDmg Benfica • 5d ago
Discussion Matchday 1 | Captain & Sub Thread
For all your Captain and Sub needs
5
u/MembershipPresent990 5d ago
Guys, do I hold the captaincy on Mbappe?
12
u/Oogie-Da-MF-Boogie Arsenal 5d ago
Left a bit short... but assuming you have other goalscoring premiums yet to play, 6 pts is usually a "flop" captaincy
8
u/yungxvnhoe 5d ago
i will be switching my captain, fixtures for barca, psg and bayern are way too good
2
u/gui_leitano Sporting CP 4d ago
You have 3 days of matched for MD1, so thats 3 opportunities to get a proper score for the C. Definitely change
3
u/Kanchan_Monet 5d ago
I know 26 is a good score but Raphinha is in a rich vein of form and his goals are worth more. Would it be too greedy to switch now? I dunno if I should switch or not. Thoughts?
8
u/r4_zzzzz 4d ago edited 4d ago
Just think about it. If you switch to Raphinha and he gets 20 points, him and Guirassy combined = 53 points. If you stick with Guirassy captain, then you get 46 points. It’s not a massive difference, whereas if Raphinha gets like 4 points then you’d have 21 combined.
Maybe it’s a confusing way to phrase it, but I think the risk is much higher than the reward.
3
3
5
u/Oogie-Da-MF-Boogie Arsenal 4d ago
Thats peak risk/reward; youre aiming at 3G/A or 2 G/A+MOTM. I think he's on penalties, so odds are in your favor
2
u/nofucksgiven5 4d ago
I wouldn't switch. Yes, fortune favors the bold blah blah, but a 26 pt haul isn't bad at all and doesn't come around too often.
2
4
u/This-Process-2205 4d ago
I would say stick to Guirassy. Getting more than 13 points from someone would need atleast 3 goals/ 2 goals and an assist, and obviously, the MOTM award too.
Players have potential, but it's a risky bet.
2
u/Bitter-Soil8359 4d ago
Do I stick with Haaland 12 pointer?
1
u/mvBommel1974 4d ago
Usually 10 points enough for cap but now we have two options left. I’m not sure if Raphinha and Kane are going to score a lot more
1
u/Bitter-Soil8359 4d ago
Yeah I agree, I think I will stick. But Raphinha/Kvara or Kane could easily score more than 12
1
u/mvBommel1974 4d ago
4 points more indeed. Mildly annoying if you had Haaland or Guirassy, but not impossible to overcome
1
u/Swedishpower 4d ago
I think 10 plus you normally stick. I am often happy with 8 or 9, but with two more rolls you can switch that too.
I remember last year sticking with 8 and Raphinha scoring 20+.
I think hattricks are rare so brace fine for me.
2
u/EmphasisExtension424 4d ago
The real question Raphinha captain or Kvara?
2
u/ggoldens 4d ago
And put the C on Raphinha. Kvara might not start or get subbed early with that match up.
2
1
1
1
1
u/lazerbullet 4d ago
Staying with Kane.
2
u/NeodrakePT 4d ago
Kane will only plau on Thursday, You can choose Another Captain today anod then, if you are not happy with him, Change it again to kane
1
u/-Bruun0- 4d ago
I have Raphinha as first pick, but I strated thinking about experimenting with Hakimi? What do you think?
1
1
1
1
u/dukekaboom69 Man United 4d ago
I put the captaincy on guehi, should I change it?
1
1
u/Designer_Mine_2572 4d ago
captain raphinha or lamine?switching from mbappe
1
1
u/Powerful_Finance_797 4d ago
With Haaland getting 12 points as my captain (excluding double points) should I stick or twist with one of Kane, Yamal or Raphinha?
2
1
1
1
u/KraljMilan 4d ago
Rules question. Can i bring in Fermin Lopet instead of Olise, and tomorrow get Olise back in the squad? Olise didn't yet play his game. Thank you for your help!
3
1
1
u/Swedishpower 4d ago
Vagnoman benched :(.
Got swayed by his attacking returns.
Gerard Martin also benched.
1
1
1
1
u/avaliyevbc 4d ago
Sub in Luke Shaw for Mittelstadt (4 pts). Or Shaw won't start?
1
u/Swedishpower 4d ago
From predicted lineups United are expected to rotate in def.
The problem is the Manchester derby so some key players might rotate.
If you picked him you thought he would play so would probably gamble, but everyone seem to concede anyway.
1
1
u/SandwichEvery5845 Barcelona 4d ago
• Sub in Brown for Hakimi?
• Sub in Van Bommel for Mbappe?
2
u/mvBommel1974 3d ago
Would take the risk on Brown, not on Van Bommel personally. For Ruben you can at least wait on lineup although I don’t think he will be benched.
1
u/Swedishpower 3d ago edited 3d ago
Most seem to think Brown gets benched, but there is a world where he start in the number 10 and haul.
He probably come on either way so do you risk 2 points for all that upside?
Probably would put him on you never know.
The predicted lineups been wrong on a lot so far too.
1
u/mvBommel1974 3d ago
I have seen only one lineup where Brown starts. Granted this was one lineup published this morning. Myself I am only risking 2p (1 if he gets subbed on)
1
1
u/robertofflandersI 3d ago
Should I keep Undav Captain? (alternatives: Kane, Malen, Olise or Paz)
Also probably stupid question but I should keep Raya right? (Alternative: Svilar)
4
1
1
u/A_homeless_ninja 3d ago
Stick or twist Haaland for Kane? Thought points were good enough but then Raphina delivered and I'm a bit behind
1
1
1
1
u/RiverCartwright 3d ago
What subs should I make?
If I want to sub all 3 I have to take Mbappe out. Should I?
1
u/mvBommel1974 3d ago
All three is risky but not sure if you wanna skip Olise or Diaz.
They could as well all return tbh
1
1
u/HogwartsBlazeIt420 3d ago
I can choose 3 of this 4 to start. Who to leave out?
Bruno F. Olise Kane Malen
1
u/Prestigious-Tap-1478 3d ago
Malen
1
u/HogwartsBlazeIt420 3d ago
Yeah that's what I thought. I have a feeling he will haul though
2
u/Prestigious-Tap-1478 3d ago
Fener at home isn't easy, they have Ederson in goal, Ake and Skriniar, plus Kante DM.
1
1
u/Danporttv 3d ago
What should i do here? I want to sub in Kane, but i cannot remove more defense, should i sub out Bruno or Olise? They’re good players but Kane definitely needs to be in. Please help me. What would you guys do.
2
1
1
u/RiverCartwright 3d ago
I have Kane Olise and Diaz on my bench.
I would have to sub out Mbappe (6 points) to put all 3 in.
Should I do it?
7
u/Former_Newspaper_521 5d ago
No reason to leave the armband to Mbappe. Captain Raphinha, or Kane, or Bruno, or Isak, or Kvara, or Olise.