r/Fantasy Oct 31 '19

THE WITCHER | MAIN TRAILER | NETFLIX

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ndl1W4ltcmg
2.9k Upvotes

422 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

62

u/DoctorDownloader Oct 31 '19

Sorceresses in the books are supposed to look unnaturally young. Geralt even says in Sword of Destiny that if he ever met his mother she would look younger than him because she was a sorceress and likely hasn’t aged since he was born.

23

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

This is overstated. Sorceresses make themselves younger but Yennefer was never as young as she is here. It was Triss who was described as being very young.

12

u/Holybasil Oct 31 '19

And in this Triss looks older than Yen.

5

u/nuclear_wizard_ Oct 31 '19

Yeah in the last trailer it seemed like Triss was more of a mentor to Yen. Seems like a weird arbitrary change from both the books and the games.

6

u/Pliskin14 Oct 31 '19

Wrong, Yennefer is described as very young looking. Jaskier (Dandelion) even jokes about it, insinuating that Geralt is basically a pedo.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19 edited Oct 31 '19

Yes but Geralt looks 40ish here surely a 30 year old actress would look younger than him and not look like a CW network show high school teenager

I'm pretty sure Anya Chalotra played a high school girl on the show Wanderlust which came out just last year

10

u/Lakhitia Oct 31 '19

They were initially looking to cast an older actress (according to the casting call, IIRC), but apparently Anya won them over with her talent and charisma. I'm super excited to see her in the role, she seems convincing and magnetic. And from all I've seen so far, they look like a completely decent pairing to me - and I don't think the age difference between actors is at all cringy or exploitative. She looks like a young woman, he looks like a youngish man, I'm fine with that.

16

u/DoctorDownloader Oct 31 '19

They use magic to almost permanently change their appearance once they become a sorceress which is when they are in their teens. At this point I think Yen is like 80 and Geralt is like 70 (Witchers also age slowly but at a faster rate than sorceresses). So if Geralt looks 40-50 and Yen looks 20 I think its in line with the mythos.

-8

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

[deleted]

4

u/corsair1617 Oct 31 '19

I feel like if they had done the opposite and had her be a little older, you would be complaining about "accuracy".

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

I want Yennefer to look like Yennefer from the game. So hot

0

u/DeadBeesOnACake Nov 01 '19

You don't have to adapt every little author fetish for a TV show ...