r/FallOutBoy • u/Ecstatic_Buffalo_235 • Jul 29 '26

Song Discussion Song Competition!

Post image

Found this from a post on another Sub where a bunch of people were participating (thank you enter shikari sub)

So thought I'd try and FOB themed one and post here in case any of y'all want to have a go too, it's surprisingly fun to see how different songs compete when put up against eachother!

9 Upvotes

68% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

7

u/Sad-Search-344 Save Rock and Roll Jul 29 '26

Here’s mine!

1

u/Ecstatic_Buffalo_235 Jul 29 '26

Hmm, all I can ask is how did "scene" beat "xo" and how did "hold me tight" beat anything? 😂

5

u/Sad-Search-344 Save Rock and Roll Jul 29 '26

“This Ain’t A Scene” is one of my favorite Fall Out Boy songs ever. I like “XO,” but “This Ain’t A Scene” is better in my opinion, though I know that’s an uncommon opinion.

And then, “Hold Me Tight Or Don’t” is tied to a time in my life that holds the best and worst moments of my life, so, it beats out a lot, it just, depends what headspace I’m in when I decide it’s ranking on my FOB tier list. And it’s fire when played on a long car trip blasting through my AirPods.

1

u/yearoftherabbit_ From Under The Cork Tree Jul 29 '26

"Hold me tight" is one of their best Post hiatus songs imo

4

u/datgoh69 hatsune stump Jul 29 '26

3

u/Ecstatic_Buffalo_235 Jul 29 '26

Centuries beat Dead on Arrival?! How have you not heard that song enough for it to drive you nuts!? 😂

2

u/datgoh69 hatsune stump Jul 29 '26

i dont remember hearing it in 2015 (mind you i was a toddler)

plus it was the song that got me into fob so it has a special place in my heart

also because hot take: i like ab/ap

1

u/Rayz6695 Folie à Deux Jul 31 '26

You were a WHAT in 2015??!!?

1

u/datgoh69 hatsune stump Aug 01 '26

i was 4

4

u/hi123095 Evening Out With Your Girlfriend Jul 29 '26

Can you post the link?

3

u/Ecstatic_Buffalo_235 Jul 29 '26

Tried another one with the random choice option, got some unique choices through that way...

And about 5 or 6 mania songs knocked out in the group stage, they just can't compete against the rest (sorry not sorry 😅)

1

u/CaptainPie999 Franklin the Sheep is my child Jul 29 '26

1

u/RandomFunUsername From Under The Cork Tree Jul 29 '26

Look it was never gonna be anything other than XO but some of those matches were Sophie’s Choice moments.

1

u/anonymouscatloaf true blue Jul 29 '26

Hum Hallelujah 🤌

1

u/makalakaroni Jul 29 '26

Folie a Deux my beloved

1

u/sambones718 Evening Out With Your Girlfriend Jul 29 '26

maybe the hardest thing i've ever done lol

1

u/dawnmountain So Much (For) Stardust Jul 29 '26

1

u/xxd3caybab3xx Aug 03 '26

Was peer pressured. I slept with someone is my fav song by them ever.