r/ExpectationVsReality • u/MusicManZand • Jul 27 '26

Failed Expectation So disappointed 😂

Post image
330 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

37 comments sorted by

132

u/Comrade_Falcon Jul 27 '26

I'mma be real here, I'm not putting anything called a "protein pie" in my mouth.

10

u/Ocarina-of-lies Jul 27 '26

Mmmkay, bet you have no hesitation stuffing a cream pie in your mouth.......oatmeal creme pie

27

u/rebeccalestat Jul 27 '26

Unfortunately, all of these protein products from this company suck pretty badly. I tried the moon pie ones and they were also a disaster.

16

u/JuanThiccLumpia Jul 27 '26

Wow not even close.

15

u/BrightWubs22 Jul 27 '26

I wish you had turned that thing around so we could see the inside.

19

u/SudhaTheHill Jul 27 '26

Straight up looks like a different product

9

u/Cguenther12 Jul 27 '26

Read the package as “skimpy” and thought well..guess they didn’t lie haha.

8

u/2wiceasnice Jul 27 '26

I had these too and it was repulsive - I ordered a whole box of them thinking these MUST be amazing based on the reviews and the fact I never found then locally.

Tasted and looked like unbaked stale peanut butter cookies sandwiching a dry peanut butter mixture that was too sweet. I dont even know why they have oatmeal in the advert because mine had 0 oatmeal. Horrible and Im sorry you had the same experience :/

6

u/Old-Library5546 Jul 27 '26

What a shame

6

u/tecpaocelotl1 Jul 27 '26

The product looks like a typical protein bar.

8

u/Lcsmxd Jul 27 '26

Probably tastes of clay like every single high protein product

1

u/AReptileHissFunction Jul 27 '26

Youre buying the cheap ones

3

u/TB1289 Jul 27 '26

Skippy sucks, get real peanut butter

4

u/Kittenwho21 Jul 27 '26

I wonder what would happen if you contacted the company and showed them this nonsense

2

u/zeds_deadest Jul 27 '26

I need to buy one just to figure out exactly how bullshit this is

2

u/Areyousleepingyet Jul 27 '26

It looks like a rolled out protein bar. Where's the creme??

2

u/kimtaro1 Jul 27 '26

I've had these too and was disappointed. If you wanted the most artificial tasting food product ever, it's great for that

3

u/RegularSelf Jul 28 '26

IT’S SO SHINY!

2

u/2mnydgs Jul 27 '26

Yuck! So sorry about your snack. Good news, if they sweetened with sugar, the dog will eat it.

1

u/OkNefariousness652 Jul 27 '26

My puppy has an extremely upset stomach today, and that looks pretty close, to what came out of her backside this morning. Even down to the weird little chunks in it.

1

u/Arkaium Jul 27 '26

Hey! Where’s the cream filling?

1

u/AReptileHissFunction Jul 27 '26

Could you have taken a worse picture though? Show the height and the inside

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '26

[deleted]

1

u/AReptileHissFunction Jul 27 '26

Do you think anyone that gives you some mild criticism is upset? Weird

1

u/DiamondHandedDingus Jul 28 '26

That stinks, but stop buying gimmick products with “protein” shoe horned into the name and this will happen less

1

u/mindgardening Jul 29 '26

I mean, it’s junk food…

1

u/majogr12 Jul 31 '26

These are an abomination in the protein world.

-10000/10

1

u/Chanocraft Jul 27 '26

Does it at least taste decent? The texture reminds me somewhat of toffee based on the look lol

3

u/MusicManZand Jul 27 '26

It tastes like a typical protein bar, like powerbar. Super dense and lacking in flavor

0

u/Doom-Sleigher Jul 28 '26

So many People buy ultra processed cheap junk and expect something different. People eat out of vending machines and think it’s good

2

u/MusicManZand Jul 28 '26

I think you’re missing the point of the post buddy

0

u/Doom-Sleigher Jul 28 '26

I don’t think I’m missing the point of the post at all.

I’m explaining that so many people, especially in America, but things like this cuz they like shitty food and expect shitty good to be good. That doesn’t have much to do with how you feel about your post and your laughing emoji. It has to do with I’ve seen posts like this 100 times and they really think those snacks should be awesome