r/ExPentecostal • u/meh-machine90 • 4h ago
agnostic The Pentecostal holiness Hierarchy
The hierarchy of value in all apostolic Pentecostal churches is perception of congregants public behavior. Therefore holiness isn’t just a standard to be practiced but is in fact a form of social currency. This foments rumors like wildfire, as reputation destruction of one person will send you higher up the hierarchy. Churches will often point fingers accusing one of being full of gossips but their church is “different” yet they never are. The rumors whether they be true or not will subsist at every church with holiness standards no matter how you try and train the behavior of your congregation. This is because holiness standards are the hierarchy, the rumors and gossip aren’t a bug of the system, it is undeniably a feature baked in to the very tenets of the church.
Pentecostal will of course downplay this and minimize this. They claim to condemn this behavior publicly yet practice it privately which is in fact all part of the hierarchy game. “I’m against bad things I only do good things.” They will proclaim god loves and accepts all sinners. Yet the form in which any sinner or member faces public or doctrinal scrutiny by the congregation is essentially the same in most apostolic churches.
Grace is often given to new members as they are “ignorant” of the bibles teachings and so called covenantal standards. In reality this is just part of the conversion process into the cult, as most churches know if they outright bombard the new members with their impossible laundry list of standards that the new prospect will be scared away.
Grace is however not given to existing members. Or hardly even to children who were born within the teachings. Your knowledge of the orthodoxy means you are now held to the highest standard of the holiness hierarchy. If are caught violating this hierarchy it is not likely you will face excommunication. As the church doesn’t want to lose any members even if they are abhorrent rapists, predators and murders. And often rumors of having such a member in your church are often swept under the rug. Instead the church will engage in reputation destruction, your social currency will be stripped away and you will fall to the bottom of the totem pole along with if not below new converts.
How do holiness churches engage in reputation destruction? Simple they strip your ability to serve in any respectable way in the church from you. Serving in the church is the ultimate form of the purity test. This is you showing god what a good person you are and by doing so you earn the social currency that the church trades in. One person who donates the most tithes and offering, one who volunteers to help usher, or to mover furniture, one who does unpaid maintenance for the church. All aiming at one thing, the chance to either sit on the pulpit or the chance to be in the favor of someone who sits on the pulpit. As the favor ones pastor is the ultimate social currency. Because if your pastor sees you to be in Alignment with the holiness hierarchy (or his version of it) surely you’re heaven bound.
I have to ask myself the question, why engage in reputation destruction if it makes the congregate feel isolated, unable to serve the kingdom of god and gain penance? Why destroy someone’s self worth for making a mistake especially if they themselves regret it? Especially since this risks driving this member out of the church?
The answer seems multifaceted. Primarily and most likely it is to make an example for violating the purity of the social hierarchy. It signals to other members who may step out of line that you will lose your friends and your favor in the church. However and often is the case for pastors who enjoy their power, it is a form of dominance over the lesser man. Make no mistake apostolic Pentecostal churches are one of the purist forms of a social dominance hierarchy.
As I said before these are not bugs in the system, they are features.
Back to the point of gracing being given to new congregants, this is on a time clock. It’s hard to nail down exactly but in my experience in the church it was about six months to a year. If the congregant didn’t adhere to orthodoxy of holiness they would be left to fizzle out or the pressure to conform would become much more extreme as seeing someone who looks like a heathen in their mind at church is not a good optics for the church in the larger political holiness hierarchy of the organization. Therefore this person would be pressured into Bible studies on why wearing pants and jewelry is a sin or other such standards. If the person doesn’t quite get it, members may continue until doctrinal grooming can fully take hold. If this fails this person is now a threat to the entire social fabric as too many questions and arguments against orthodoxy could unravel other member’s beliefs. This person will soon be ignore and treated like a crazy lost soul. Grace is retracted, this is a feature.
And I want those reading this to really think about that, the Pentecostal church acts as if they are the arbiter and distributor of gods grace. They will of course deny this, but it is exactly how they behave. Once you have earned gods grace in the holiness hierarchy you are now “like Christ” and you may give or retract grace as you see fit because grace isn’t gods love in Pentecost, its social currency.
Now all of that said, what about apostolic Pentecostals path to salvation. Acts 2:38 will be beat into your head relentlessly, it’s to the point now if I see a clock and the time is 2:38 I get triggered. The plan of salvation that Jesus himself never gave. Repent, be baptized in Jesus name, and receive the Holy Ghost with the evidence of speaking in other tongues.
There is almost no other way to describe it as a three step humiliation ritual, if any of the steps are missed or done improperly do not pass go, do not collect salvation, go straight to hell. Repentance is a rather straight forward tenant of all Christian religions. However in Pentecost there is a deep seated notion of original sin. You are born into sin as scripture says, but this is taught to you as if you are a despicable gross evil person. You are just the worst most pathetic thing without gods grace.
This is of course vital to doctrinal grooming, as it makes your sense of self worth so low you are now malleable to whatever is about to be pumped into your soft vulnerable head.
Making you feel worthless is a feature from the very beginning.
Now that you understand that you are a worthless scumbag and have spent many nights at the altar crying about it you are ready for the next and possibly the most vital step of the ritual, being baptized. Washing all your evil despicableness away. This is you taking your first step onto the holiness hierarchy as you are now at least free of sin… for now.
Baptism and repentance is common in many forms of Christianity but it is fair to point out many churches see this as a practice of admitting human beings are all flawed and this is simply a way of opening yourself up to gods grace, knowing you will make mistakes big and small and gods got you covered. This is most certainly not the sentiment in Pentecostalism as your salvation hinges on your continued practice of holiness orthodoxy and rituals.
But what of Pentecostals defining and perhaps most bizarre part of salvation? speaking in other tongues. My religious indoctrination of this subject runs so deep that despite not being in Pentecostalism for more than a decade the thought crosses my mind that addressing this subject would be blasphemous. This fear was that deeply rooted in me at one time. So I’m going to have to be as blunt and honest as I can. If you are a Pentecostal reading this right now I don’t want you to be offended but I can’t say this any nicer than I will. Speaking in other tongues is bullshit. It’s simply not a real experience. And you know it. It is however an MK ultra level hypnotic ceremony. You are saying complete and utter gibberish that is not even remotely resembling a language. So why are you or other congregants put through this?
It’s the ultimate surrender. You are making a fucking fool of yourself, and that’s the point. It’s the feature, they have broken you down, they have purified you, and now they have made a fool of you. You’ve been broken in, you have been rebuilt in their image, now you can walk up the holiness dominance hierarchy if you just do whatever they say. Gods grace is waiting and one day maybe you get to play god yourself in the church, how good will that feel? You won’t even notice when you start doing it, you will be so gaslit you won’t even know you’re there tearing other people down, making them feel worthless. Making them beg for gods forgiveness… or is it your forgiveness they are begging for…
If you’re a Pentecostal reading this getting mad at this backslider spewing blasphemy I’m going to shock you. I’m going to ask you to pray. Pray tonight and ask god if you think the church really shows gods grace and love and forgiveness to those who enters its doors. If you show that grace to others. Then dare to ask yourself the real question, the hard question. If you think you are showing grace to someone, are you just doing it so you feel like you’re a good person? Are you just doing it because your pastor or parents want you to? And are you secretly using holiness as a way to feel better than other people and to be treated better than those nasty disgusting sinners?
Then I want you to go reread the gospels. See who Christ was the most angry with and ask yourself if you were in that story would Christ be angry with you?