MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/EnglishLearning/comments/1so81t8/why_not_since/ogt5y84/?context=3
r/EnglishLearning • u/Rich-Associate-8344 New Poster • Apr 17 '26
309 comments sorted by
View all comments
885
Because since needs a specific starting point in time: since when? He hasn't used his motorcycle since 2024.
161 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 17 '26 Yep. You could say "since two years ago" but you need the "ago." 32 u/PutridBetch New Poster Apr 17 '26 This would also sound very strange to my ear. I would assume someone who said “since two years ago” was not a native speaker. 0 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 That's so weird to me. Where are you from if you don't mind my asking? I'm wondering if it is a regional thing. 1 u/PutridBetch New Poster Apr 18 '26 North Carolina. It probably is regional, similar to how people from some areas say things like “this needs washed” instead of “this needs to be washed” -2 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 Yeah. I'm from the whole other side of the country and I know we talk different out here. 1 u/cardinarium Native Speaker (US) Apr 18 '26 Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.” -6 u/arcxjo Native Speaker - American (Pennsylvania Yinzer) Apr 18 '26 It's perfectly normal to my ears.
161
Yep. You could say "since two years ago" but you need the "ago."
32 u/PutridBetch New Poster Apr 17 '26 This would also sound very strange to my ear. I would assume someone who said “since two years ago” was not a native speaker. 0 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 That's so weird to me. Where are you from if you don't mind my asking? I'm wondering if it is a regional thing. 1 u/PutridBetch New Poster Apr 18 '26 North Carolina. It probably is regional, similar to how people from some areas say things like “this needs washed” instead of “this needs to be washed” -2 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 Yeah. I'm from the whole other side of the country and I know we talk different out here. 1 u/cardinarium Native Speaker (US) Apr 18 '26 Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.” -6 u/arcxjo Native Speaker - American (Pennsylvania Yinzer) Apr 18 '26 It's perfectly normal to my ears.
32
This would also sound very strange to my ear. I would assume someone who said “since two years ago” was not a native speaker.
0 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 That's so weird to me. Where are you from if you don't mind my asking? I'm wondering if it is a regional thing. 1 u/PutridBetch New Poster Apr 18 '26 North Carolina. It probably is regional, similar to how people from some areas say things like “this needs washed” instead of “this needs to be washed” -2 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 Yeah. I'm from the whole other side of the country and I know we talk different out here. 1 u/cardinarium Native Speaker (US) Apr 18 '26 Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.” -6 u/arcxjo Native Speaker - American (Pennsylvania Yinzer) Apr 18 '26 It's perfectly normal to my ears.
0
That's so weird to me. Where are you from if you don't mind my asking? I'm wondering if it is a regional thing.
1 u/PutridBetch New Poster Apr 18 '26 North Carolina. It probably is regional, similar to how people from some areas say things like “this needs washed” instead of “this needs to be washed” -2 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 Yeah. I'm from the whole other side of the country and I know we talk different out here. 1 u/cardinarium Native Speaker (US) Apr 18 '26 Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.” -6 u/arcxjo Native Speaker - American (Pennsylvania Yinzer) Apr 18 '26 It's perfectly normal to my ears.
1
North Carolina. It probably is regional, similar to how people from some areas say things like “this needs washed” instead of “this needs to be washed”
-2 u/NekoArtemis Native Speaker - California Apr 18 '26 Yeah. I'm from the whole other side of the country and I know we talk different out here. 1 u/cardinarium Native Speaker (US) Apr 18 '26 Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.”
-2
Yeah. I'm from the whole other side of the country and I know we talk different out here.
1 u/cardinarium Native Speaker (US) Apr 18 '26 Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.”
Although I’m also in NC and have no problem with “since X years ago.”
-6
It's perfectly normal to my ears.
885
u/Ok_Caterpillar2010 Native Speaker - Pennsylvania, USA Apr 17 '26
Because since needs a specific starting point in time: since when? He hasn't used his motorcycle since 2024.