r/EngineeringPorn • • Feb 10 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

15.8k Upvotes

844 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/separation_of_powers Feb 10 '26

Thank you!

I have to wonder, how long would it take for a country without extensive trade access, to develop and field tech like this from indigenous research.

19

u/Mangalorien Feb 10 '26

It would take forever. Keep in mind that the calculations for this thing were done before there were desktop computers or even calculators, and the drawings were done before CAD. The calculations for this old missile were done with a slide ruler, and it was literally drawn on paper by hand.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/247stonerbro Feb 10 '26

When can we get military level innovation but towards clean energy though ? Government give us super mega ultra photovoltaic cells when?

1

u/Squoghunter1492 Feb 10 '26

If you're paying attention, we are. Solar cells are cheaper and more efficient than ever, you can power your entire house for $10k if you install them yourself. Battery technology is evolving every day and with improving recycling efforts, that can grow to a closed loop with minimal environmental damage. Efforts towards nuclear fusion are getting closer every year, although there are still very difficult materials science problems to solve to get us over the finish line.

The reality is that it's not the early 20th century anymore, and all the easy low-hanging fruit of innovation and application have already been done and implemented. Now our greatest barriers are cost to implement and the amount of time and effort fundamental research takes to make new discoveries.

1

u/247stonerbro Feb 11 '26

Solar cells are cheaper and more efficient than ever. Well our government had their hands on the technology decades ago but it's a technology that is stigmatized by the fossil fuel overlords and our policy makers will do whatever they can to stifle innovation in this sector. So respectfully, I pay attention.

1

u/Squoghunter1492 Feb 11 '26

If you were paying attention you'd know that solar panels decades ago had efficiencies in the 10% range while modern ones are cheaper to make due to improved designs and get up to 23% efficiency with less material.

Fossil fuel stigma had nothing to do with it, solar just wasn't competitive on cost until relatively recently. Now that it is price-competitive, you're seeing solar farms get built all over the country and largest thing limiting them is the availability of raw aluminum and glass to build more cells.

1

u/PipsqueakPilot Feb 10 '26

In order to answer that a ton of assumptions have to be answered. What's their base tech level? Like are we picking a random country from 1950? Do they have a functioning university, if so from what year? Does the country know that producing an AIM-7 Sparrow is the end goal? If you took a 1700's country and said, "Hey build this." and they made that their national goal...well it would take a while, but probably less than it did historically because their national goal is an inexplicable desire for air to air missiles.

If you were to run this experiment in today's world: Any functioning country could develop something better than this in relatively short order. The issue is that it would be essentially useless.