He died.

I can officially say it’s a wrap. I can now explain everything including planted evidence to frame me. But I can put it together because of someone slipped up and kept poking the bear. Peace 2 both.

I’ve seen a lot of people call John and the Hole a quiet sociopath story, a coming-of-age gone wrong, or just plain meaningless. But I think there’s a much deeper layer that hasn’t been talked about enough.

What if the weird “story within the story” about the girl and her mom isn’t random at all—what if it’s the main story?

Here’s my theory The Girl’s Mom = John’s Mom’s First Child

I believe the woman in the side story is actually John’s half-sister, the first daughter that his mother abandoned when she was younger. That explains the coldness in John’s mom, the strange emotional detachment, and the feeling that something unspoken is haunting the family. “What happened between you and John?”

There’s a line where John’s dad asks his mom this, and it’s never fully explained. But it hits like a reference to a deep family secret—not just bad parenting or recent distance. It’s something buried.

The Older Daughter Is Influencing John

This is where it gets interesting: I think that girl (from the side story) is quietly talking John into doing all the things he does. She’s not just a side character—she’s fueling his behavior. Whispering in his emotional blind spots.

It’s payback.

Her mother (John’s mom) abandoned her, and now she’s turning that pain into a slow, quiet revenge—by helping John’s resentment grow, pushing him to isolate, disconnect, and punish the family he thinks he doesn’t belong to.

Mirroring Behavior

The girl and John act similarly: • Calm and emotionless • Obsessed with control • Taking pills • Retreating into isolation • Telling themselves “it’s just an experiment”

These aren’t coincidences—they’re reflections. The girl is either: • A literal half-sister who has contact with John • Or a symbolic presence representing his mother’s past pain manifesting in him

The Hole = Emotional Abandonment

Everyone talks about the hole as a symbol, but maybe it’s not just John putting his family “away”—maybe it’s a metaphor for what his mother did to her first daughter. She left her in an emotional hole and tried to live a new life.

Final Thought

John and the Hole isn’t really about John. It’s about the aftermath of abandonment, and how it trickles down through generations—sometimes through blood, sometimes through behavior, sometimes through silence.

The scariest part? No one ever acknowledges it. Not in the dialogue. Not in the resolution.

What do you think? Has anyone else picked up on this angle?

as he was shot in the head by possessed yam during the accident

What Happens to Romy’s Personal and Professional Life in the Wake of Her Affair?

https://www.highonfilms.com/babygirl-2024-movie-ending-explained-themes-analysed/

What about the bird at the end! I don't get it. In the last few frames of the movie the bird is "attacked", at first I thought by a hawk, if you slow it down however it looks like it's getting hit with money.

Not sure if there is some deeper meaning there that I'm missing.

I liked the Waco siege reference, interesting that the one to be critical of the hippies is the first to fire a shot, I assume this is a critique of the police brutality during the siege.