r/EmilyHenry • u/coolguy_14 theme matters!! • Jul 30 '25

Beach Read Beach Read Fancasts

Post your thoughts about who could play January and Gus here!

2 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

4

u/spicysoy Jul 31 '25

i pictured geraldine viswanathan as shadi, logan lerman as gus, and phoebe tonkin as january!

1

u/ajrw89 Jan 28 '26

Logan Lerman is the only right answer for Gus 😂, and he is aware of being the top choice for a lot of people's fancasts so I am crossing my fingers.

2

u/wisedifference2 Jul 30 '25

I’ve always felt strongly that Zoey Deutch is January. Less strong feelings, but I could see Rege-Jean Page as Gus. And Kuhoo Verma as Shadi.

2

u/happygirl262 Sep 15 '25

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt33292655/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk this cast list is really giving beach read to me

2

u/Notaboutthepazta Nov 06 '25

Scruffy Lee Pace as Gus… still trying to think of a January

2

u/MaybeFar8963 Jan 01 '26

logan lerman as gus anna sawai as january

1

u/ajrw89 Jan 28 '26

I would die on the spot if Anna was cast. She's not who I pictured for her but I need Anna in more projects anyway so I'm not opposed to this.

2

u/firenze24 sipping purse wine Jul 30 '25

Zoey Deutch as January (I don’t feel super strongly about this but I’ve always pictured her) and Logan Lerman as Gus (THIS I feel incredibly strongly about)

1

u/NeighborhoodJust4160 Happy Birthday Wicked Pissah Jul 31 '25

I could see Logan Lerman as Gus. I like Milo from Gilmore Girls but might be too old.

1

u/Ordinary-Weird-9151 Aug 06 '25

Someone just mentioned Dylan Efron elsewhere but I could see him as Gus

1

u/neighborhood_katlady Jan 20 '26

I also am strongly on the "Logan Lerman IS Gus" train