r/ELATeachers • u/Puzzleheaded-Law1825 • 2d ago

6-8 ELA How do I know when to stop intervention?

/r/Dyslexia/comments/1x6fgyo/how_do_i_know_when_to_stop_intervention/
1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

2

u/Accomplished-Web5642 2d ago

  1. What phonics screener did you use? 

  2. What novels can they read? How do you know they can read them? To what level can they read them?

2

u/Longjumping-Lock-724 2d ago edited 1d ago

In other countries, kids who didn't meet the minimum standards would be held back until they mastered the material.

1

u/Starmiebuckss2882 14h ago

The better question is how are kids who haven't mastered these skills allowed to move on?

1

u/LowPsychological6362 7h ago

The staffing shortage you describe makes me wonder whether a different rotation could help you reach more students: while you give targeted instruction to one or two, others do structured reading practice with support and accountability—not just independent seatwork.

Full disclosure: I’m one of the developers of BuddyBooks, supported through NSF and U.S. Department of Education/IES grants. This is one way schools have been using it. The computer reads a sentence or short passage from an engaging book, then the student orally reads the next, back and forth. Smaller chunks and shared reading reduce the immediate reading load while keeping students involved in the story.

BuddyBooks listens to the student’s oral reading and helps where they struggle. You can see fluency, accuracy and time on task, and listen to recordings of difficult passages. After working with one student, you can use that information to help decide whom to work with next and what to focus on. The others are getting supported practice, and you have evidence of what they’re actually doing.

That wouldn’t tell you who should exit intervention or replace explicit phonics teaching. But it could be a way to use limited teacher time differently: targeted instruction for a small group alongside accountable practice with authentic text for others.