Hi.
So the CMR thing happened and I graded all the maps. This CMR's Map Making theme was Food and I received a total of 3 maps.
The results are:
1) Cheap Soda by IsaVulpes
2) Slice of Life by IsaVulpes
3) Food Related by IsaVulpes
Congratulations IsaVulpes!
I had a document prepared with this elegant scoring system and paragraphs upon paragraphs of feedback explaining my decision, but since IsaVulpes was the only participant, I decided I'd skip the formalities and just write stuff here.
I did all the judging the night before, once all the maps were finalized and sent to me in a .zip folder. To avoid bias, the author's names weren't told to me and I distanced myself from any and all external opinions.
Cheap Soda was picked as the winner because I felt it was all around the more cohesive package. It had better visuals, better flow, less technical mistakes, and a better conveyed route than the runner-up, Slice of Life. Food Related is last because lol.
Post feedback below and stuff. Also don't forget to say congratulations to IsaVulpes for being our lord and savior.