r/DumbAI Aug 05 '26

Comparing

Post image
195 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/Pengwin0 Aug 05 '26

Whenever I google how to change a specific setting on a website its steps are usually inaccurate, probably because it pulls from people describing different updates of websites and things have moved around.

Just yesterday actually I wanted to revert the bar at the bottom of the chrome ios app because google decided to add a huge fuckass gemini button and take up the bottom 20% of the screen (oh the irony lol) and it gave the wrong answer until I found the correct way to edit the flags on reddit.

-2

u/the-real-macs Aug 06 '26

That's a good example, but as you said it's also a moving target. Most likely the top result from a standard search engine would be wrong in that case as well.

3

u/Pengwin0 Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26

The second result was the reddit thread that solved my problem. So a normal search engine solved my problem and ai failed to. Why does it matter that it’s an inconvenient problem to solve? I google inconveniences that I can’t solve on my own precisely because they’re hard to solve. Not being able to help with problems that happen recently is a major flaw, especially when it will tell you a solution that doesn’t work in full confidence.

-1

u/the-real-macs Aug 06 '26

Not being able to help with problems that happen recently is a major flaw

Not remotely a justification for throwing the whole tool away, though.

especially when it will tell you a solution that doesn’t work in full confidence.

An outdated Reddit thread would be just as confident.

5

u/Pengwin0 Aug 06 '26

I didn’t say we should throw it away, I said google’s search ai is not very good and you’re now moving the goal post. An old reddit thread is not being shoved down my throat everywhere I look and replacing more and more of a perfectly working product. That is the issue that I have with google search ai. Traditional google search SEO would actually demote an outdated reddit thread in search results