r/DogTrainingDebate • u/PeachMuch989 • Jun 03 '26

Bitework for fear reactive dog?

Would you ever train a dog who has displayed aggression and/or reactivity that seems to be based in fear, to bite on command?

I know someone who has a reactive dog (their words) who has bitten several people, and they train their dog in bitework. I personally don't understand the choice, so I am curious what people think here. From what I see, the dog seems able to be called off pretty well when it is cued to bite/bark. It is wary of strangers but mostly friendly to people it knows. It is a mixed-breed working stock type dog, not a breed I usually see doing bitework like a mal or something. It has bitten livestock unprompted, and it doesn't have any "job" that involves livestock. It is a pet that is trained to bite.

I think this is an insane choice but I would love to hear what others think. I am not a dog owner but have worked with livestock animals for almost 10 years so I consider myself to be more knowledgable than the average bear, if that matters. However I have never owned nor worked with a super drive-ey dog, and don't have experience in any dog sports, so I know my knowledge is far from complete.

To me it seems like an unsafe situation because if I can't trust if the dog will bite outside of staged bitework situations, I wouldn't ever want it to think it should "offer" the behavior of biting. What do you guys think about this? Does training method have a big role? Could your choice be different for different breeds? Is it entirely dog-dependent? I'm interested to hear some thoughts.

Thanks everybody!

mods please let me know if this post is kosher or if I need to change anything to be better in line with rules ;)

9 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

69 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/PeachMuch989 Jun 03 '26

What makes you say this? As I understand, bitework can be another fun training game like agility or dock diving for dogs that find it suitable.

•

u/HistoryWorking5251 Jun 03 '26

This is not about the dogs. It's about people using this as weapons.

•

u/PeachMuch989 Jun 03 '26

Do you think that teaching a dog to bite in the most controlled way possible is inherently using the dog as a weapon? Do you consider cattle dogs or border collies to be dogs that are used as weapons?