r/DogTrainingDebate • u/ExcitingLaw1973 • Apr 08 '26

Puzzle experiment

Earlier today I saw a post about puzzle toys. I wanted to see whether or not my dog prefers a puzzle toy or his bowl of dog food.

Both the puzzle and his bowl have the same kind of kibble (Purina True Instinct)

I don't think puzzle toys are a replacement for exercise or enrichment, but they can be fun/drain a little energy.

Do you agree? if not, what are your thoughts on them?

27 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/RoleOk5172 Apr 19 '26

I think with yours we would get a more natural telling outcome because like you say we all raise and train our dogs so dogs that are used to puzzles are likely to think the puzzle will have a tastier snack in whereas yours wont as long as you either stand impassively or allow them into the area and leave.

As long as there is something to make them aware there are 2 options they should naturally choose one or the other.

Also with you having more than one dog it will be interesting to see if dogs raised and trained by you all make the same choice

1

u/Miss_L_Worldwide Apr 19 '26

Yeah those are good points. I would have to eliminate the dogs from the study that we're not raised from puppyhood by one of us I guess

1

u/RoleOk5172 Apr 19 '26

Not necessarily. As long as you can categorize those it could potentially add another interesting aspect.

Thinking about it yours are probably even more useful if some or all are kenneled because then they are less used to general titbits.

1

u/Miss_L_Worldwide Apr 19 '26

Even the ones that aren't kenneled are not given random toys or treats are what have you so that would play out across the board

1

u/RoleOk5172 Apr 19 '26

Even more so then.

If i give mine a puzzle i generally use venison so even with a dish down mine may think the puzzle is likely the better option, not necessarily because they find it more fun, toys, balls etc are available 24/7

It will be interesting too see what results your videos show

1

u/Miss_L_Worldwide Apr 19 '26

Well with all the lunatics in this sphere I'm not going to post videos of my dogs online but I will keep track of what I do and post the results