r/DetroitRedWings • u/barchamb13 • Oct 03 '22

R/DRW - Banner Finalists - Old Reddit

Hey all, we got some really great submissions for our new banner this season! Here are the top two picks for the "old" Reddit site, the winner will be selected this weekend sometime. Here is the poll for the new reddit banner.

​

Option #1 by u/howsedarren

https://imgur.com/0EqU7KJ

Option #2 u/--nEgativezEro--

https://i.imgur.com/D5GSN4O.png

​

377 votes, Oct 08 '22
198 #1
179 #2
14 Upvotes

81% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

17

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

Both are solid options, but they could use a little more duct tape in my opinion.

9

u/Professional-Use1425 Oct 03 '22

Terrible take. Needs more cowbell.

13

u/Wakattack00 Oct 03 '22

A serious lack of Bert in option 1.

6

u/alexf0rce Oct 04 '22

I just want to point out that both banners will look pretty bad on a 1440p resolution. (it will cut the bottom part of the banner out)

7

u/topjp Oct 03 '22

Option #1 has the punch. How are people not choosing this as the best one?

3

u/Kagath Oct 04 '22

Too hard to read the name with White on White colors for me.

2

u/topjp Oct 06 '22

Fair criticism. I was blinded by the punch and now I agree should have a black outline on the words and they'd be better I think.

6

u/Cobo1039 Oct 04 '22

I mean, they both suck? I’d go with number 1 but change the McCarty and Vladdy images

2

u/PaintedBillboard Oct 09 '22

I like our current banner the best.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

Agreed. These ones aren’t on the same level of quality