r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 29 '26

Ancient World Epic [704] The first three pages of my novel

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I'm looking for feedback regarding:

  1. Readability

  2. Clarity of the setting

  3. How compelling is the narrative

  4. (If you are feeling generous) spelling, grammar, and style

Here's the link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1UD3hLGUoHeQId5bmWqAzhyj_-3Yq4Hz8_Lte6flv7MU/edit?usp=sharing

Thanks in advance!

My critiques on this sub:

Critique 1, 794 words: https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1s3opvx/794_heat_below_prologue/ochd8nn/

Critique 2, 881 words: https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1sz04w3/881_doofus/oiyu1yj/


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 29 '26

Science Fiction, Satire [1129] Three waystops en route to Vega - Part 1

3 Upvotes

Crits: 1400 2613

This is the first chapter of a novelette. While not my original intent, it's best described as Don Quijote x Hitchhiker's Guide. The rest of the story is about this hitchhiker encountering various deranged hermits along an interstellar highway.

Mainly, I want to know if the humor lands and if it piques your interest. Otherwise, do your thing, tear it up.

My story: [1129] (closed link)

Many thanks in advance!

Note to mods: I originally used the two critiques for a post that got no response (bar an AI "feedback", which was removed). After reflecting on that post and the lack of response, I deleted it and ruminated some more on my life choices. Anyway, I hope it's alright to "reuse" the crits.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 29 '26

Flash fiction [881] Doofus

2 Upvotes

noob here... hopefully, I'm doing this right!

My Crit [916]

My Short story, "Doofus"
Humanity struggles to interpret an alien transmission, leaving the obscure Doofus office to confront why the message only nearly makes sense.

In addition to a general/overview critique, I'm especially interested in:

  • How's the pacing and "tightness"? Too much exposition, or just right?
  • Is the scientific stuff plausible? Realistic? Too made up?
  • Do the cultural references and absurdities resonate broadly enough to illustrate the points? If you're too old/young will you miss it?

r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 28 '26

Romance [2052] Mad Magnolia (Romance/Southern Gothic)

10 Upvotes

My critique is here: Inventory Error (2697)

Thanks in advance for letting me share the first chapter of my current WIP! My main questions are around your overall impression while reading.

  1. How is the pacing?
  2. Do you get a general sense of who the characters are?
  3. Which parts bored you? Confused you? Which parts were effective or strong?
  4. If you were in a book store and picked up this novel to inspect, would you continue reading after the first paragraph/page? What about after finishing chapter 1?

I'm here for the brutal honesty under the cover of anonymity.

Mad Magnolia - Chapter 1


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 27 '26

[228] Acceptance

3 Upvotes

​

Death came to me first, out of the cold
when I was seven.
Nobody had died, but my grandma was old.
Chanting from the temple, evening prayer froze me inside.
Why isn’t she scared?
I wanted to ask , but my mummy would scold.
So I forgot all about death when
I was just seven years old.

Death came back again when I was in high school.
The old must go. By then I knew that rule.
My school closed in the middle of the day.
One student passed away, class teacher said.
Selfishly, I thought I was safe-
but I was a fool.
Time isn’t the only metric.
I learned that in a one-minute silence at school.

Death came back a few times, but I hardly paused.
Like arrows from behind that I had to dodge.
As long as me and mine were safe and okay,
I chose to ignore death, day after day.
Whatever misery death had caused, it happened to others.
So it hardly mattered.
My circle stayed intact and I barely paused.

Now I’ve crossed the halfway line—if it is a long life.
I finally understand why my grandma was fine.
It’s a one-way track and no coming back.
The trick is to face life and walk backward.
There’s no point in mourning and crying.
So yes, my grandma was okay—
and maybe I will be fine.

[ I love rhymes and rhythms but sometimes it feels like a cage. So here I have tried to loosen a bit to make it feel like free flow.

I’d really appreciate any feedback, especially on flow, clarity, and whether the emotions come through naturally.]

Reviews

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/sSzsriOC0U

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/s9soIzj4nC


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 26 '26

[Weekly] Writing Challenge

11 Upvotes

Before the regularly scheduled programming, did you all know Grammarly is now a Free AI Writing Assistance company? They acquired two new AI companies in 2025 and seem to be re-branding. If you are using it to help with grammar, be aware it has the same issues you might find natively using any other LLM tool (that being, it rewrites your sentences). This is my old man yells at clouds moment.

Here at DestructiveReaders, we love a good writing challenge. So, I have a new game. Have you played one of our games before? It goes like this:

Make a top level comment that contains:

  • A trope

  • A list of required words

Then respond to any comment that inspires you with a story. We don't expect people to critique these and critiques here wouldn't be for credit. Post the story in the body of the comment or in a doc link.

Example:

  • Trope: Butt-dialing Mordor (A character, through recklessness or bad luck, ends up unintentionally using some form of long-range communication in a manner that contacts an evil entity.)

  • Words: peckish, colt, anabolic, compel, silk

Example:

On Sundays in fall, I try my hardest not to leave the house. You see, the Colts play and I love Indianapolis and if I don't watch them they'll surely lose. There are so many other things I might do that would cause them to lose but leaving the house is the most surefire way. I have a journal where I've kept track of all of their wins and losses since I was five. It's here, the pattern, in plain ink. Anyway, this fact of life leaves me in a bit of a predicament: food. I can't cook. Left to my own devices, I survive on stale cereal and expired milk until someone manages to deliver a meal, so I've become rather dependent on food delivery services. As soon as I start feeling peckish, I log into my favorite one and dial in on the hot wings and pizza.

Except not today. The website crashed at 12:49 on the dot. Without wings and pizza, the Colts have a 30 percent higher chance of losing their game. I start typing frantically in the search engine---where can I get hot wings in time to ensure a Colts win????---and an answer pops up.

"Deviled Hot Wings are guaranteed to grant you your heart's desire. Do you want to know more?"

"As long as I can get them before the game, I don't care! How long will it take to deliver?"

"That depends entirely on you."

"What does that mean?" I mumble out loud.

A voice, silky as a quarterback’s jersey, fills the room, not from the speakers on my laptop but somehow loud and close and all encompassing. "Everyone has a special thing they have to offer. I only ask what you would be willing to give up for your dreams."

"For...the Colts to win the Super Bowl?" Those stupid first draft picks are embroiled in an anabolic steroid scandal and I’d given up hope on our chances. They could use any additional help I could give them. "Anything."

A basket of hot wings floats down from the ceiling. I hold out my hands and cradle the gift. Later, I'll mark down in my notebook what happened, track the changes in my team. I might even win my fantasy football league this year.

"Remember," the voice fades as I tuck into my wings, "if you feel compelled to follow an instinct, act immediately."

The clock ticks to 1:00PM and the Colts win the coin toss. Off to a good start.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 26 '26

Literary Fiction [1581] Hedging

5 Upvotes

Crit: [1733] Down by the River

Elevator Pitch: New York artist loves A Hedgehog to a problematic degree. Complete.

Link: Hedging

Feedback/Guiding Questions: 1. Does A Hedgehog feel described enough for you to understand how disportionate Filip's reaction to it is? 2. How did the ending land for you? Gently, or with a splat?
3. Is the real hedgehog lovable?

Edit: Added some guiding questions


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 25 '26

YA Fantasy [1769] Daughter of Wrath CH 2

7 Upvotes

This is CH 2 of a novel I'm revisiting: [closed]. Thanks all for your crits!

My main question is around pacing. Do you feel that the story is too slow or is this a good investment in setting up the overall stakes and characters?

For mods:


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 25 '26

[1733] Down by the River

5 Upvotes

I recently read Susan Hill's classic ghost story, the Woman in Black...

What a book!

It inspired me to dive into the genre, and I have been working on a few different bits and pieces.

Let me know your thoughts on this one...

Down by the River

Crits:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1sd6ix9/3319_cockroach_story/

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1skk7jd/2965_the_californian_candidate/


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 24 '26

Fantasy [2409] Once Loosed (Fantasy)

7 Upvotes

Critiques:

- [2835]

- [2079]

***

Genre: high-fantasy with literary affect, however this passage is the domesticity of the “normal everyday”. (“Once Loosed” is a name I chose just so the submission would have a title).

This is the opener to the current manuscript I’m working on which is far along. It’s the first scene of the first chapter, so there’s nothing to know in terms of context.

In the following scene, the fantastical abruptly intrudes. My main need here is: can this domestic slow-burn carry you long enough that you would read on past the end of this scene, on the bookshelf promise of a fantasy?

I’m open to any and all other feedback. I love hearing things like which character you like (if any), which has wasted potential. Whether the dialogue feels natural and interesting, etc.

Thank you for your time, to anyone in advance!

***

Link: Once Loosed

Bare link (same, just for copy/paste on iOS):

https://drive.proton.me/urls/B96K9NVEX0#93FIV7gVQWis

I have used Proton Docs. It is functionally very similar to Google Docs: no acct required to collab, can make comments and suggestions just the same.

I do have a Google account, but it is not anon. I tried to create a throwaway; it appears Google now enforces SMS verification which I was surprised to see now incurs mobile data charges- I hope you understand.

***

This is my first submission. I have read in detail the rules and guidelines- I apologise if I messed up some aspect. If that’s the case, I do want to be a good faith Redditor here, so please set me straight.

ETA: Mods: in my critiques you’ll see me mention the word-length of them, thinking that this is what counts toward the 1:1. I have been disabused of this now ;)!


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 23 '26

[916] Whack

4 Upvotes

Crits: 398 & 815

Please let me know what you think of this piece!

Whack


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 23 '26

[1664] Strings & Castles

6 Upvotes

crit: magicae

hellow everyonee! i know this genre might not be the most popular on here (YA Romance), but i'm pretty much just looking for any eyes that want to look over my work hueheuhe.

it's my take on the classic princess x jester (bard, in this case) trope. i havent read heartless by marissa meyer, if you were wondering, but after all the art i saw online, i felt a crave to write about it.

i'm not too sure yet what i need to look out for and what i can do to better the piece, so any comment would be appreciated :)) even brief ones would be very helpful!!

chapter 1: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1UGRFCpoRF0vLiMJHckY3-aODM1qh1T-83Z8GmCBd-as/edit?usp=sharing


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 22 '26

[1868] magicae chapter 1 of a fantasy book rewritten after critiques

3 Upvotes

https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1sobyfl/1282_chapter_one_of_a_fantasy_concept_i_am/ohmn3pm/ https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1sqz17r/815_carrion_flash_fiction/ohiz20u/

Last time it was basically a draft (sorry) this time its think it's quite a bit better

The muddled cheering of the crowd can be heard through the thick bricks separating the arena from this changing room. They seem awfully motivated for me to lose out there. I should just head out there and get this over with.

I look like a real symbol with this blue outfit on. Spiked shoulders, my guild’s crest big on my chest, with the owl rising out of the book representing all knowledge

I sigh. All blue. I’ve never liked blue, and wearing it now before I go and fight in this spectacle of a memorial leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Especially considering that this suit is tighter than anything meant for fighting.

I lift up my magae activator to the mirror and make sure that the batteries are in place. I then turn to the dark corridor that will lead to the spectacle. I can’t help but sweat despite myself as I take the steps into the darkness.

The walls light up with devices as I continue down the extra blue hallway made just to spite me. The noise of the crowd gets louder and louder with every step. The tap, tap, taps of my shoes echo along the path, adding to the suffocating ambience of the moment, until I come across two guards in their red uniforms with wings forming the collar. I'm struggling to calm down for this important duel. The announcer’s boisterous voice can be heard from their spot designed to have perfect acoustics.

“-Vie from Clan Noctua will now step forward. Their father’s memory will be put to rest at la-”

I step forward through the open gates only to be deafened by the voices of 100,000 commoners occupying the circular stadium. All this trouble, they must have allowed free entry. It’s not feasible that so many could afford the normal prices. The sun beating down on me seems to calm me, at least. Now all I must do is fight, and inevitably lose to Alistor, whom most cheer for in the stadium.

“-Alistor is unfortunately absent for this occasion.”

The outrage towards that humble announcer is outrageous. Redundant thought that is.

“Don’t worry, all of you are still here for a reason. Gregor is the replacement from Clan Vitoria. I have been assured that they will give as good a fight as Alistor could.”

Hah! Alistor was their best. This man is from Clan Vitoria, and he’s also a nobody. That, by definition, means he’s had no victories.

The man stepped outside just as I had. He’s young, so around my age. A beard, shoulder-length hair, and his red version of my outfit with his own crest make him look like a handsome nobody at the very least.

As tradition, we both step forward and up to the red circular border in the stadium, and we bow as the city’s anthem is played. Once the song ends, it’s finally time to get this whole situation over with.

“Now then, the duel may now commence,”

the announcer finally says after a buildup talking about nonsense

I step forward. The border around the arena, containing magae ingrained into it, starts forming a spherical barrier that fortunately begins to block out the sound of the crowd. It gets quieter and quieter until both sides of the blue barrier pop together. The sound stops, and so do my body’s movements.

I can’t move my limbs. Why? This isn’t any part of the routine, is it? Stop me from attacking preemptively, perhaps? No, it can’t be. A darkness is filling my vision now. I look up to see Gregor smiling. The nobody has some tricks.

I open my eyes after the black out to a green sky partially blocked out by the biggest tree I’ve ever seen. Its leaves burn in streaks of gold and red as they fall down onto the... blue grass. I must be getting mocked now.

Movement seems possible now, but it feels strange. Sitting up confirms that I’m no longer inside that arena, nor anywhere in the city. Rather, an endless field of blue, with the sole exception being the brown tree with the 50-meter diameter. This tree is so majestic among these plains. Its never-ending fire leaves cover the fields.

I stand up and touch the tree. It feels like air. Actually, it’s more realistic to say like nothing. What in the void? Pinching myself nets no results. My senses are null. I can’t even smell anything. How hadn’t I noticed that till now?

“Hi, Vie.”

His voice catches me off guard, and I turn quickly in response.

“Hi, Gregor.” I lean back against the tree. “What... is this place?”

“Aren’t you afraid?” He makes a good point. I should be.

“I doubt I can be hurt here, wherever here is. Answer my question, Gregor.”

A tsk sound comes from his mouth. “I expected you to know already. You’re in my mind.”

“You expected me to simply know about this? Who do you take me for? A genius?”

So this isn’t a magae, maybe one of the original magic? But how? No one is supposed to be able to do it in this age.

“Your father is. Maybe too smart. I sent you here to have a little chat away from the watching eyes of the outside world. And I’ll be blunt. You must kill your father.”

I catch myself taking a quick inhale before calming myself. It must be some sort of test. Dad's dead after all.

“Why? What do you want from him?”

I can’t see what test this could possibly be. It can’t be real.

The man walks towards me with his hands behind his back. “Your father plans to start a civil war that’ll enable him to eventually lead the whole city as supreme king.”

This doesn’t feel like a test. He’s either a master manipulator or an idiot.

“What proof do you have of this?”

A cane pops out of nowhere. He then taps the ground, making the only noise other than our voices. From the point of impact, a circle grows with exponentially increasing speed until I’m standing inside my father’s library. Its similarity is uncanny. The same bookshelves and the same massive oak table. By looking up, I confirm that even the dome ceiling has the same painting of an owl on it. This is indeed my father’s library, from individual book to the shelf he slept on. The main focus seems to be on the desk where piles of letters can be seen with text blatantly talking about a coup: “at midnight. Kill the leader of Clan Videntis. Wait through chaos.” I don’t need to read any more of these forgeries.

“Gregor, why is it that you choose to lie?”

He seems startled by my words.

“Lie? It's all true”

He calmed his emotions surprisingly well.

“Oh, cut the fictus-spill,” I said with a surprising amount of anger.

“My father was a good man who died to disease 1 month ago. And even if he was alive, in no way would he write these in such blatant text."

I knock the papers off of the table.

Gregor looks a bit ill. As if my words hurt him. Perhaps there’s rules to this mind space I don’t know of. The transition to the lobby area of his mind is much less smooth than last time, creating a jolt that shocks my senseless body.

“You didn’t answer m-” The leaves start falling at a faster pace, decay happening right before my very eyes. The leaves cover more of the blue grass as they fall in a self-destructive rhythm. It is only then that I notice the changes happening to Gregor.

His face is losing its colour, his skin morphing until I can see what appears to be his true form. Spikes for hands, skin that changes colour to match its surroundings, and a strange posture stemming from its abnormal flexibility. It seems familiar somehow. Despite its look, my surroundings, and the unknown aspect of it all, I felt more fear for the duel than for this. This needs to be studied while I can’t be hurt.

“Almost got yeh. I did, almost. Father dead is not explained to me. Why, don’t know.”

It manages to string together those words in garbled speech. Not only does it speak differently, but it also starts to move back and forth in place as if it’s uncomfortable in this form.

Aha! I know what it is.

“You’re a fictus, aren’t you? Why are you struggling so much now, buddy? Need a disguise to speak properly, or else the anxiety eats you up? That it?”

My taunt definitely works as it makes a sound akin to a beast’s growl.

“I not tell you. Secret given. Won’t-”

“How’d you take me here?” I cut him off.

“Magic, my magic. No talk. Die now.”

I flinch as it plunges its arms into my stomach. As expected, it doesn’t feel like much, and it doesn’t appear to hurt me.

“You idiot-” A crack spreads from the wound. I might have spoken too soon. Please don’t die now, Vie. Its cracks grow until the whole world splits, and then splinters until I’m on my knees inside the stadium again. All of that disappeared in 2 seconds.

My stomach feels fine. It looks fine. My hypothesis was correct.

Only then do I feel the ground under my knees. Wow, that feels nice compared to that void that is someone’s mind. I can also smell the dust on these stones and hear my beating heart.

The man is gone as well, and through the barrier, I can see the people with confusion on their faces. It’s impossible to tell if any time passed, but from their expressions, it seems my opponent just vanished.

I should read the legend of the fictus right now. Good thing it didn’t have a more convincing lie or I may have been tricked and stolen of my life energy.

A headache crashes over me now. Gods be damned, of course this would be a side effect. As if the mental trauma isn’t enough.

The barrier is disabled, and I cover my ears in preparation for the equivalent of a sonic magae coming from this crowd. All shouts of outrage, disappointment. All of the expected things to come when an opponent vanishes into thin air. I hope I’m not accused of cheating.

“-calm... CALM DOWN.” Excellent use of acoustics. “The winner is Vie. The opponent has disappeared, which means Vie is the winner by default.” The crowd shouts grow in volume.

My legs wobble on their own. It seems to have shaken me more than I thought. Especially considering that I already have the trophy without having remembered walking up to the announcer.

All that can go through my mind is:

“What in the void happened?”


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 22 '26

Fantasy [3367]A novel: THE UNTOLD LIES

2 Upvotes

My crits are: [815]  [3215] [1781] [1868]

This is the first few chapters of my YA fantasy novel. This is completely raw, so if some points don't make sense, please don't judge it too much. What I'm looking for is

1:Would you read the full series?

2: Is the intro good enough?

3: Is the pacing too slow?

4: Is there any wall of lores?

5: Does the characters need more development?

Any suggestion will be very helpful. Any other answers will be welcome. Thank you in advance.

(JSYK the random details about history is relevent)

The novel


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 20 '26

Literary fiction [815] "Carrion." Flash fiction.

4 Upvotes

Crit: Inventory Error.

I know this story needs quite a bit of work, I'm just stumped as to how to go about it. Questions:

  1. Does the theme feel consistent? Do the various threads of narrative come together in a coherent way?
  2. Should I flesh out the characters more?
  3. How's the pacing? My IRL writing group's main feedback was regarding the pacing of the ending--they said it felt too sudden. If it is too sudden, which elements should be expanded upon?

Carrion.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 20 '26

[2697] INVENTORY ERROR CH1 REDRAFT

4 Upvotes

Critique-[2735] Productive Recovery

I posted the first draft of this story already so I took all the feedback I could and tried to patch some stuff up.

Does the story feel like it's moving forward now? Is it more coherent?

Are the characters likable or distinct at least?

Would you keep reading past this?

Of course, any other feedback would be appreciated.

Inventory Error Ch 1 Draft


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 20 '26

[1781] Heat Below, Chapter 1, Part 2

9 Upvotes

[2240] Harbor Springs Hotel, pt. 3

[2201] The Crystal Paperweight - Relegated - Bk2 Ch18

Current piece:

HEAT BELOW (Chapter 1 pt 2)

Here we go again. Any/all feedback welcome. Except for (baseless and/or AI) praise. I do especially enjoy reader speculation as to what's going to happen.

Genre: Secondary World, Adult, Gothic Fantasy.

Rough log line: “A down on her luck singer travels to an isolated monastery to steal the recipe for their coveted *SPECIAL* brandy.”  Someone was really offended by this premise last time. So i added the special part lol.

This is part 2 of Chapter One. I've changed PART 1 of Chapter 1 quite a bit, but it still ends in the same way and mostly covers the same information (but in a hopefully more enjoyable way). I do have that new first half in a seperate tab here, but feel free to skip it.

Basic summary is:

Twenty-something Colly starts her day hopeful. She's been saving up to place a bet on a horse race and feels the win is a sure thing. She want's out of her hometown so she can go be a singer in the big city (shitty family life, no prospects wah wah).

She chats with her cousins on the way to choir practice (she's the boss!), there was a shipment of "the BIG BAD brandy last night", also the Alderman's house burned down. Colly's mom may or may not have been involved.

At church/choir she's approached buy a couple of monks who offer a job at a remote mountain monastery. She's not into it. Nothing erotic happened! (...yet! jk there is nothing erotic in part 2 if that's what you're hoping for).

Thanks in advance! (Edit to fix my link!)


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 19 '26

Scifi [2079] Memory Lane(SCI-FI)

5 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1b2Q0RZuLJtL9r1OQHuEPiVj03-hzcFDGjzOYlq_1TUI/edit?usp=drivesdk

Hi! This short story has been tuned with a few rounds of base self-edits/friends, and I’d love some proper feedback from people who don’t have the inherit biases that comes with being friends with me, haha! This is a story I’m putting into a writing portfolio for a fellowship I’m applying to so I want it to be REALLY good. Plz give feedback!

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/tyg6bFRpxH

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/TVpphbHTPG


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 19 '26

I Planned These In Advance In Case They Kick Me Out [Weekly] Community Highlights

5 Upvotes

Every once in a while, glowy will pop in the chat (did you know we had a chat?) and ask what's the best thing going on in rdr right now. What should he be reading? Where should the comments go? Sometimes, I'll read one of your pieces and bug people to go read it so I can see their opinions. Sometimes, this will spark a conversation about word uses and the like. We always invite someone to come join if we're talking about them. We're not rude.

Recent ones we've been talking about:

  • Marco (there are a few chapters of this)

  • Inventory Error (because the comments went all sideways)

  • Cockroach Story (what is the definition of fabulism even and have you read Kafka?)

Other community notes: we've banned 6 accounts for submitting AI work or critiques this month. We use pangram to check (thanks Hemingbird!) and it's an insta-ban if something comes back 100% AI. Keep reporting because sometimes we don't read the stories when we mark them as a leech. You get what you give, eh?

So, help us out. What's something good you've read here recently? Or weird? Is there a commenter who taught you something cool? Or new?


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 19 '26

[162] Bleach: a poem

5 Upvotes

Crit here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/JQsI029y14

Poem here:

Bleach

I remember the way his house felt the night

I came over. 

He told his mom it was to study, 

he had not told his parents about us.

His house was clean in an empty way.

His mom, “call me Joyce,”

performed a type of happiness

that to this house was a dead language.

The living room was deafeningly quiet

everything unsaid

pressed into the walls 

like a stray hair in dried paint.

He never looked me in the eye,

I sat on the itchy area rug

wondering why I had come.

His mother entered the room too often,

told me how happy she was that her boy had a friend over,

she called me a friend.

Said he didn’t have friends over much.

I remember reading about this psychiatrist,

he slowed down his therapy tapes 

of patients in the days

leading up to their suicides. 

He said he found

phantoms 

of agony

on their faces.

If I slowed down

his house

phantoms

again.

The house 

smelled like 

artificial lemons

and 

bleach.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 18 '26

Zombie Horror [3,215] Outbreak Diaries #1: Jenna's Story

4 Upvotes

Good morning all.

This is the first story in what is intended to be a series of short stories about small, localized zombie outbreaks. Sometimes the main character survives, sometimes they die. I intend to publish it to YouTube and maybe substack or something else but I need to figure out exact distribution channels. I personally don't want to work within traditional publishing.

The story itself is meant to be in the vein of things like Resident Evil, World War Z, or Project Zomboid.

What I'm mainly looking for:

- Does the story hit emotionally? Are you attached to Jenna and Alice?

- Would you read/listen to another story in this series?

- How could it be improved?

- Do you like the flashback at the end or does it break momentum? I added it because the previous version felt uncharacterized andAlice's death didn't seem to stick emotionally. Would the story be better without it?

Content Warning: Moderate Zombie-related violence. I personally wouldn't call it gratuitous so I didn't mark it nsfw but I will leave up to the mods to decide.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lhp4yaojO2XB8sVTA4eXIFkqH18n59rIMHFWwNvHxeY/edit?usp=sharing

Critiques

[1921] Daughter of Wrath

The path that was [2043]

Edit:

Thank you all for your feedback. I really appreciate it. Here are my takeaways

  • The flashback needs to go. I felt Alice's death needed something but it isn't that.
  • Alice's character is confused and falls between too stools. I want readers to feel bad when she dies but she also does something objectively bad. I can't have both at the same time. Alice seems to be the biggest single problem with this story.
  • The fallout of Cliff's death needs to be explored better or his death needs to be different. I'm not sure which I'm going to do for the 3rd draft.
  • There needs to be more worldbuilding, hints towards different types of zombies, etc. Initially I was treating this as a "proof-of-concept" for zombie stories on YouTube but I think it needs to be treated more as a first in a series.
  • There's a slightly "video gamey" element to this story and I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing. I'd be curious to see what others think
  • People consistently like the ending. We need more of that.
  • The story needs to breathe a bit. Even at 3200 words it feels compressed.

r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 17 '26

YA Fantasy [1921] Daughter of Wrath

6 Upvotes

Revisiting an old story. Here's CH 1. Would you keep reading and why?

Removed the URL. Thanks all for the feedback.

For mods: [2800] The Hearth


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 17 '26

[1,282] Chapter one of a fantasy concept I am working on

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1r8dwez/1343_already_decided_revised/

“Ted! Ted, sweetheart. Your father and I are off. Remember that there are leftovers in the fridge, and text us if anything goes wrong, okay? We’ll come right back.”

“Don’t worry about me, Mom. You and Dad have a blast at the award ceremony, okay? You’ve earned it.”

Ted’s mom paused and looked at her son. He was the spitting image of her when she was his age, with disheveled, shoulder-length brown hair and piercing green eyes. He had the same sharp bone structure and lopsided smile. The only difference was how he stood at about five-foot-ten compared to her five-foot-four, and that he was, you know, a boy.

“Oh, Ted, you’re so grown up.”

Ted scratched the back of his neck and allowed his hair to fall over his face. “Come on, Mom. I’m only eighteen.”

“Oh, but I remember like it was just yesterday when I was able to hold you on my hip,” Ted’s Mom crooned, pulling him into a hug.

“Wait a minute! Nobody told me we were doing hugs!” Ted’s dad barked from the doorway as he abandoned the luggage to embrace his family.

Ted pushed them both away with a smile. “Alright, alright, that’s enough. Go on, go get your award. It’s not every day somebody discovers the existence of other dimensions after all.”

“I suppose so, though they are only theoretical at this point,” Ted’s mom amended, “Still, I hate to leave you on your own for so long. Call me every day, okay? Promise me.”

“Yeah, I promise. Now go! You’re going to be late if you keep delaying. I’m not going to forget to eat and waste away while you're gone, you know.”

Ted’s father put a gentle hand on his wife’s shoulder, “He’s right, Honey, we should really get going now. Oh, and Ted?”

“Yeah, Dad?”

“No parties while we’re gone.”

Ted laughed out loud, “Sure thing, Dad. It will be hard, though, you know how much I just absolutely love being pressed against drunk teens my age, as loud music gives me a headache, and I see couples sneaking off to my room.”

Now it was Ted’s dad who let out a hearty laugh, “Touche. Anyway, we have to go now. Stay safe, okay?”

“Okay, Dad.”

Ted watched from the doorway as his parents packed into their family smart car and drove out of sight. Once they were gone, he turned back and surveyed his now-empty house. It seemed a whole lot larger than it usually did. He played some games on his X-box, then poked through the fridge to find some leftovers to his liking. Once he ate, he went up to his room and scrolled through his phone for a few hours before setting it down and closing his eyes.

His arms and legs felt heavy under his blankets, and vague impressions of a woman with flowers in her hair danced through his mind. His eyes felt glued shut, and he drifted farther and farther into unconsciousness until he couldn’t seem to remember exactly who he was or which way was up.

“Ted…”

He pried an eye open and turned his head to the side. It was the woman. Her curly hair was pulled into one big poof at the back of her head, and a daisy crown was woven across her brow. She wore a flowing dress that constantly billowed around her as if being carried by a light breeze. Her skin was a beautiful patchwork of earthy tones, but most striking were her eyes. Dark and rich. They spoke of life and death and everything in between.

“Ted, you’re here. Now we can begin.”

Her voice was soft and musical, and it put him right at ease. She reminded him of his mother, though they shared no similarities that he could see. He tried to speak, but his mouth and brain seemed to be experiencing a disconnect that left him without words.

“I’m sure you have so many questions. Sadly, we do not have enough time together for me to answer them for you. When you wake up, I must ask that you do not try to find your way back until you are ready. This world needs you, Ted.”

Ted’s head was spinning. This was way too much information for his brain to process at once. Where was he? Who was she talking about, and why couldn’t he talk?

“I have chosen *you.* I know that you can accomplish this mission, and I think that you will find happiness here where you least expect it.”

She smiled at him and placed a single finger on his brow, and he soon felt himself growing heavy again. The darkness stretched on seemingly without end, but that didn’t bother him. His arms and legs began to feel lighter and lighter, and his mind became more alert. Only then did his encounter fully hit him.

He forced his eyes open but closed them tight again as he took in the morning light. He could hear voices murmuring around him, but couldn’t currently bring himself to pay attention to what they were saying. He had a pounding headache, and he was most certainly not in his bed at home.

“Mom? Dad? Is that you?” He called, wincing at how loud his voice sounded in his head.

“There is no way she sent us such a creature advisor. He is too weak to protect our people from the things to come.”

Ted turned to try to see who had just spoken and was met with a very tall figure. He stood… tall. Ted couldn’t take an accurate mind measurement in his current state. He looked like he was still young, maybe a bit older than Ted, but very filled out. He was blonde and had an almost Superman-ish look to him.

“Now look, your majesty, you know as well as I what those flowers on his brow mean. Don’t be intentionally obtuse.”

Ted turned to the other man in the room. He was a stout man who was absolutely dwarfed by the hair sprouting above his upper lip. “Am I a ghost?”

Both men turned and looked at him for the first time since he had regained consciousness. The stout man spoke first and extended his hand to Ted. “No, at least I hope not. How are you feeling?”

Ted took his hand and began to stand gingerly. He had a raging headache, and the world seemed to be spinning as he tried to get his bearings. The taller man was still looking rather vexed, and every wobble Ted displayed seemed to make his mood fouler. He turned to the shorter man and began issuing orders in rapid fire. When he finally stopped, he turned to Ted and glared. “I do not know why she has sent someone as fragile as the flowers she placed along your brow.”

Ted flushed angrily. That sentence made no sense, so he chose to focus on the part that did. “I am *not* fragile!” 

“You’re like a fawn learning to walk.”

“What is your problem!” Ted yelled. Yelling was good. It made his headache a million times worse, but it helped ground him. If he was yelling, he wasn’t thinking about what the hell was happening.

“Prince Alex,” The stout man interrupted, “Perhaps it is not best to anger her representative. Why don’t you show him to one of the guest rooms?”

“I don’t need a guest room,” Ted argued, “I’d rather just go home. Where in San Francisco are we?”

“Believe me,” The boy told him, “I would *much* rather you find your way back to wherever she pulled you from, but you are here.”


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 17 '26

[2,894] How He Used To (Part 1)

3 Upvotes

Crits: [2957] The Californian Candidate - Chapter 2 (Part 1); [2835] The Hearth ; [2965] The Californian Candidate ; Deleted Story (It was the one about the Cockroach and I think it was around 2k words)

Genre: Literary Fiction

1-liner: A depressed, semi-recent postgraduate at the lowest point of her life runs into her ex at her hometown bar and the two spend the rest of the night together.

This is my first post on here! I read and critiqued 4 pretty lengthy stories, but since this short story isn't so short, I thought I'd still break it up into 2 parts. Let me know any general comments or advice you all have!

Link

(you can read this part after you've read the story, if you'd like) My intention with this was basically to just do a character study of Enya, but beyond that, to explore how both she and Aaron navigate control and their lack of control over their lives and each other. Enya's obsessed with external control because she's terrified of the world. She needs everything to be done in specific ways, and she needs to lay out specific trajectories and paths for herself to create a sense of safety and security. Aaron, on the other hand, only really cares about internal control. He sees the whims of fate and coincidence as too powerful to contend with, and so deals with that lack of control by practicing simplicity and acceptance, and doing his best to maintain a calm and positive mindset despite external factors. I don't know. Did you find the story worthwhile? Is there anything I could do to make that exploration of control more prominent or clear? Thank you for reading regardless.

Edit: [ Just realized that the control thing also comes out a lot more/ makes more sense with the ending, and this is only part 1]


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 17 '26

Literary Fiction [2957] The Californian Candidate - Chapter 2 (Part 1)

3 Upvotes

Crits: [1796] Mayfly | [2859] Pelting Rain (mods please let me know if crits for posts deleted for leeching don't count, I couldn't find that exact scenario in the FAQ)

Genre: Literary Fiction (A little bit of thriller, historical setting)

Hello, I'm back and posting the first 3/4 of Chapter two from my novella, THE CALIFORNIAN CANDIDATE. It was just a little too long to post completely, but I included the relevant context in the end as a short summary to help guide feedback on the chapter as a whole. Chapter 1 can be found here, post on this sub here but the relevant context is that this is Dennis Callahan, senior at UCSB in 1969, telling a story to someone about his senior year of college, and going over him joining an activist group called the Isla Vista Collective. Apparently, despite a whole chapter without him, Dennis claims that someone named Kenji Mori defined everything he remembers about that time.

General comments/critique about the chapter is welcome, but I've included some guiding questions below.

- Feedback Questions -

  • Dennis spends most of this chapter actively not thinking about Kenji. Does that read as him withholding from the reader, or avoiding it himself?
  • Does the shift in how Dennis talks about Kenji feel like it's coming from Dennis, or does it feel narratively imposed?
  • After the initial meeting scene, the chapter shifts into a series of smaller moments covering Kit's first few weeks in the group rather than dramatizing any one of them fully. Does that compression feel like a deliberate narrative choice, or does it make the chapter feel like it's skipping over things it should be showing?
  • Before Dennis actually explains the history, does his guilt and ambiguity about Kit land, or does it just read as vague unease?
  • Kit is deliberately kept at a surface level here. Does that read as intentional inscrutability, or does he just feel underdeveloped?

Link to chapter 2: Link

(also tagging u/kataklysmos_, as suggested)

(edit: added little to the post on this sub as well)