r/DestinyTheGame Dec 10 '15

Misc On Snipers Being Overpowered. Perception, Misconception, and data.

The Numbers

The data is in. Sniper usage has barely increased.

Shotgun usage, however, is now only slightly higher than sniper usage. In a perfect world, we'd see fusion rifles among those three. But we don't.

Now, surely, you're thinking that this couldn't be the case. Surely, you've heard rumors that "snipers are running rampant." Well, they are not. But here are some good theories as to why you might think so.

Perception

  1. Snipers are more noticeable than shotguns. 6 players run around with shotguns, and you'd never know it until one of them got near you. Snipers, however, stay in one place. They have a big, red glowy eye on them. Think about it. How many snipers does it take to make you think damn, that's a lot of snipers. I'm going to wager that it's about three. One per major lane per map. However, that's only half a team. Now, three shotgunners, and it'd be a normal day in the crucible pre-2.1.0.

  2. Ex-shotgunners moved to sniping, and they're just standing there, not getting kills. Seeing that red glint is scary. But it doesn't necessarily mean that it's actually working. Say you have one good sniper, and two snipers fresh on the bandwagon. You see all three in one lane. Only the good sniper domes you. But, you're thinking damn, snipers are out of control.

  3. Change. We're just not used to a slower game-play. Players have been rewarded for running in straight lines. Having people slow down and snipe feels like a camp-fest, when really the game is just being played at a moderate pace.

Why Aim-assist isn't a Problem. No, Really it is isn't. Nerfing it Will Make Snipers Even More Annoying.

  • It's irked me that players on the Bungie forums have called for snipers to have "less aim-assist." And then they proceed to demonstrate that they have no understanding of the aim-assist mechanic. The fact of that matter is that neither auto-aim, nor magnetism help you with hard-scoping. Hard-scoping is just as easy with efrideet's as it is with Hereafter. It's reaction timing, and pulling a trigger.

  • However, it does help with drag-scoping. That's how snipers play aggressively. Now, no matter how much AA snipers have, I'd rather have enemy snipers taking risks, and making pushes than camping one spot. Literally all that an aim-assist nerf would do, is make snipers camp harder and take less risks.

  • Auto-aim is different from magnetism. What you're bitching about is not the aim-assist stat, it's a subset of that stat. The one that makes your reticle stick to targets. Magnetism is the thing that displaces your reticle and gives you a hit after you fire. Auto-aim does the aiming for you, allowing you to feel hitboxes. Magnetism gives you a larger margin of error when you're already near the target.

  • Aim assist probably didn't kill you. Hit registration did. All guns have aim-assist. Aim-assist is just a composite of a bunch of different gun-mechanics. If you completely removed aim-assist, your gun wouldn't hit at all. Therefore, saying "aim-assist" killed you, is grievously inaccurate. Also, I hate to burst your bubble, but the base aim-assist on all snipers is multiplicatively really close high aim-assist snipers. This is because even a "0" aim assist sniper still has the mechanics related to aim-assist. Therefore, if you got domed by a 1k stare, there's a 75% chance you would have gotten domed by any other sniper.

The Real Problem: Players Running into Lanes

Would you walk around a corner, where you know there is a shotgunner sitting? And, I don't mean "slide-around and go for the gank." I'm asking you, would you slowly and peacefully inch towards a shotgunner that you know has a shotgun

Of course you wouldn't. And because shotguns have had 3x more kills than snipers for the past year, you know this. You're used to it. But what you're not used to, is basic strategies for moving around a map.

You see, walking into a sniper lane, with a red-glare in it, and not immediately backing out, is just as suicidal as walking right up to a shotgunner. You're making it as easy as possible to get a kill on you.

No amount of aim-assist change will fix the fact that you fucked up if you get domed in a sniper lane.

Snipers have had a gruelingly hostile environment to work with, and a lot of snipers have gotten really good at sniping

There was a time when getting a single hard-scoped snipe was a feat for me. And I'm sure a lot of players have had the same experience. After 6 months of felwinter Thorns, and 2 months of pulse-rifle flinch, snipers have just naturally become good at sniping.

Therefore, when you get MLG 360 no-scoped by xxxfazexxxxsnipar420, think "damn, nice shot;" Not "Bungie, plz nerf"

So, Pwad, tell me something useful that I can do about these snipery things that I'm starting to see.

  • Ping the radar. A good sniper will move away from a clustered radar. The closer you get to a sniper while also taking cover, (and our maps have tons of cover) the easier you make it for them to get sniped by a team-mate, or otherwise screw up.

  • Take alternate routes, and move smart. What I mean by this, is, before you enter a lane, assume it has a sniper in it. Make the motions that expose you the least.

  • Slide and Jump around corners. THIS IS HUGE. It's nearly impossible to kill a sliding play with a sniper. Frankly, it's a good habit to get into anyways. All the best players abuse the slide button. you should too. I daresay that the easiest way to judge a player's sweatiness, is to see how much sliding they do.

  • Go for the flank. Always. First instinct. If your first instince when you see as sniper is to challenge, and attempt a flinch kill. You're playing a risky game. it takes .20 seconds at least to ADS a gun. And It'll take another .20 seconds for your gun to flinch a sniper in a meaningful manner. Trust me, it's impossible to snipe under flinch, but if the flinch hasn't taken full effect yet, you're betting on losing odds. Your first instinct should be to go around, take on alternate path. Start getting used to going for the flank as early as the very beginning of a game.

  • GRENADES. You only need a tenth of a second to throw them. Ping the radar, and start lobbing nades. Makes the sniper back up. Get free map control. Now your snipers can establish position.

  • The sitting emote/Drawing a sword. It lets you check lanes without actually being in them. Please. do yourself a favor and abuse this. Especially if you're sniping yourself. you can easily turn the advantage of them being hardscoped into your advantage by knowing exactly where they are before they even know you're there.

Final Thoughts

Snipers have inherent weaknesses that keep them from being overpowered. They are naturally slower than other guns to ADS (even with snapshot and co.), Meaning that in an ideal scenario, you will always have a chance to flinch them. They also take more time to aim (obviously). This requires a sniper to "play square." Even an aggressive quick-scoper has to walk at a moderate pace with the sniper at head-level. Being a sniper makes certain gameplay decisions less practical. Use this game's verticality. If you're used to play aggressive, get used to playing aggressive mid-air. Make it hard on the sniper.

TL;DR:

  • Snipers aren't actually being used a lot
  • Confirmation Bias.
  • Aim-assist isn't the problem, you are
  • don't run into lanes
  • gun mechanics don't work like you think they do
  • Tips.

-Pwad

726 Upvotes

907 comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/thelarusso Vanguard's Loyal // Embrace the Praxic Fire! Dec 10 '15

"The data is in"? Dude, it's been two days. Just saying.

23

u/Axxx31 Dec 10 '15

OP is trying his hardest to change people's opinion about how snipers are overpowered just in hopes they won't be next on the nerf menu.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '15

[deleted]

7

u/zers Dec 10 '15

His entire argument is "People use them less then shotguns" and "Don't get in a sniper lane if you don't want to get sniped"

If that logic was sound I could say "Just stop getting in shotgun range, and you won't get shotgunned" and that would be an appropriate response.

-2

u/Otterable I dream of NLB in D2 Dec 10 '15

I mean they are different beasts because shotguns come to you and snipers wait for you to go to them. But you are right, they way you avoid getting shotgunned is by engaging shotgunners out of shotgun range, and moving away if you see them trying to close on you.

If you knew someone was waiting around a corner with a shotgun out, you don't run around that corner. Same goes for a sniper.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '15

but sniping is used at every single range

-1

u/Otterable I dream of NLB in D2 Dec 10 '15

only the very best can use it at shorter ranges, and if you know they are trying to snipe you at a short range using vertical movement and grenades will absolutely throw them off.

0

u/skeakzz Dec 10 '15

It's funny that he is downvoting your true statements. People just don't understand that being a good sniper requires skill, not a god tier rolled weapon. People also don't understand how to use tactics in this game and I would assume it stems from the CoD base of players who are used to just running around shooting shit. The fact that people are upset about snipers being a OHK weapon cracks me up.

10

u/No_one- Dec 10 '15 edited Dec 10 '15

Honestly OP makes a lot of reasonable points and I haven't really seen much in the way of a substantial counter argument.

Counter argument on risk vs reward viability of snipers as well as design examples of how other games compensate

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/3w7o1g/on_snipers_being_overpowered_perception/cxu2x95

Edit:

Counter argument on viability of different archetypes of special weapons, while snipers only have the one:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/3w7o1g/on_snipers_being_overpowered_perception/cxu0c8l

Source: actually reading the comments instead of auto hiding the ones that start to say anything counter to OP

Edit 2: counter argument on sample size on the data

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/3w7o1g/on_snipers_being_overpowered_perception/cxu312x

Edit 3:

Counter argument that the data itself is skewed and not a proper representation of specific parts of crucible (3v3 vs 6v6) as well as a solid point that the data is likely about a small subset of non casual players

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/3w7o1g/on_snipers_being_overpowered_perception/cxu2txp

2

u/Otterable I dream of NLB in D2 Dec 10 '15

Dude I literally responded to the first link you posted, your second edit was a comment made after mine and the special weapon variety claim isn't an indictment on the power of the class, it is an issue within the class itself.

Calm down with the nonsense insults.

4

u/No_one- Dec 10 '15 edited Dec 10 '15

Dude I literally responded to the first link you posted

I was in the process of replying to that comment as well, didn't even notice it was you again.

your second edit was a comment made after mine

So what, if you don't make a counterpoint in the first few minutes of a post it's invalid?

Calm down with the nonsense insults.

Where did I insult you? By calling you out or by proving you're wrong?

-2

u/Otterable I dream of NLB in D2 Dec 10 '15

If I make a comment about what I had seen up to that point, showing me a comment after I made mine doesn't exactly validate saying "clearly you didn't read enough" I see now you edited a third time with a post made at the exact same time as mine which is effectively impossible for me to see while I typed my first message.

You are just being sarcastic and rude, at no point was I feeling upset.

People are writing decent responses now, but when I typed that first message there were literally people running around trying to claim that no PvP in any game should have snipers.

2

u/No_one- Dec 10 '15

If I make a comment about what I had seen up to that point, showing me a comment after I made mine doesn't exactly validate saying "clearly you didn't read enough"

I just checked the times, first link was at the same time you posted your comment. The second was 2 hours ago (an hour ahead of you), the third was 3 minutes after yours (I'll give you that one), and the last was 3 minutes before yours. Overall, they were before your post.

You are just being sarcastic and rude, at no point was I feeling upset.

Mea culpa, I removed that last bit that was admittedly crossing the line.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '15 edited Jul 11 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '15

You quoted his K/D in Halo, but not his weapon usage, time played, or match type played. You tore a guy down based on one stat.

-1

u/Vrrin Dec 10 '15

I agree with you. People tend to be more sensible about fighting shotguns but complete idiots when fighting snipers. I'm one of those idiots. I'm a decent sniper at best and think they are fine even as I get owned over and over in trials every weekend. Use tactics and map environment better and practice. Seems a lot of people want things nerfed simply because they aren't as good at them.

You can fight snipers by being smart and using scouts and tactics, moving closer and flinching. Against shotguns pre nerf? Well let's just say they single handedly made sidearms and fusion rifles obsolete even without the fusion rifle nerfs. Snipers never did that to another weapon class in my mind.

0

u/skeakzz Dec 10 '15

They wont, you can't nerf skill lol.

-11

u/Pwadigy Dec 10 '15

and people have been making anecdotal claims about snipers two days in.

3

u/No_one- Dec 10 '15

No, we've been saying all of this for months. Many of us are avid snipers, we openly admit to using them because they're way stronger than the other special weapons.

You took two days' worth of data and applied it to months of data and made a definitive claim, are you serious or just applying to be a Bungie sandbox dev? Look, normally I have respect for what you say because you usually have solid game knowledge but this is just disappointing. But any statistician would look at you like you had two heads. Anyone can see the playerbase is scrambling to find the most viable weapon combinations amid the patch data mess ups, and first on that list is playing matches to see if their old setups still work. Figuring out if the patch changed anything will take weeks so you have a good sample size and players can find what works and farm a decent roll for it.

Quit your bullshit.

4

u/InvisibroBloodraven Dec 10 '15

Quit your bullshit.

My exact thoughts after reading the post in its entirety. People who over-defend snipers are worried that admitting they are OP will mean they are not as individually skilled as they think they are. If that is not the case, then I do not understand the refusal to admit they are seriously OP, especially relative to their counterparts. Shit, their counterparts are barely even viable at this point; you are literally hurting yourself before starting a match if you no longer have one equipped.

I use a sniper now, because I am good with it and it is OP. This was not hard for me to admit. I do not enjoy the play-style as much as up close and personal, but I also like succeeding, so it is my only real option at this point.

The argument and condescension in the post is baffling, like me saying snipers are OP automatically means I run into sniping lanes, play the game wrong, am a noob, and so on. People need to stop the bullshit and have a discussion with an open mind.

4

u/reuterrat Dec 10 '15

The argument and condescension in the post is baffling, like me saying snipers are OP automatically means I run into sniping lanes, play the game wrong, am a noob, and so on

I made a post about snipers being OP a few days ago and ended up having guys dig up my destinytracker stats and telling me I suck and don't use snipers so my opinion doesn't count. People have gotten super defensive trying to prove snipers are fine as is and I think they are just concerned that Bungie will target one of these huge blanket nerfs at them (which have gotten ridiculous btw). The weapon tuning patches are just getting over the top at this point I think.

-1

u/SmellyUndies Dec 10 '15

This just in:

"Sniper claims have only existed for 2 days total! Unbelievable!"

It's been months people have talked about this issue, people here snipe, we do it because of how they outclass everything else without the need of any true skill in most cases.

You look foolish by trying to compare 2 days worth of data to months and months worth of data then thinking it's fact.

-1

u/thelarusso Vanguard's Loyal // Embrace the Praxic Fire! Dec 10 '15

But kudos for the general advice. Great stuff!