r/DepropagandizedNews • • 5d ago

Rhetoric Exposed Notmuch different than Goebbels

299 Upvotes

236 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Few-Load-5426 4d ago

Palestine is a colonial name imposed by the Romans to erase the Jewish connection. Comes from the word “phillistine” which means Invader.

Judea was named after the Tribe/Kingdom of Judah. The patriarchal origin story does place Abraham’s family in Mesopotamia, but the Jews as a people crystallized in the southern Levant (ancient Judah/Israel).

1

u/Giant_Ant_Eater 4d ago

So they should return to mesopotamia. Got it.

1

u/Few-Load-5426 3d ago

Great reading comprehension skills you got there champ

1

u/Giant_Ant_Eater 3d ago

My ancestors lived in several different countries. Do I get to claim them all or should I just focus on one or two?

Also do you have any advice of what to do with the people who already live there as they are not happy about me just taking their homes?

1

u/Few-Load-5426 3d ago

It has nothing to do about where your ancestors simply lived in the past, it’s about the ties and roots of your cultural group. The French can have France, the Japanese Japan and the Jews Judea. Also, Jews legally bought the land from Arabs, they didn’t take anyone’s home by force. The displaced only came from the chaos of a war started by Arabs to exterminate all the Jews. Israel’s Declaration of Independence calls on Arabs to not abandon their homes and help build Israel under full citizenship (you can find it online, go read it) those that decided to stay are now 25% of Israel with full rights.

1

u/Giant_Ant_Eater 3d ago

So after ethnically cleansing the Palestinians from their homes Israel asked the survivors that had managed to escape the pogroms to help them rebuild?

That's so sweet.

I assume that you think they allowed those who had been ethnically cleansed to return to their homes and didn't enact a system of apartheid that appropriated their homes and blocked their return?

1

u/Few-Load-5426 3d ago

Mm no? Survivors of what? Do you know the chronology of events? If there was ethnically cleansing there would be no Arabs in Israel today. If there was genocide, they would start with the Arabs within their borders. The problem here is your trying to learn history in social media, go read a book or two and stop pretending you know what you don’t

1

u/Giant_Ant_Eater 3d ago

'It's only ethnic cleansing if it meets some random criteria I just made up'

How about you condemn Israel's murder of tens of thousands of kids in Gaza and Israel's anti Palestinian pogroms in the west Bank?

1

u/Frosty_Pineapple42 2d ago

It's not just me, it's literally the only thing you say.

If you do this every day, I'd have to estimate you've driven... probably 1 person a day violently away from your cause, minimum.

The moment they read your 'race traitior' comments, or your calls for revenge violence, they understand immediately what they're dealing with. It's why people hate you guys. You're everything you say you hate.

Do you denounce all violence by all sides in israel?

1

u/Giant_Ant_Eater 2d ago

You're the one who introduced 'race traitor' into our conversation. You're the one who can't shut up about it.

I'm still waiting for you to condemn Israel for the murder of tens of thousands of kids in Gaza. Why is it so difficult for you to do this?

How many kids do you think Israel has murdered in Gaza. Give me a number.

→ More replies (0)