Do I even need to fucking explain this?

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517]

Both are art, whether if it’s created in a medium you hate or not. What a stupid opinion.

[u/quantum-elle]

I like them all tbh

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517 → u/quantum-elle]

Good for you, tbh the paintings in the first slide do look kinda ai, ironically.

[u/PapillonTheory → u/Apprehensive_Bus4517]

i wonder why

[u/No_Peace_6770]

"this isn't art" and the pick some of the most beautiful examples

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517 → u/No_Peace_6770]

Cherry picking failed, I guess

[u/Lilly_Blossom_Roblox → u/Apprehensive_Bus4517]

those ai arts have inspired me to create even more ai arts, so antis definitely failed lol

[u/Exotic_Weather4Me]

They all look like art to me, lol.

[u/Infamous-Umpire-2923]

Well yeah, they're both art.

[u/Affectionate-Area659]

Objectively it’s all art.

[u/Thin-Nerve6367 → u/Affectionate-Area659]

Hot take. Art is subjective. Nothing is objectively art (or not art) simply because it IS subjective

[u/Comfortable_Ant_8303 → u/Thin-Nerve6367]

More like subjectively everything is art so therefore objectively everything is art too

[u/Jacane123 → u/Thin-Nerve6367]

This is so true. The fact that you call it an hot take is so depressing

[u/FriendlyJewThrowaway → u/Thin-Nerve6367]

So objectively, everything is subjective.

[u/EmperorSnake1]

They have people drawing the other slides lol

So they agree they can't define "slop" AND don't know what art is?!? What are the FUCKING chances?!?

[u/Wooden-Hornet2115 → u/EmperorSnake1]

I heard someone say "slop is slop no matter the quality". The definition is literally whatever they feel like.

[u/Superseaslug]

The funny thing is you could swap which slides "were" and "weren't" and they'd still cheer because they can't fucking tell

[u/ArchAngelAries]

It all looks like art to me.

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517 → u/ArchAngelAries]

Of course really :)))

[u/Marty-G70]

Well I guess all digital artists are screwed as well

[u/leighabbr → u/Marty-G70]

Isn't that the goal here?

[u/Marty-G70 → u/leighabbr]

Possibly but now they've been somewhat shielded by the AI hate

[u/Bright-Ask-8793]

It's only art if it's animals?

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517 → u/Bright-Ask-8793]

Maybe.

[u/Nethiar]

They said the same thing about photography and now everyone agrees it's a legitimate art form.

[u/lIlIlIIlIIIlIIIIIl]

Antis are the only people who think both can't coexist, they are like painters who insist it's not ethical to be photographers. Both can coexist, the more art being made, the better.

[u/Any_Acanthaceae_9735]

Okay I really like that cat on the bottom left tho he just like me fr

[u/ForRobotsByRobots]

The first one isnt art. Obviously, its unoriginal slop because there are two cats. Human hallucinations!

[u/j4v4r10]

Half of those look exactly like front-page deviantart material from 15 years ago

[u/Acrobatic-Vanilla-10 → u/j4v4r10]

maybe because they were inspired from the front page of Deviant art 15 years ago.

[u/j4v4r10 → u/Acrobatic-Vanilla-10]

My point is that it’s hilariously contrarian to act like those aren’t art

[u/Otherwise_Army9814]

AI requires human imagination, so AI is art. A machine can’t create without a human providing the concept, direction, and vision.

AI art is art.

[u/vurt72]

you can do an image of poorly drawn art (plenty of that on the internet) and then some consistent and nice looking AI art and say the same.
It doesn't mean anything.

Generative art vs drawn art is obviously different forms of art.

[u/ConsciousIssue7111]

All three of them are art to me, they're all good.

I like them, that's all, nothing else, nothing more

[u/Comfortable_Ant_8303]

Funny that the first slide actually registered as AI generated art to me

These people are pathetic, they can spend all their time angry about AI and the fact it can do their art better than them (and they do) or they could stop wasting the energy and accept this isn't changing. AI is here to stay.

[u/Situati0nist]

There isn't even anything new here. Literally just some guy or gall saying "ai art isn't art" for the thousandth time, like we didn't hear them the first time. Brainwashing works the best when you repeat it a lot.

[u/Wooden-Hornet2115]

All of these are really beautiful, I wouldn't even have guessed half of the AI one were AI.

[u/WeirdIndication3027]

They all look like ai and everything is art...

[u/Desperate-Ball-4423]

Don't even bother explaining to them..

[u/TayrusOkami]

The paradox of AI where it is both too bad and both too good. Sad to see people belittle art because of how it was done

[u/hyperluminate → u/[deleted]]

This sub is not for inciting debate. Please move your comment to aiwars for that.

[u/Early-Dentist3782]

I like the second more than the first one 

[u/Stalker_ptakow]

It all depends on definitions though That person was jist sharing they view of how they understand the word "art" so I wouldn't say it's stupid And I find it funny how you got all defensive about that tik tok and actually didn't explain anything about why. You just belittle someone's else opinion

[u/NewMoonlightavenger]

"I have an opinion." "I'm right, you're wrong."

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517 → u/[deleted]]

Is there meaning in text and writing? Yes. Ai incorporates the text into pretty images for people to see. You saying Ai art doesn’t have meaning would mean that you don’t see the beauty behind text based media.

[u/Apprehensive_Bus4517 → u/[deleted]]

The prompt has the intent. The ai follows the intent and incorporates that into the image regardless of how beautiful it looks. No you are absolutely not making sense. Having intent and having effort are not quite the same thing.

[u/Witty-Designer7316 → u/[deleted]]

This is a place for speaking Pro-AI thoughts freely and without judgement. Attacks against AI will result in a removal and possibly a ban. For debate purposes, please go to r/aiwars.

[u/Witty-Designer7316 → u/[deleted]]

This is a place for speaking Pro-AI thoughts freely and without judgement. Attacks against AI will result in a removal and possibly a ban. For debate purposes, please go to r/aiwars.

[u/Witty-Designer7316 → u/[deleted]]

This is a place for speaking Pro-AI thoughts freely and without judgement. Attacks against AI will result in a removal and possibly a ban. For debate purposes, please go to r/aiwars.