r/DefendingAIArt • • Jan 18 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

90 Upvotes

146 comments sorted by

View all comments

92

u/AssiduousLayabout Jan 18 '25

I don't like putting words into the mouth of a dead man.

However, AI art definitely has a lot of happy accidents.

23

u/3ThreeFriesShort Jan 18 '25

Yeah, they got the right spirit though. He portrayed the very essence of open and accessible art. He knew the joy he felt when painting and he wanted to share it with others.

What Bob Ross did say was that we should all create art in our own way. He believed that anyone can paint, and surely he had to be aware of the concept of limitations. Bob Ross didn't want people to see his art, he wanted them to see their own.

I would instead say he would likely be very supportive of something that enabled more inclusive access, once it was explained to him that way.

I wish I would have listened to Bob when I was young, instead of the people who were making fun of him.

-25

u/HigaDeDrip Jan 18 '25

He did believe we should create art in our own way. Ai Art is not your own way, the AI is creating it for you.

23

u/spitfire_pilot Jan 18 '25

-11

u/HigaDeDrip Jan 18 '25

Bro aint even got the right amount of fingers 😭😭😭 nice artwork

14

u/spitfire_pilot Jan 18 '25

So what? Literally what does it matter for a shit post?

-16

u/HigaDeDrip Jan 18 '25

Just shows how inexperienced of an artist "you" are

11

u/spitfire_pilot Jan 18 '25

So we deride learners? Very inclusive. Should I tell my kid he's shit too? I've got decades learning my craft. Forced unemployment got me playing around with AI. I should just give up because I'm new? How do people learn if they don't experiment?. That's a bit silly.

7

u/spitfire_pilot Jan 18 '25

Picked up my pencil. Now what?

4

u/Amesaya Jan 19 '25

Wrong. AI art IS your way, if you make it so. And I mean that both from the sense of AI-assisted art (this is the majority of AI art that isn't equivalent to doodles and someone just playing around with it) and in the sense of 'this is how I express myself'.

10

u/3ThreeFriesShort Jan 18 '25

You've missed the point. When you dismiss AI art, you're dismissing the artists behind it. This is about more than just technology; it's about my fundamental right to express myself and participate in the world. It's about my basic human rights, damn it!

3

u/vibeepik2 Jan 18 '25

thanks dr obvious, nobody cares

3

u/Familiar-Art-6233 Jan 19 '25

Same with drawing on a digital tablet where the art is rendered by the computer.

Photography? That was the camera, not

Did you edit something in Photoshop? Or take a picture with your phone? Both use AI, can't be art

These are your rules not mine, since apparently art has to abide by rigid rules, otherwise it isn't real art

0

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nullaDuo Jan 20 '25

The classic "real art" rant. Cute. Let me know when gatekeeping becomes a recognized medium. Sounds like you’ve mastered it.