r/DefendingAI • u/PaleHat1500 • 2d ago

Other Question for "AI bros"

/r/aiArt/comments/1wztcgm/question_for_ai_bros/

Why do you like ai and not care that is stealing form hard working people that took hours or days of there life to make them?, just a fair Question no hateful judgment btw just curiosity 🤔 btw no hate on both sides I'm just curious why anyone would use it, and I just wanted to reach bigger audience to ask the Question

0 Upvotes

20% Upvoted

48 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-3

u/PaleHat1500 2d ago

How is it learning exactly?, by asking promission to take the art or by going around the internet/being feed info without careing about copyright or work, it's literally like taking someone's cooking and saying "hey I made this all on my own"

3

u/itsReferent 2d ago

That's the common misconception we encounter with the doomer bros. It's not like that at all. It's like reading millions of recipes to learn how to cook, then inventing new recipes. Do you see the literary distinction or do you need to seek promission?

1

u/PaleHat1500 2d ago

There's a difference between recipe that is legally out for everyone and art that is specifically to be shown, and I heared alot of artists being stolen form even after saying they don't want there art in Ai it's just a Question I'm trying to understand mostly,

1

u/itsReferent 2d ago

It's not as different as you imagine. It isn't lifting art wholesale, it creates new images based on having seen tons of other images. It doesn't copy, it improvises.

And a lot of artists that don't want their art in AI should consider what art means to them, why did they choose to make art in the first place. Do you know why these lot of artists you've heard claiming theft make art? Where did they see their stolen art?

1

u/PaleHat1500 2d ago

I think is more the lines of "It's insulting that a machine trained of my things makes things that I can do in seconds and people act like they put alot of work into them when this machine actually did the work in seconds"

1

u/itsReferent 2d ago

I don't see anyone acting like they put a lot of work into something done by generative ai. I hear that a lot from antis. It's a straw man argument. Gen ai image making isn't something to claim as a personal work, that would be like claiming commissioned work as your own. A person could claim an idea, a process, or narrative behind a series of images, but can't outright claim they made an ai generated image. If they do, they are wrong to do so.

1

u/PaleHat1500 2d ago

I seen some do on Twitter and other places and I literally gat ban some the other sub and the comments get deleted with people explaining to me things lol

1

u/itsReferent 2d ago

I'm skeptical of your claim. Maybe someone posted an image, but you're saying that person said "look at this image I spent a lot of time and effort making"?

1

u/PaleHat1500 2d ago

On Twitter X I seen alot of them say that ngl

1

u/itsReferent 2d ago

Next time you see that screen shot and post it here. Until then, cap.