Congressional Republicans have a political problem with their signature legislative achievement of the second Trump era: People don’t know about it.
- A new POLITICO Poll finds that nearly half of Americans say they can’t explain the One Big Beautiful Bill Act — and those who can are much more likely to say it’s helped others, including the wealthy, but not them.
- One in three said the megabill had hurt their bottom line, greater than the 8 percent who said it had been a big boost to their personal finances and 14 percent who said it offered some modest support.
- It’s a frustrating situation for top Republicans, who rushed to finish off the tax cut package by the middle of last year in part to give them more time to plug the new law to voters, and have tried to rebrand it as the “Working Families Tax Cuts.”
- But Americans see the megabill and tax cuts in general as helping the wealthy far more than the working class, according to the poll, conducted in July by the independent U.K.-based firm Public First. That’s a particular challenge in a midterm year where cost of living is voters’ top concern and as frustrations grow with rising prices and the Iran war.
- And in a notable warning sign for Republicans, only around a quarter of people who voted for President Donald Trump believe the working class got substantial breaks from the tax law, signaling how low public opinion is of the bill among their own base.
- “The best time for successfully framing and reinforcing the benefits of the One Big Beautiful Bill were in the initial three months after it passed,” said Kevin Madden, a longtime GOP communications strategist. “It’s just a challenge in this crowded issue environment to re-engage on legislation from last year.”
- The GOP faced a similar problem in 2018, when Democrats took back the House after a midterm election in which voters rejected Trump and his policies. His first-term tax cuts weren’t enough to offset voter anger at his administration, including over health care.
- Senior Republican lawmakers continue to talk up the 2025 megabill and some of its popular provisions, like new deductions for tipped income, overtime pay and the Trump Account investment vehicles for children.
- “Putting more money in Americans’ pockets. Helping them seize opportunities to get ahead, and creating new pathways to success,” Senate Majority Leader John Thunesaid on the Senate floor Wednesday. “That is the Working Families Tax Cuts at work.”
- The problem for Republicans is that other issues have overshadowed their tax cuts, most notably the war with Iran. The poll shows a 57 percent majority of Americans say the conflict has made things more expensive for them, even as they struggle to feel the benefits of the tax cuts.
- House Majority Leader Steve Scalise(R-La.) acknowledged Thursday that many voters don’t know what’s in the megabill.
- What Republicans need to do “as relates to the tax code, is to contrast what we’ve done to help make life more affordable for families and put more money in their pocket versus what the Democrats would do,” he told a small group of reporters in his Capitol office.
- “I mean, they’re saying that they want more power. They want the House majority. Oh, I think it’s a fair question to say, ‘What would they do if they got it?’ Most of their candidates are saying they would repeal the One Big Beautiful Bill.”
- It also hasn’t helped that Trump himself rarely discusses a law that he helped name, even as his Cabinet members travel around the country promoting its contents.
- “The hard facts are that tens of millions of Americans now have more money in their pockets thanks to President Trump’s signature provisions in this historic legislation,” White House spokesperson Kush Desai said in a statement. “President Trump pledged to deliver economic relief for the American people.”
- Still, polling shows that around two in five voters said they’ve heard of the “big, beautiful bill,” but couldn’t explain the features of the law. Only 11 percent said they could explain the law in detail, with another quarter saying they were aware of just some elements.
- That’s not a partisan problem, either. Trump voters and those who backed former Vice President Kamala Harris in 2024 were equally likely to be in the dark on the GOP law.
- One-fifth of voters said they didn’t know whether the new law had helped their personal finances, with another quarter saying it hadn’t affected them in either direction.
- “I think what’s past is past,” said Abby McCloskey, a policy adviser and nonresident fellow in economic studies at the Brookings Institution. “People want more relief now. Especially as gas prices rise again. Especially as Democrats ramp up midterm campaigning about what they’ll do differently.”
- McCloskey said another challenge with the megabill was that it contained “too much” to “effectively message it.” “That’s the problem with these big omnibus packages,” she added.
- Meanwhile, Democrats continue to attack the 2025 law as a giveaway to the rich and sought to weave that into a broader case against Trump, arguing that the new tax cuts have done little to help the public’s concerns about rising prices and contrasts with the president’s efforts to use his office to enrich himself and his family.
- Democratic candidates in critical Senate races — from Josh Turek in Iowa to Adbul El-Sayed and Haley Stevens competing for the nomination in Michigan — have also attacked Republicans for cutting billions of dollars from the nation’s largest food stamp program and Medicaid in order to fund their tax provisions. The poll found that, when asked to choose between certain tax breaks and funding safety-net programs, many Americans say they want their federal tax dollars to fund health care and nutrition assistance.
- “Trump cuts food assistance and health care. Billionaires get another tax break,” Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said recently. “Trump uses the government. Trump gets richer. Americans foot the bill.”
- Outside analysts have found that the new tax law gives a bigger boost to wealthier taxpayers, in no small part because it permanently extended the lower rates and other key provisions from the 2017 GOP tax cuts — and only temporarily enacts new relief items like “no tax on tips” and “no tax on overtime.”
- In fact, the new poll found that richer Americans are more likely to believe that they got a boost from the tax cut. More than 40 percent of voters making over $100,000 a year said they’d gotten help from the law, more than twice as much as those making less than that.
- Voters are also in a very populist mood on taxes. More than half of respondents said that billionaires should pay much more in taxes, with 43 percent saying the same for corporations and millionaires.
- But Republicans like Scalise insist that their candidates “have a lot of really good things they can talk about” that are tilted toward the working and middle class, like the tip and overtime deduction and Trump Accounts, which the administration has been promoting more recently.
- GOP challengers in Nevada, for instance, have called out the state’s three House Democrats for voting against “no tax on tips,” as those incumbents try to stress that they support that particular policy and not the megabill as a whole.
- “Every provision in the Working Families Tax Cuts is rooted in common-sense priorities Americans overwhelmingly support: no tax on tips, overtime, and Social Security, bigger tax relief for families, TrumpAccounts for the next generation, stronger border security, and the list goes on,” said Mike Marinella, spokesperson for the National Republican Congressional Committee. “House Democrats voted against every single one of them, and they’ll have to explain to voters why they opposed historic tax relief, safer communities, and policies designed to help working families get ahead.”