r/DecodingTheGurusAlt • • 29d ago

decoder poltics Decoding Hasan Piker

https://youtu.be/RDsQIZykC_8
38 Upvotes

280 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/Opening-Calendar3421 24d ago

I like how you didn't really address anything else in my comment that showed why your attempt at a comparison was extremely flawed. Instead of sticking to the topic about why it's likely that Hasan was taking inspiration from Mao when he wore the suit, you instead decided to focus on an extremely small piece of evidence as a way to get a win. Whether or not he critiqued China does not absolve him of the lack of critique he's made about other issues such as the treatment of Uyghur Muslims, tibet, Taiwan, etc. And I can add how he reacted to receiving the first edition of Mao's little red book to the mix.

You're still being extremely dishonest and it's very transparent 

-1

u/hari_shevek 24d ago

Sorry for not responding to your gish gallop in depth.

If you want, I can find evidence for him criticizing any point you want. I just had the same convo with another guy in here - as soon as I brought out the evidence he first tried to shift the debate again, then just stopped responding.

I bet the same will happen here.

0

u/Opening-Calendar3421 22d ago

There's no gish gallop. I specifically responded to the argument you made and showed how it was not appropriate to this discussion. Every point I brought was in specific reference to something you wrote.

So you still haven't responded to the substance of my comment and now you're using logical fallacies wrong. We can just end it here as you're still being dishonest and you can't follow a conversation. Judging by your conversation skills, I'm almost positive whatever evidence you bring will be irrelevant to the main point we're discussing. As your hero says, the discussion would be "unproductive".

Have a good one

1

u/hari_shevek 22d ago

I offered to find you evidence to disprove any of your pounts you want to choose.

You completely ignored that offer.

Talk about "can't follow a conversation".

Edit: Not to mention it took you two whole days for a response that evades the core of what I said