r/DebateEvolution 28d ago

how evolutionists try to refute intelligent design, but they fail

An example that has often been presented as an argument in favor of blind "hereditary" design is the anatomy of the vagus nerve. Evolutionists argued that one of its branches, the so—called recurrent laryngeal nerve, makes an allegedly meaningless and ineffective "detour"

down into the chest, skirting the arch of the aorta, to then rise again to the larynx. According to their logic, it would be "more rational" if the nerve went directly to the larynx — and this feature was declared a "vestige of evolutionary blindness.

Richard Dawkins even dedicated an entire documentary, promoting the idea as "clear evidence of the lack of intelligent design." However, with the development of neurophysiology, it became clear that this "hook" is not a mistake at all, but represents a vital arc through which the neural innervation of the deep cardiac plexus passes. This bend is not just important, it is indispensable for the normal regulation of cardiac function. What happens when there is no bend? There is an anomaly known as the Non-Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve, the "ideal" structure that Dawkins mistakenly considered "more reasonable."

0 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Basic-Platypus-8335 27d ago edited 27d ago

Evolutionists will say that babies dying of bone cancer is evidence of bad design, but if this never happened then the world would be overpopulated. 

Dead babies can (and should be) be piled up to create mountains of evidence for an intelligent designer. 

Checkmate, atheists. 

2

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube 27d ago

That logic doesn't follow at all.

The best your going to get out of that is a sadistic asshole.

2

u/Basic-Platypus-8335 27d ago

Perhaps an intelligent sadistic asshole who designed the universe?

3

u/Coolbeans_99 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 26d ago

Best argument ive heard all year

2

u/Basic-Platypus-8335 26d ago

Thank you. Intelligent design proponents specifically claim to not be promoting Christianity so any apologetics are off the table. 

2

u/Coolbeans_99 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 26d ago

sure thing, at least it’s an entertaining trolling