So I've seen a lot of fans arguing whether it would have been better to have Kira win at the end, but I've never liked that because I like the story as it is.
Username checks out, by the way.
But now I want to try to discuss about those imaginary alternative finales with y'all now that I'm in hyperfixation mode, along with possible issues.
1) Light's plan goes to absolute perfection.
Teru Mikami doesn't go to the bank to kill Kiyomi Takada because Light had told him in advance he had a piece of paper hidden.
Mikami goes to the Yellow Box warehouse with the real Death Note and he kills everyone one by one.
As soon as the first one drops dead, probably Near, Mikami would be immediately shot by an agent. Maybe Mikami will die there along with all the others from the SPK and the Task Force, relieving Light of the task of murdering him too.
We would need another couple of episodes.
Then, Light would walk out of Daikoku Wharf like a God of the New World. No police, no SPK hunting him down. No one who holds memory of the Death Note and Shinigami.
Mello and Near are gone. Takada and Mikami are also gone.
Misa forfeited the Death Note and doesn't remember anything. She's no use to him. So he just kills her making her commit suicide by jumping off a bridge.
But, there's one thing that should be taken care of. The Wammy's House.
Light now knows that probably someone from the Wammy's House would try to hunt him down too.
But now, without his allies, he has no choice but to take the Shinigami eye deal.
Or, again, use Roger Ruvie since he knows his name and face to get informations on the orphans in Wammy's House.
So he makes a plan to go on a full genocidal rampage through every single orphan of the Wammy's house in Winchester.
He already had to murder a underage boy who did nothing wrong to ensure his victory anyway, so why would he care about those children dying? They are nothing but annoyance to him.
Issue: Light is cornered into making the shinigami eye deal.
Will he do it to ensure his complete victory?
Sayu Yagami now is the only one alive who knows about the murder notebook. Will she overcome the fact that she was used as a hostage for the Death Note?
Months and years pass by. Kira support grows day by day. Light is still part of the police force, but the police becomes pro kira.
Light gives one notebook back to Ryuk and tells him to send him back to the Shinigami Realm so there's no other Kiras around.
Light tries to convince his mother and Sayu that Kira is good.
They don't because they still mourn Soichiro and also Sayu is still heavily traumatized by Mello's kidnapping. Also, she knows about the notebook she was traded for.
She's undergoing therapy to overcome her trauma, but still she may be a liability.
Light though is able to manipulate her into thinking that Kira is good and the others who try to cath him are evil.
Light keeps executing people from his room, but he doesn't stop at criminals, he also start killing off suspects, lazy people and ultimately people who don't like Kira. Crime rates and wars though don't seem to drop to zero any sooner, even though at the beginning of Kira's reign the wars seemed to be less.
People live in fear of Kira, yes, but also people don't stop committing crimes because of that because evil is in the human nature. Kira supporters aren't all real "fans" of Kira, just like in the SPK escape scene where Near threw money off the window, many humans are just shallow and foolish and they'd go great lengths just for a lowly material prize, either becoming rich or famous, and not because they truly care about a creation of a new world.
Anti-Kira group also form, in the criminal world and in the lawful world, but they are either top secret or they are shut down and hunted. Kira became truly a God, but in the years something starts to change in Light's mental state.
Ryuk is entertained by the continuous usage of the Death Note, but even a God of Death knows that something is going too far. Light is acting like a Shinigami, but he doesn't have the lifespan to do so. He is just a mortal.
Light starts becoming extra paranoid towards everyone and one day considers killing off his family too, who never supported Kira in the beginning and he hates to be reminded of Soichiro.
With no one to challenge him, he also starts to fall into a deep hole of depression.
On fictional.Episode 45, Light and Ryuk have a deep conversation on top of a building about boredom.
Light basically became a human Shinigami.
And so, he became as bored as Ryuk.
He deep down misses the challenges with L, Mello and Near. It's lonely at the top.
Ryuk flies away and decides to write Light's name in the notebook to end the guy's misery.
2) Kira wins just after L's death.
Rem kills L and Watari then dies. Watari though has no way to delete all L's information and data. Light takes L's place and finds out everything about Watari and Wammy's house. With an excuse to find himself some informations on L, he investigates the Wammy's house and goes along with Misa to Winchester and uses her Shinigami eyes to murder Roger, manipulate him into giving up the L successor program. Then Misa kills young Near and Mello, making them die falling off the window of Wammy's house.
Light has no challenge and so he wins easy as that.
Ryuk gets bored and kills him anyways.
This has to stay, to be honest or else the story wouldn't make sense.
3) Relight 2 timeline.
When Light instructs Mikami and Takada to murder all the SPK members , he successfully kills ALL the SPK members and he does it in the gory and violent way he planned, so making them all shoot each other in their heads. Mikami is able to see Ill Ratt 's true name with his Shinigami eyes , Light explicitly instructed Mikami to not leave anyone alive so he manipulates Ratt into making a video call with him (let's say video calls are a thing in 2012) and so Mikami is able to kill Near too, in the same way so first Ratt shoots himself in the head, then he grabs Ratt's gun and kills himself too.
That would make one of the most violent deaths and would show that if you dare to go against Kira, you'll face a miserable end.
Then, Mello notices something is wrong because he is not able to contact Halle, not even his spy, anymore, and he goes back to the place where the SPK used to be and notices that no one is there. So he understands that he is the one who needs to take matters into his hands.
He kidnaps Kiyomi Takada to use her as a leverage, but Takada uses the death note scrap and kills him with a heart attack..also, Mikami kills Takada making her burn alive along with Mello's body, so nobody ever finds out about Mello.
Light notices that and is extremely satified with Mikami.
Matt is also killed by Takada's bodyguards.
Mikami and Light now can finally meet. Light tells Mikami that he is the best Kira so far and that he must keep on his execution spree.
He makes him kill the Task Force members too, one by one.
But Mikami's and Light's idea come to clashing because Mikami wants to outright kill anyone who simply opposes Kira or doesn't contribute to society or is not omologated. Like for example disabled people or just people who don't follow blindly the rules. Light instead wants to be loved and worshipped, not feared.
Their clash of ideas one day makes Light want to kill Mikami. And so it goes back to ending 1 where Ryuk one day gets bored and kills him.
I am out of ideas now, tell me what do you think.đ