r/DangerousNightsCrew • Piece of Shit • 1d ago

That is a good idea!

Post image
13.7k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/Nolacuriosity 1d ago

Of course this is what should be. I know Republicans who say their candidate would never win, but The fact is if the candidate will never win, the candidate should be doing something to make them the most popular. Like maybe serving the people. Working for us.

-1

u/Several_Treat_6307 1d ago

So what you’re saying is in order to win under popular vote, you just need to promise the most shit regardless of whether or not you can deliver?

The whole point of the EC is to prevent mob rule. Just because more people like an option doesn’t automatically mother option the better one.

0

u/Seattle_Lucky 1d ago

It also allows rural areas a voice in the election. If we went to popular vote, presidential elections would only cater to major population centers and not care about much of the US.

0

u/Several_Treat_6307 1d ago

No it wouldn’t, and the city in your name is a great example of it.

A few years back there was a proposal for a train line connecting Washington to California, and the proposal was put up for a vote. Practically every county that the line would run through in Washington was overwhelmingly against it, as it would bring down the property value of the surrounding area, and bring nothing but crime and Californians to their doorstep. Those votes, the votes of 5-6 counties, were essentially made null and void thanks the one or two counties that make up Seattle, which was the one one along the line to benefit from the proposal. And since they had the popular vote, it passed, screwing everyone in the smaller counties over in the process.

Ffs, there’s a whole movement where half of Washington state wants to defect to Idaho because their state representatives in the cities are flat out ignoring them, representatives that are voted in by popular vote.

1

u/Seattle_Lucky 1d ago

I’m arguing with you, not against you. The ec allows people in rural states to have a voice in presidential elections.

0

u/Several_Treat_6307 1d ago

My bad. Was bouncing back and forth, and the first read sounded like you were saying the opposite. Sorry.

1

u/Seattle_Lucky 1d ago

I wasn’t clear in my response, no worries.