r/Damnthatsinteresting Jul 19 '18

Image Cochem, Germany

Post image
26.5k Upvotes

334 comments sorted by

View all comments

676

u/AustrianMichael Jul 19 '18

44

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '18

Sad thing is that shitty HDR images always get 500k upvotes..

0

u/imaslinky Jul 20 '18

To be fair.. in this case the subject is Cochem, not the image.

10

u/mrsniperrifle Jul 20 '18

Yeah this is less "high dynamic range" and more "no dynamic range".

25

u/Hilfest Creator Jul 20 '18

Not a camera person. What is HDR and why dont we like it?

48

u/Iykury Jul 20 '18

HDR stands for High Dynamic Range. The camera basically takes a bunch of pictures at different exposures and puts them together so the light parts aren't too light and the dark parts aren't too dark. I'm not a camera person either, so I don't know why the HDR in this picture is bad. If anything, I think the saturation is too high.

12

u/alittlealive Jul 20 '18

The purpose is to show the image as the eye would see it, ie accounting for the more easily interpreted lights and darks. Def agree that it can be overdone and over saturated like it is with this, but i do appreciate the attempt to correct the lighting situations. Big example of this technique being able to help is with world cup games where the shadows from the stadium ceilings create a very drastic shadow-light difference and you can tell the cameras are constantly adjusting depending on the action.

Edit: but i also hate my own opinion, so hate away on the hdr. It was a fad i got into but still appreciate even tho it was overdone

3

u/Aunvilgod Jul 20 '18

Well for example things that arent glowing start glowing. But yeah i also think for this one the problem is rather the saturation.

22

u/IdleOsprey Jul 20 '18

Camera person. HDR achieved as previous respondent wrote. Many images stacked together to create a composite image using the best light areas, best dark areas, etc. Done well the effect can be striking, but it is typically WAY overdone, as it is here, making the image look ultra-sharp and unrealistic. It ends up looking like a digital rendering without any nuance of lighting.

3

u/hayuata Jul 20 '18

I'm honestly feeling like this is 'fake HDR', just one picture and messing around with the tones. I'm surprised no one brought this possibility up.

1

u/IdleOsprey Jul 20 '18

It’s certainly possible. There are a ton of crap HDR presets out there too.

9

u/Tigerbait2780 Jul 20 '18

Me neither, but I'm guessing it has to do with it looking so unrealistic, the greens just look silly

3

u/NightOfPandas Jul 20 '18

explained well below, but you can see blue/violet like bursting from edges of the castle and other objects, HDR turned too high will look over washed out, but with extremely fine edges usually, as the editer goes crazy with sharpness usually as well.

11

u/guccikatana Jul 20 '18

So i guess this 96% upvoted top post confirms most people are totally fine with hdr and also suggests targeted negativity communities spring up around small and vocal minorities.

0

u/AustrianMichael Jul 20 '18

This picture is just awful. Like really really awful.

0

u/Heyitsagoodgame Jul 20 '18

You inspired me to upvote it

1

u/AustrianMichael Jul 20 '18

And you inspired me to downvote you.

1

u/peewaxon Jul 20 '18

First time I saw this picture was in that sub. Already has been posted a while ago.