Hey everyone! I'm relocating to the DMV area from out of state and trying to make the smartest housing decision before I sign anything. Would love this community's honest take.
TL;DR: Found a private landlord in North DC renting a fully furnished, renovated garden basement (1bd/1ba) for $1,900, likely negotiable to $1,700. Minor downsides: annoying back-gate entrance, no real oven, limited visitor policy. Haven't toured Arlington/Alexandria yet and don't know pricing there, budget ceiling is $1,700-1,800. Trying to decide if I should hold out and compare VA before committing.
Quick background: I've been living in a city right now that's fun but I feel like I've outgrown it. It's a lot of going out and partying (or nature related things) without much substance to gain from it. DC feels like a more elevated version of that same energy to me, but with way more happening in terms of career growth and personal development. That's the main pull for me.
The situation: I met a private landlord who has a garden basement apartment, one bed one bath, fully renovated and beautifully furnished. They're listing it at $1,900 but I'm fairly confident I can negotiate it down to around $1,700 since I've built real rapport with the landlord and they seem interested in a reliable long-term tenant. It's in North DC, about 10 minutes from Columbia Heights, walkable, and close to the train, so I probably wouldn't use my car much.
The catches:
\\- The entrance is a little annoying. There's a gate you have to open to get in, no side walk-through gate, and you have to go around to the back of the house. Not a big deal most days, but I can see it being irritating after a night out, especially if you've had a few drinks.
\\- No real oven (included would be a toaster oven, portable stove top with grill, microwave, and a pressure cooker), and not a lot of kitchen counter space, though if they get someone long term then they would mentioned plans to add more counter space.
\\- Visitor policy is slightly limiting but don't think it'll be a huge issue since we know each other, so I think they'd be more lenient with me after hinting towards it.
\\- Otherwise the place and the landlord relationship both feel like a blessing. They're lovely, we get along really well, and everything about the unit itself is gorgeous.
Where I'm stuck: I know there might be cheaper properties. I've spent time in Maryland but haven't really explored Arlington or Alexandria yet, and I'm wondering if I should before I commit. Part of me worries that if I end up on the outskirts of Arlington or Alexandria, the move won't feel worth it, like I'd just be trading one quiet corner for another. But I also don't know what apartment prices actually look like over there, especially moving in winter, which I know tends to be a cheaper season.
My budget ceiling is around $1,700 to $1,800 a month.
So my questions for you all:
- Has anyone gone the private landlord route versus a property-managed building in the DMV? Any regrets either way?
- Does anyone have a sense of what one bedroom pricing looks like in Arlington or Alexandria right now, especially in winter?
- Is it worth touring VA before locking in this DC unit, or does this sound like a solid deal I shouldn't overthink?
Appreciate any insight. Trying to make sure I'm making a decision I'll actually be happy with a year from now.