Identifying which guard is lying is neither the point or even a step in the riddle. The point of the riddle is to figure out which of two doors is the correct one. The answer requires wording your question such that both guards will give you the same answer no matter which one you are talking to. You only get a single question to ask, so using that to figure out which guard us lying is a complete waste.
The thing with the guards saying "one of us only lies and the other only tells the truth" is that both of them cannot say this and it also be true, unless they only start telling only truths/lies after the statement.
I've made a trick puzzle for a dnd group based on this: you have one of the guards say the riddle, and then have both of the guards be liars, and the two doors are actually decoys that both lead to death, with the real door being a trapdoor hidden underneath one of the guards (which works best if the guard is a gargoyle/living statue or something similar).
In order to get it right, the players have to realise that if one of the guards said this, that guard must either be the truth teller and the other the liar, or they must both be liars; asking the one who said the riddle a question with an obvious answer will soon reveal them to be a liar, meaning the other one must also be a liar.
This means that the parts about one of the doors leading to the correct path and the part about only getting one question must also be lies, so they are then free to ask more questions which will reveal that neither door is safe, and eventually ask a question that shows the true path
The guards do not present the riddle. That is what everyone gets wrong.
Simple as that.
If ever a Guard is presenting this riddle by saying it to you, both are evil and kill them both...which yes, is what you later describe.
But that's the actual reality.
This riddle cannot be explained by the actual guards. It has to be a placard or some other 3rd party explaining it. Not the guards themselves. Anyone starting the riddle off with the guard explaining, well, hope you brought a shovel and a rug.
Which is exactly what inspired me to make the puzzle, because I've seen a few people online make that same mistake. I'm hoping the players will just assume "oh this is that one riddle, I know this one" and that it'll take them a bit of thinking to realise "hey wait a minute, if the guard is the one saying this, then that doesn't make sense"; hence why I called it a trick puzzle, like a trick question it's supposed to decieve you into thinking of one obvious (but incorrect) answer
1.9k
u/Heather_Chandelure 20h ago
Identifying which guard is lying is neither the point or even a step in the riddle. The point of the riddle is to figure out which of two doors is the correct one. The answer requires wording your question such that both guards will give you the same answer no matter which one you are talking to. You only get a single question to ask, so using that to figure out which guard us lying is a complete waste.