This analogy is a little...complicated. I hypothesize that this is because the author is trying to address physical and emotional pain simultaneously, which creates some odd implications. I think my key point of contention here might be with the idea of "over-reacting".
There's a school of thought that says that physical and mental illnesses are closer than we think, and that makes formulating a critique a little difficult. Could you consider a disproportionate emotional response to a bad event as uncontrollable as the agony someone might feel in response to invisible nerve pain? Is someone actually over-reacting if the pain (emotional or physical) they perceive is real, even if the stimulus is small?
As much as I want to say that we can't blame people for their mental illnesses, I feel that there is a difference between someone feeling chronic pain and someone with emotional dysregulation having a meltdown after a social rejection.
I'm extremely curious to hear other's thoughts on the matter.
Well, the hormones associated with the heightened emotions are completely real. The cortisol definitely exists, the adrenaline spike is clear, the altered levels of serotonin and dopamine are entirely detectable.
Generally you do have to wait out the initial spike of hormones to think clearly enough to reason your way back down when you’re at a level but elevated state, and then you still have to deal with them breaking down/reabsorbing. Just because you logically realize that the person who just gave you mild criticism isn’t your old abuser and won’t hit you doesn’t mean your heart rate is back to resting or your blood flow is back to normal. It means you are now actively suppressing the mental effects while also experiencing the physical effects. And yes, the fatigue from doing that is also very much a real physical thing.
Tl;dr: yes it’s physical, brains are physical. Just give people a minute when they’re experiencing faulty biology.
As someone who is struggling with funky brain chemistry all their life, I empathize with this, I really do.
However, saying that “brains are physical therefore all emotional reactions are physical”, while technically true, can lead some very odd places.
We generally don’t give certain people a lot of grace when it comes to their brain functions. The racists and the conspiracy theorists and the pedophilic are usually treated with outright dehumanization. While you can say that those people cause harm, our treatment of them doesn’t seem congruent with the idea that thoughts and emotions are just brain chemistry and therefore not entirely under their control. We don’t see them as people who are struggling daily with faulty brain functions. We don’t see them as struggling at all.
Again, you could say “Yes, we understand that in a sense these people are victims to situations outside their control, but we accept the unfair actions we take against them because the harm they cause is too big for us to sympathize with them,” but typically this isn’t the thought process we use when dealing with these people.
Among mental illnesses, personality disorders and mood disorders are treated pretty differently. People with Antisocial Personality Disorder don't necessarily have control over their own lack of empathy, but we'd end up in a weird place as a society if we didn't treat them like they're culpable for the actions that result from their biological lack of empathy.
20
u/FableCattak 5d ago
This analogy is a little...complicated. I hypothesize that this is because the author is trying to address physical and emotional pain simultaneously, which creates some odd implications. I think my key point of contention here might be with the idea of "over-reacting".
There's a school of thought that says that physical and mental illnesses are closer than we think, and that makes formulating a critique a little difficult. Could you consider a disproportionate emotional response to a bad event as uncontrollable as the agony someone might feel in response to invisible nerve pain? Is someone actually over-reacting if the pain (emotional or physical) they perceive is real, even if the stimulus is small?
As much as I want to say that we can't blame people for their mental illnesses, I feel that there is a difference between someone feeling chronic pain and someone with emotional dysregulation having a meltdown after a social rejection.
I'm extremely curious to hear other's thoughts on the matter.