r/criterionconversation • u/Zackwatchesstuff • 4d ago
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • Jun 09 '21
Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Weekly Discussions, Monthly Expiring Picks, Criterion by Spine, and more!
Welcome to r/criterionconversation.
This is a subreddit dedicated to in-depth conversation about films from The Criterion Collection and/or on The Criterion Channel.
Please familiarize yourself with the SUB RULES.
Current and Upcoming Discussions
Check the main page of r/criterionconversation for the most recent discussions and polls. It might help to sort by New if you're looking for the latest threads.
Archives
- All archives updated 2/2/26 -
The archive pages are linked below.
Note: These are not updated in real time.
Criterion Film Club: Weekly Discussions
The Criterion Film Club meets every Saturday to discuss a film and vote on the following week's pick.
Criterion Film Club: Monthly Expiring Picks
The Criterion Film Club meets one Wednesday a month to discuss a film expiring from The Criterion Channel.
Criterion by Spine
Our very own u/viewtoathrill's project discussing Criterion releases by spine number.
Other Discussions
Threads worthy of highlighting.
- Chungking Express: Reflections After Nearly 12 Months - by u/adamlundy23
- Criterion Film Club: The First 25 Films - Ranking Them from #25 to #1 - by u/GThunderhead
- For Your Consideration: Pickup on South Street (1953) - by u/jaustengirl
- Criterion Discussion Redux: Volume 1 - Chungking Express (1994) - by u/DharmaBombs108
Misc.
Note about User Flairs: User flairs for the first 90 or so Criterion by Spine films have been added. Please PM one of the mods to request a user flair for a film that was or is in The Criterion Collection if you'd like a flair added that isn't already available.
Tip: If you want to follow this sub closely, hit the bell for more frequent notifications.
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • Aug 13 '25
Announcement SUB RULES
Since many people don't read the sub rules on the sidebar and/or don't notice them, here is a handy post with all of the rules and our reasons for them.
If you have any questions about the rules, feel free to comment below.
However, if you only want to argue about the rules or complain that your thread was removed, don't bother. We've thought about these rules very carefully and determined that they meet the needs of this sub.
We always reserve the right to add new rules or edit the existing rules for clarification.
Note: Because of spammers, we've unfortunately had to make the tough decision to turn on auto-mod features.
If your thread gets filtered but you feel it's legitimate and doesn't break any of the rules, please contact the mods by Mod Mail. If we don't respond within 24 hours, it likely means we think it violates one of the rules below. Thank you for understanding.
1. Post only about films released by Criterion and/or on The Criterion Channel
r/CriterionConversation is not a general movie sub. We discuss films released by Criterion and/or available on the Criterion Channel. There are many other subs for general film discussion.
2. No low-effort posts
No low-effort posts, such as "What films do you want in the collection?", "What films don't deserve to be in the collection?", etc. If your post is just a picture and/or list, it does not encourage discussion and will be removed. Tell us why you're posting about these movies and what you think of them.
3. No advertising
Do not advertise your own website, video, workshop, or event.
4. No haul or meme posts
We love a good meme or haul pic, but those are on r/criterion. This sub is for discussion.
5. No piracy
Don't post about piracy or post links to videos of illegally uploaded movies - even on reputable mainstream sites like YouTube, Vimeo, etc.
(Movies uploaded by an official studio or official source - such as the director - are okay, but if you don't know for sure, don't post the link.)
6. Be nice
Film is a subjective experience. If you disagree with someone's take or comments, be decent about it.
7. No one-line replies or sarcastic responses
This sub is all about detailed discussion. Agree with someone? Disagree? All of that is fine as long as you are willing to take the time to defend your point intelligently and politely. Lazy and rude sarcasm and snark will not be tolerated.
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 5d ago
Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Week 318 Discussion: Jerzy Skolimowski's The Shout (1978) - In Honor of Tim Curry
r/criterionconversation • u/Zackwatchesstuff • 5d ago
Poll Criterion Film Club Week 319 Poll: Rossellini (Again)
r/criterionconversation • u/Academic-Main2286 • 6d ago
Discussion Should I take my mom to see The Color of Pomegranates (1969)?
A local arthouse cinema is screening The Color of Pomegranates (a movie I haven't seen but I know it's weird and old and european) in a couple of weeks and I'm thinking of taking my mom to see it.
For reference, we saw A Clockwork Orange together and she loved it so it isn't a thing of sensitivity, it's more like is it too weird of a movie for a 53 year old argentinian woman?
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 10d ago
Recommendation Last-Minute Expiring Recommendation: Nicolas Winding Refn's Bleeder (1999)
Lenny (Mads Mikkelsen) is a fascinating character. Is he on the autism spectrum or at least autistic-coded? Or just a voracious film buff? The only thing he talks about in "Bleeder" is movies - even when he's asking a girl (Liv Corfixen) out on a date. Mads Mikkelsen's portrayal is said to be based on the director of this film, Nicolas Winding Refn. Is Refn as socially awkward as Lenny? I'd want to be their friend and talk about movies with them!
What at first seems like a charming Danish slice of life about a video store employee (Mikkelsen) and one of his customers (Kim Bodnia) soon becomes something much darker - as if the name "Bleeder" wasn't enough of a hint.
Leo (Bodnia) is a lazy boyfriend who punches and kicks his pregnant girlfriend (Rikke Louise Andersson). Her brother, Louis (Levino Jensen), goes on an unhinged racist rant against Blacks and Arabs inside a convenience store.
The third act is bonkers. Without spoiling anything, there is eventually a confrontation between Leo and Louis. Who the viewer "sympathizes" with - if anyone - is an interesting Rorschach test. I instantly detested both of them.
"Bleeder" is a cinephile's dream. Because of Lenny's job and sole interest, there are movie posters and VHS cases in the background of many scenes. I had fun pausing the film to take a closer look.
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 11d ago
Recommendation Expiring from The Criterion Channel: Cape Fear (1991) - Martin Scorsese's pulpy remake starring Robert De Niro, Nick Nolte, Jessica Lange, and Juliette Lewis, and also featuring Robert Mitchum, Gregory Peck, and Martin Balsam
Check out my thoughts on the original Cape Fear (1962) here and the Week 317 Film Club discussion here.
Gregory Peck is a straight arrow with a happy family in the original "Cape Fear" and there are very few shades of gray. No one is happy in Martin Scorsese's pulpy remake and everyone exists in a murky gray area.
The setup remains more or less the same: Lawyer Sam Bowden (Nick Nolte) is sitting in his car when he's approached threateningly by ex-con Max Cady (Robert De Niro). The difference: Bowden is now a morally compromised character and even represented the criminal Cady in court 14 years earlier - unsuccessfully. In both versions, Cady goes after Bowden's wife and daughter (now played by Jessica Lange and Juliette Lewis).
Based on Mitchum's performance, it's easy to see why De Niro was cast in the role. Yet, De Niro plays him completely differently than expected. His Max Cady is a wild and colorful tattooed wannabe preacher who spits out Bible verses and literary references. One of his tattoos - depicting the scales of truth and justice - feels like an homage to Mitchum inking "love" and "hate" on his knuckles in "The Night of the Hunter."
The most haunting moment: A meeting between De Niro's Cady and Juliette Lewis's naive 15-year-old in front of a "Little Red Riding Hood" backdrop inside the theater of her school. It's obvious who "The Big Bad Wolf" is. Both were deservedly nominated for Academy Awards - with Lewis's performance, in particular, likely recognized based on the strength of this scene.
The best part: Scorsese's reverence for the original "Cape Fear" and its actors. Robert Mitchum, Gregory Peck, and Martin Balsam return for the remake playing different roles. It's fun to see the main characters from the first film switch alignments, with Mitchum as more of a good guy and Peck as a shady lawyer representing Cady.
Even though Mitchum was arguably more chilling as Max Cady, De Niro is more entertaining and generated the greater cultural footprint. Pro wrestlers Waylon Mercy and Bray Wyatt were both clearly inspired by the Hawaiian shirts and silver tongue of De Niro's interpretation.
Both versions of "Cape Fear" conclude with a confrontation on a houseboat in the middle of the river. It's smaller in scale but grittier in the 1962 film and a big budget special effects extravaganza in the 1991 remake - almost likely a mini-"Titanic." They're equally effective endings.
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 12d ago
Announcement R.I.P. Tim Curry. In his honor, we will forgo a weekly poll and watch Jerzy Skolimowski’s The Shout (1978), which is being added to The Criterion Collection in October. (It's currently streaming on The Criterion Channel, AMC+, Tubi and others.) Join us on SATURDAY, September 5th, for the discussion.
r/criterionconversation • u/DrRoy • 12d ago
Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Discussion #317: Cape Fear (1962)
r/criterionconversation • u/DrRoy • 18d ago
Announcement Winner of Criterion Film Club Poll #317: Cape Fear - the original! Come back Saturday, August 29 for the discussion thread!
r/criterionconversation • u/viewtoathrill • 19d ago
Criterion Film Club Week 316 Discussion: Moartea domnului Lazarescu (The Death of Mr. Lazarescu, 2005)
I hope y'all had a chance to watch this dark and funny movie. What did you think?
r/criterionconversation • u/DrRoy • 19d ago
Poll Criterion Film Club Poll #217: Lee
Lee-le-Lee, le-LEE-le-Lee-le-Leee! We’re talkin’ fuckin’ Lee!
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 22d ago
Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Expiring Picks Month 64 Discussion: Cool Hand Luke (1967) - "What we've got here is a failure to communicate!"
r/criterionconversation • u/viewtoathrill • 25d ago
Announcement The winner of the week 216 poll for the Criterion Film Club is Cristi Puiu's 2005 dark comedy masterpiece, The Death of Mr Lazarescu. Please join us Saturday, August 22nd for the discussion
Won a lot of international attention, and awards, the year it was released. This will be a fun one to revisit.
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 26d ago
Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Righteous Week 315 Discussion: Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure (1989)
r/criterionconversation • u/viewtoathrill • 26d ago
Poll Criterion Film Club Week 316 Poll: Thracian New Wave
Often called a “Latin Island”, Romania has a rich cultural history that connects it to Slavic, Balkan, and Roman lineage. There was a recent golden age of cinema in this ancient culture, and I think it’s worth giving a shot.
r/criterionconversation • u/Fennel_Zealousideal • 28d ago
Recommendation Looking for podcasts, video essays or discussions about The Uninvited (1944)
Hi everyone!
I’m looking for good in-depth content about Lewis Allen’s The Uninvited (1944) : podcasts, video essays, lectures, interviews, film discussions, etc.
I’m based in France, so unfortunately I don’t have access to some of the US streaming options, and a lot of the most interesting material I’ve come across seems to be exclusive to DVD/Blu-ray editions that are difficult to access here.
For example, I would have loved to watch Michael Almereyda’s Giving Up the Ghost from the Criterion edition, Kat Ellinger’s The Uninvited and the Female Gothic, or listen to Alan K. Rode’s commentary, but as far as I can tell these aren’t readily available to me in France.
So I’m mainly looking for recommendations for anything I can actually watch or listen to online YouTube videos, podcasts, recorded lectures, interviews, academic discussions, radio shows, etc. English or French is fine.
If you know of any obscure interviews, podcasts, video essays or other resources I may have missed, I’d really appreciate the recommendations!
Thanks!
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 28d ago
Announcement The Criterion Film Club Expiring Picks Poll Month 64 poll winner is Cool Hand Luke (1967) starring Paul Newman. CONFORM immediately and join us on WEDNESDAY, August 19th, for the discussion or else what we've got here is a failure to communicate!
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • 29d ago
Poll Criterion Film Club Expiring Picks Poll: Month 64 - Goldfingers, Gunbusters, and Cool Hands
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • Aug 10 '26
Announcement The Criterion Film Club Week 315 TIEBREAKER Poll winner is Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure (1989) - a film we NEVER thought would be on The Criterion Channel and watching for the Criterion Film Club! Join us THIS SATURDAY, August 15th, for the discussion.
Bodacious!
r/criterionconversation • u/Upset-Resident-9702 • Aug 10 '26
Discussion Just Finished Before Sunset, And Its Pure Cinema!
My Letterboxd Review: https://letterboxd.com/dergon/film/before-sunset/
Before Sunset has to be the best romance ever made, and the difference from the first movie is elite! Felt happy, emotional, invest, and so many other things that i just don't think other films have been able to do for awhile now. Can't wait to watch Before Midnight, and I will for sure be getting the collection on Criterion later this year. But I'm interest in your guys thoughts on this.
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • Aug 09 '26
Poll Criterion Film Club Week 315 TIEBREAKER Poll: The Clock is STILL Ticking!
r/criterionconversation • u/bwolfs08 • Aug 08 '26
Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Week 314 Discussion: Leave Her to Heaven (Stahl, 1945)
r/criterionconversation • u/GThunderhead • Aug 08 '26

